	Current Plan $0/month Free Get Started	Pastor $30_{per month}	Team $75_{per month}
Sermons per month	4	5	20
Clips per sermon	2	8	20
Admins that can edit sermon pages and sermon clips		1	5
Sermons automatically pulled from Youtube and emailed to you		by Mon morning	on Sundays
Ability to delete sermons
AI Assistant's website training depth	NA	Crawls your homepage and all pages linked from it	Crawls your homepage and pages up to two links deep
AI Assistant's youTube Sermon Training	NA	Sermons from the past 12 months	Sermons from the past 24 months
Max length of videos	1.5 hours	2.5 hours	4 hours
Customer support		Email	Chat + Zoom calls

Distinguishing Shame from Guilt

by Desiring God
on Apr 07, 2025

If you are an admin of Desiring God, log in to make edits below, and your changes will appear on this shareable page

Distinguishing Shame from Guilt

Devotional

Day 1: Guilt as a Moral and Legal Condition

Guilt, from a biblical perspective, is not merely an emotional response but a moral and legal condition that signifies deserving punishment for actual wrongdoing. It is a status before the law of God or man, independent of personal feelings. This understanding challenges the common therapeutic definition of guilt as simply a feeling of regret for one's actions. Instead, it emphasizes the objective reality of guilt as a condition that exists regardless of whether one feels guilty or not. Recognizing this helps individuals align their conscience with biblical truths, ensuring they feel guilt appropriately when they have truly erred. [02:56]

"For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it." (James 2:10, ESV)

Reflection: Consider a time when you felt guilty. Was it based on actual wrongdoing or merely a feeling? How can you align your understanding of guilt with biblical truths today?

Day 2: The Broader Understanding of Shame

Shame, according to the Bible, is a painful emotion of disgrace or humiliation caused by wrongdoing or impropriety, often influenced by others' perceptions. However, the Bible expands this concept to include behaviors or conditions that should cause such emotions, even if they do not. This broader understanding helps individuals discern when shame is appropriate and when it is not. It encourages a deeper reflection on the nature of shame and its rightful place in one's spiritual life, allowing for a more accurate alignment with biblical teachings. [04:46]

"Then I shall not be put to shame, having my eyes fixed on all your commandments." (Psalm 119:6, ESV)

Reflection: Reflect on a situation where you felt shame. Was it due to actual wrongdoing or external perceptions? How can you discern the appropriateness of shame in your life today?

Day 3: Distinguishing True and False Guilt

True guilt arises from genuine wrongdoing, while false guilt occurs when one feels guilty without having done wrong. A healthy conscience, aligned with God's word, helps individuals discern these feelings accurately, ensuring they do not carry unnecessary burdens. This distinction is crucial for spiritual well-being, as it prevents the weight of false guilt from hindering one's relationship with God and others. By understanding and applying this distinction, individuals can live more freely and in accordance with biblical principles. [06:39]

"For whenever our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart, and he knows everything." (1 John 3:20, ESV)

Reflection: Identify an area in your life where you might be experiencing false guilt. How can you seek God's truth to release this burden today?

Day 4: Recognizing True and False Shame

True shame is appropriate when one's actions are genuinely disgraceful, while false shame arises from situations where no wrongdoing has occurred. Understanding this distinction helps individuals avoid unnecessary embarrassment and focus on living uprightly. It encourages a deeper examination of one's actions and the motivations behind feelings of shame, promoting a healthier spiritual life that is aligned with biblical teachings. [08:40]

"Instead of your shame there shall be a double portion; instead of dishonor they shall rejoice in their lot; therefore in their land they shall possess a double portion; they shall have everlasting joy." (Isaiah 61:7, ESV)

Reflection: Think of a recent experience where you felt shame. Was it justified? How can you differentiate between true and false shame in your life today?

Day 5: Recalibrating the Conscience

Our consciences can sometimes mislead us, requiring recalibration according to biblical truths. By aligning our conscience with God's word, we ensure that our feelings of guilt and shame are appropriate and not based on false premises. This recalibration is essential for spiritual growth, as it allows individuals to navigate their emotions in a way that is consistent with their faith, leading to a more authentic and fulfilling relationship with God. [07:29]

"I will instruct you and teach you in the way you should go; I will counsel you with my eye upon you." (Psalm 32:8, ESV)

Reflection: Reflect on how your conscience has guided you recently. Are there areas where it needs recalibration according to biblical truths? How can you seek God's guidance in this process today?

Sermon Summary

In today's discussion, we delved into the intricate concepts of guilt and shame, exploring their definitions and distinctions from a biblical perspective. The conversation was sparked by questions from author Scott Christensen, who is working on a project about true and false shame and guilt. We began by examining the common definitions of these terms in psychotherapy, which often differentiate guilt as a feeling of regret for one's actions and shame as a painful feeling about oneself. However, I emphasized that these definitions do not align with biblical teachings.

From a biblical standpoint, guilt is not merely a feeling but a moral and legal condition of deserving punishment for real wrongdoing. It is a status before the law of God or man, independent of one's feelings. Shame, on the other hand, is a painful emotion of disgrace or humiliation caused by wrongdoing or impropriety, often influenced by the perception of others. The Bible expands the concept of shame to include behaviors or conditions that should cause such emotions, even if they do not.

We also discussed the concepts of true and false guilt and shame. True guilt arises when one has genuinely violated God's law or just human laws, while false guilt occurs when one feels guilty without having done wrong. Similarly, true shame is appropriate when one's actions are genuinely disgraceful, while false shame arises from situations where no wrongdoing has occurred, such as honest mistakes or unmet expectations.

The role of conscience is crucial in discerning these feelings. A healthy conscience aligns with God's word, helping us feel guilt or shame appropriately. However, our consciences can sometimes mislead us, requiring recalibration according to biblical truths. Importantly, when God forgives us through Christ, we should not continue to feel guilty, as our wrongs have been covered and punished.

In conclusion, understanding these distinctions helps us navigate our emotions and align them with biblical truths, fostering a healthier spiritual life.

Key Takeaways

1. Biblical Definition of Guilt: Guilt is not a mere feeling but a moral and legal condition of deserving punishment for real wrongdoing. It is a status before God's law, independent of personal feelings. This understanding helps us align our conscience with biblical truths, ensuring we feel guilt appropriately when we have truly erred. [02:56]
2. Understanding Shame: Shame is a painful emotion of disgrace or humiliation caused by wrongdoing or impropriety, often influenced by others' perceptions. The Bible expands this concept to include behaviors or conditions that should cause such emotions, even if they do not. This broader understanding helps us discern when shame is appropriate. [04:46]
3. **True vs. False Guilt:** True guilt arises from genuine wrongdoing, while false guilt occurs when one feels guilty without having done wrong. A healthy conscience, aligned with God's word, helps us discern these feelings accurately, ensuring we do not carry unnecessary burdens. [06:39]
4. **True vs. False Shame:** True shame is appropriate when one's actions are genuinely disgraceful, while false shame arises from situations where no wrongdoing has occurred. Understanding this distinction helps us avoid unnecessary embarrassment and focus on living uprightly. [08:40]
5. Recalibrating the Conscience: Our consciences can sometimes mislead us, requiring recalibration according to biblical truths. By aligning our conscience with God's word, we ensure that our feelings of guilt and shame are appropriate and not based on false premises. [07:29]
** [07:29]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[00:12] - Introduction to the Topic
[00:32] - Author's Questions on Guilt and Shame
[01:14] - Historical Context of Shame and Guilt
[02:22] - Common Definitions in Psychotherapy
[02:40] - Biblical Definition of Guilt
[03:51] - Guilt as a Moral and Legal Condition
[04:46] - Understanding Shame
[05:38] - Biblical Examples of Shame
[06:39] - True vs. False Guilt
[07:29] - Recalibrating the Conscience
[08:40] - True vs. False Shame
[09:32] - Illustrations of Shame
[10:57] - Overcoming Shame
[11:25] - Conclusion and Future Topics

Bible Study Guide

Bible Study Discussion Guide: Understanding Guilt and Shame from a Biblical Perspective

Bible Reading:

James 2:10 - "For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it."
Philippians 3:19 - "Their end is destruction, their god is their belly, and they glory in their shame, with minds set on earthly things."
Hebrews 12:2 - "Looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God."

Observation Questions:

According to James 2:10, what does it mean to be guilty of all the law if one fails in just one point? How does this relate to the biblical definition of guilt discussed in the sermon? [04:09]
In Philippians 3:19, what does it mean for people to "glory in their shame"? How does this illustrate the concept of shame as discussed in the sermon? [05:38]
How does Hebrews 12:2 describe Jesus' approach to shame, and what does this teach us about handling shame in our own lives? [05:59]

Interpretation Questions:

How does the biblical definition of guilt as a moral and legal condition differ from the common psychological definition of guilt as a feeling? Why is this distinction important for Christians? [02:56]
What role does the perception of others play in the experience of shame, according to the sermon and Philippians 3:19? How can this influence our understanding of true and false shame? [05:03]
How can a Christian recalibrate their conscience according to biblical truths, and why is this necessary for distinguishing between true and false guilt and shame? [07:29]

Application Questions:

Reflect on a time when you felt guilty. Was it true guilt based on wrongdoing, or was it false guilt? How can you use biblical truths to discern the difference in the future? [06:39]
Have you ever experienced shame due to the perception of others, even when you did nothing wrong? How can you apply the example of Jesus in Hebrews 12:2 to overcome such feelings? [05:59]
Consider a situation where your conscience might have misled you. What steps can you take to recalibrate your conscience according to God's word? [07:29]
How can understanding the difference between true and false shame help you in your relationships with others, especially when dealing with honest mistakes or unmet expectations? [08:40]
Identify an area in your life where you might be carrying unnecessary guilt. What practical steps can you take to release this burden and align your feelings with biblical truths? [06:39]
Think of a recent situation where you felt embarrassed or ashamed. Was it due to a genuine wrongdoing or an honest mistake? How can you respond differently next time based on the sermon’s teachings? [10:20]
How can you support someone else in your life who might be struggling with feelings of guilt or shame? What biblical truths can you share with them to offer encouragement and guidance? [09:00]

Sermon Clips

Guilt is the moral and legal condition of deserving punishment for real wrongdoing. A person may feel guilty, but his feeling is not the same as the guilt. The feeling may be justified if there's true guilt, or the feeling may be unjustified if there's no true guilt. [00:02:56]

Guilt assumes a moral law or a moral standard and a system by which a person is held accountable for infractions of that moral standard. Guilt is the condition of being called to account for those infractions of the moral law. It's not a matter of how one feels about reality. [00:03:40]

Shame is a negative painful emotion of disgrace or humiliation caused by evildoing or shortcoming or impropriety. This emotion is defined in part by the fact that other people think you should indeed be ashamed. Other people are watching, other people are assessing. [00:04:46]

The meaning of the word shame is expanded beyond that in the Bible to refer to the behavior or the condition that brings down the emotion of shame. For example, Paul says some people glory in their shame. Those people don't feel shame, but they should. [00:05:24]

A person is truly guilty if he did wrong before the law of God or the just law of man, and a person is not guilty if he has done no such wrong. If he has done wrong, he should feel his guilt. This is what a healthy conscience is for. [00:06:39]

There are areas where our consciences need to be recalibrated so that they don't condemn us as guilty when we have not done wrong. There is an objective reality that we can conform to, and our consciences might condemn us when we haven't done anything wrong. [00:07:29]

If a person is forgiven by God on the basis of Jesus taking our punishment on himself, he should not feel guilty even though he did the wrong because the wrong is now covered. It's been duly punished. [00:07:43]

Suppose you cheat and lie on your income tax return in order to hold back proper taxes. A year goes by, and your conscience bothers you because you really are guilty, but you don't feel shame. It's all private; nobody knows. Then the IRS comes knocking. [00:08:08]

You should want to not only to receive God's forgiveness, which is available in Christ for your true guilt, your true wrongdoing, but you should also want to regain your good name and trust in the community, which may take longer and involves a good bit of faithful humble obedience and upright living. [00:08:47]

If you feel ashamed having done your God-given best, it probably means you love the praise of man more than the praise of God. [00:09:57]

A Christian should have such a strong sense of being loved and accepted, invested in significant life and work by God, that such a mistake quickly passes into forgetfulness. [00:10:35]

I hope these distinctions will help push along your research as you write this book. I look forward to reading all of your books, but I can't wait to see this one that you're working on. [00:11:16]