Who Do You Say I Am? Choosing the Cross

Mark 8 brings Jesus and his disciples to a real point of decision, even if the disciples do not yet know how big the decision is. Jesus asks the question point blank: who do people say that he is, and then, who do the disciples say that he is? Peter, true to form, speaks up, but Peter is not just throwing out a wild guess. Peter has seen Jesus’ words and works, and Peter answers with his heart pounding and his eyes lit up: “You’re the Messiah. You’re the Christ. You’re the chosen anointed one.”

Peter has the right label, but Peter has the wrong idea of what that label will look like. The prophets held together two pictures, the triumphant ruler who overthrows evil powers and the suffering servant who walks a broken road. Jesus knows which road comes first. Jesus begins speaking of rejection, suffering, death, and the cross, and Peter rebukes him as if Jesus needs to “think this through.” Jesus answers sharply because Peter’s words are pulling toward another source, not toward God. Jesus says, in effect, “Get in line behind me. I’m headed to the cross.”

Caesarea Philippi makes the question louder. The place stands in the shadow of Roman power, military strength, economic pressure, and a marble temple built to honor Caesar. The place also carries the memory of Israel’s idolatry and the old challenge to choose whom to serve. Jesus asks, “Who do you say that I am?” right there, where empire, idols, power, and fear are all pressing in.

The Roman cross was not a religious decoration. The Roman cross was slow, brutal, public terror, an emblem of authority over life and death. The cross means that God’s victory will not look like what the world calls success, triumph, or glory. The road of God may be messy, awful, unwelcome, and difficult, but Jesus is committed to it all the way.

Jesus’ question is answered not finally by words, but by following. Taking up the cross is not simply “dealing with stuff” or putting up with self-made burdens. Taking up the cross means letting Jesus be the one, in money, career, grudges, family, speech, ministry, silence before God, and risks others may not understand. Jesus does not come merely as a map or a recipe. Jesus comes as the destination and the meal offered for the soul. The way of the cross leads home, and that one decision puts every other decision in perspective.

##

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. The right label can miss the road [48:27] Peter names Jesus rightly as the Messiah, but Peter still resists the way Jesus says Messiahship must go. A correct confession can still carry a worldly imagination if triumph is expected before obedience. Jesus does not reject the title, but he purifies what the title means by turning toward the cross. [48:27]
• 2. Location makes the question louder [52:31] Caesarea Philippi is not just background scenery. Roman power, old idols, military force, and the memory of choosing whom to serve all gather around Jesus’ question. The setting presses the issue: Jesus is not one more power among powers, but the one before whom every rival claim is exposed. [52:31]
• 3. The cross unmasks worldly glory [54:41] Rome used the cross as public terror, a sign that empire held life and death in its hands. Jesus takes that very instrument and makes it the place where God’s victory is revealed in a way the world would never call victory. The cross refuses shallow ideas of success and shows that God’s road home may pass through what looks like defeat. [54:41]
• 4. Following answers what words cannot [58:18] Jesus does not demand that every question be sorted out before the first step is taken. The answer to “Who do you say that I am?” becomes visible in the road a person takes behind him. Words matter, but discipleship tests whether those words are only language or a life being handed over. [58:18]
• 5. One decision steadies every other [01:05:01] Houses, jobs, relationships, schools, and purchases can all surprise, disappoint, or fail. The settled decision to follow Jesus does not remove every hard choice, but it keeps those choices from ruling the heart. When Jesus is the one, success does not become an idol and failure does not become the final word.
  
  ## [65:01]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [41:41] - Questions and Big Decisions
• [44:12] - Jesus Puts the Disciples on the Spot
• [46:01] - Peter Confesses the Messiah
• [48:01] - The Triumphant Ruler and Suffering Servant
• [49:11] - Following the Way of the Cross
• [49:57] - Why Caesarea Philippi Matters
• [52:31] - Jesus Questions Empire and Idols
• [54:14] - The Brutality of Roman Crosses
• [56:42] - God’s Victory Looks Different
• [58:18] - Who Do You Say Jesus Is?
• [59:40] - What Taking Up the Cross Means
• [62:20] - Everyday Cross Bearing
• [64:24] - The Way of the Cross Leads Home

Bible Reading

Mark 8:27-38
And Jesus went on with his disciples to the villages of Caesarea Philippi. And on the way he asked his disciples, “Who do people say that I am?” And they told him, “John the Baptist; and others say, Elijah; and others, one of the prophets.” And he asked them, “But who do you say that I am?” Peter answered him, “You are the Christ.” And he strictly charged them not to tell anyone about him. And he began to teach them that the Son of Man must suffer many things and be rejected by the elders and the chief priests and the scribes and be killed, and after three days rise again. And he said this plainly. And Peter took him aside and began to rebuke him. But turning and seeing his disciples, he rebuked Peter and said, “Get behind me, Satan! For you are not setting your mind on the things of God, but on the things of man.” And calling the crowd to him with his disciples, he said to them, “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me. For whoever would save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake and the gospel's will save it. For what does it profit a man to gain the whole world and forfeit his soul? For what can a man give in return for his soul? For whoever is ashamed of me and of my words in this adulterous and sinful generation, of him will the Son of Man also be ashamed when he comes in the glory of his Father with the holy angels.” [44:12]

Observation questions

1. In Mark 8:27-30, what different answers are given about Jesus’ identity, and how does Peter answer differently from the crowd? [46:01]
2. After Peter calls Jesus the Christ, what does Jesus begin to teach openly about what must happen to him? How does Peter respond to that? [48:27]
3. What details about Caesarea Philippi make Jesus’ question feel especially weighty in that moment? [52:31]
4. In Mark 8:34-38, what specific words does Jesus use to describe following him, and what contrasts does he make between gaining and losing? [58:18]

Interpretation questions

1. Peter has the right name for Jesus but resists the road Jesus says he must take. What does that show about how a person can speak truly about Jesus and still misunderstand him? [48:27]
2. Jesus asks, “Who do you say that I am?” in a place surrounded by empire, idols, and public power. Why does that setting help show that Jesus is not just one more rival voice among many? [52:31]
3. Jesus says that taking up the cross is part of following him. How does the meaning of the Roman cross deepen the seriousness of that call? [54:41]
4. Jesus does not tell the crowd to solve every question before they begin. What does it mean that the fullest answer to Jesus’ question is shown in following him? [58:18]

Application questions

1. It is possible to use the right words about Jesus while still wanting him to fit a safer or more successful path. Where is there a temptation right now to want Jesus without the cross-shaped road of obedience? [49:11]
2. Jesus’ question comes in the middle of competing powers, pressures, and loyalties. What voices feel loudest around you these days when you are trying to decide who will really lead your life? [53:46]
3. Taking up the cross is more than just “dealing with stuff.” What burden in your life is simply the result of your own habits, and what hard thing might actually be a real act of obedience to Jesus? [01:00:25]
4. Letting Jesus be the one touches money, work, family, grudges, and time. Which one of those areas feels most unsettled for you right now, and what might seeking Jesus first look like there this week? [01:01:00]
5. Following Jesus may mean speaking differently, forgiving deeply, or taking a risk others may not understand. Is there one specific step of obedience you have been delaying because it feels costly or awkward? [01:02:20]
6. Jesus gives the grace of one decision that puts many other decisions in perspective. What decision or worry has been ruling your heart lately, and how might settling your heart again on Jesus change the way you carry it? [01:05:01]
7. The way of the cross leads home. Where does that promise need to steady you right now, especially in a place where obedience feels slow, hidden, or difficult? [01:04:24]