1 Samuel 28 opens with Samuel dead, the Philistines gathered, and Saul terrified. The text is not finally about a witch, a medium, or a spooky supernatural moment. The text is about a man who has got so practiced at saying no to God that no has become a habit. Saul asks the Lord for direction, but the Lord does not answer, not because God is cruel or enjoys silence, but because Saul has spent years refusing the word already given.
God had spoken to Saul through Samuel. God had given clear commands, sent warnings, and confronted Saul through rebukes. Saul had chosen his own way in the sacrifice at Gilgal, in sparing Amalek, in chasing David, and in slaughtering the priests at Nob. God’s silence is not absence here. God’s silence is judgment.
Hebrews gives New Testament Christians a better word than Saul had on that dark night. God has spoken fully and finally in his Son. The question is not whether God will speak, but whether a person will listen to the Son, the good shepherd. Saul heard silence, but the cross speaks a word of justice for sin and astonishing mercy for sinners who turn to Christ.
Saul’s substitute is tragic. The king who expelled mediums now goes looking for one. Saul disguises himself, sneaks out at night, and swears “as surely as the Lord lives” while breaking the Lord’s command. Saul does not come in repentance. Saul wants information, a battle plan, a favourable outcome. Saul wants the benefits of God’s favour without wanting God himself.
Saul’s search exposes the search that runs through ordinary life as well. People may not be looking for the witch at Endor, but people look for assurance, peace, hope, identity, and control in promotion, mortgages, lifestyle, sport, social media, beauty, wellness, self help, AI, and bits of spirituality. Those things may not be wrong in themselves, but they quietly become the place people look for meaning. Samuel’s old word still bites: disobedience is like divination.
Samuel’s appearance does not make mediumship acceptable. The narrator calls him Samuel, and God permits this extraordinary moment as final judgment, not fresh hope. Saul receives no new secret knowledge, only the old word he kept refusing: the kingdom has been torn away, David will be king, and Saul will die. Saul ends with a dark Passover, a feast of the damned, eating with a witch instead of rejoicing in the Lord’s salvation.
Jesus stands as God’s final word. Jesus does not merely point to life. Jesus is life. The right prayer is not, “Lord, give another sign,” but, “Lord, help the heart see Jesus.”
##
Key Takeaways
- 1. Saying no becomes a habit. Saul’s tragedy begins long before Endor, because repeated refusal trains the heart to resist God without even feeling the weight of it. The danger is not only one large act of rebellion, but the slow hardening that comes from treating God’s word as optional. Today is the day to listen, because delayed obedience can quietly become settled disobedience. [30:57]
- 2. God’s silence can be judgment. The Lord’s silence toward Saul is not indifference, weakness, or cruelty. God had already spoken again and again, and Saul had made a life of pushing that word away. A person asking for fresh guidance may need first to ask what God has already said and what obedience has already been refused. [32:11]
- 3. Guidance can replace God himself. Saul does not want reconciliation, mercy, or repentance. Saul wants information that might help him survive the next day. The heart can do the same when Jesus becomes a means to a better marriage, a safer future, a clearer plan, or a calmer life, rather than the treasure himself. [39:04]
- 4. Lesser voices promise false peace. Success, lifestyle, wellness, social approval, self help, and modern spirituality can all become substitutes for listening to God. Their danger often lies in how ordinary and respectable they look while they take the place of trust. The question is not whether these things can be enjoyed, but whether they have become the voice that tells a person who they are. [41:54]
- 5. Jesus is God’s final word. God has not left sinners guessing in the dark. Jesus is not one more clue, sign, or spiritual technique, but God’s full and final self-revelation. The heart that keeps asking for another word may be avoiding the Word already given in the crucified and risen Son.
## [52:18]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [29:32] - Spiritual Searching in Sydney
- [30:38] - Saul’s Real Crisis
- [31:31] - Samuel Dead, Saul Terrified
- [32:11] - God’s Silence as Judgment
- [34:41] - God Has Spoken by His Son
- [37:22] - Saul Seeks a Forbidden Substitute
- [39:04] - Wanting God’s Benefits Without God
- [40:17] - Modern Substitutes for Peace
- [42:23] - Disobedience Like Divination
- [45:35] - Samuel Appears to Saul
- [49:23] - Why Mediumship Is Condemned
- [50:15] - Saul’s Dark Passover
- [52:18] - Jesus, God’s Final Word
- [54:26] - Open the Eyes of the Heart