When Does Human Life Begin? A Multifaceted Exploration

 

Summary

In this session, we explored the profound and complex question of when human life begins, a central issue in the abortion debate. We examined this question from three perspectives: biblical theology, science or natural law, and government or legal culture. From a biblical standpoint, while many theologians and Christians believe that life begins at conception, the Bible does not explicitly state this. However, the implicit evidence in Scripture, such as the continuity between prenatal and postnatal life and the use of the same terms for unborn and born children, suggests that life begins at conception. Yet, these implications, while significant, are not absolutely conclusive.

From a historical perspective, early Christian documents like 'The Didache' and the views of theologians such as Augustine, Aquinas, and Luther, consistently regarded abortion as murder, indicating a longstanding belief in the sanctity of life from conception. Scientifically, the genetic code that defines a human being is established at conception, and significant developmental milestones such as a heartbeat and brain waves occur early in pregnancy, challenging the notion of the fetus as merely potential life.

Legally, the concept of viability, as established in Roe v. Wade, is problematic due to its arbitrary nature. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor critiqued this, arguing that potential life is consistent throughout pregnancy, not just at viability. This raises questions about the state's responsibility to protect potential human life from conception. As we continue to grapple with these issues, the relationship between the church and state in addressing the abortion debate remains a critical area for further exploration.

Key Takeaways:

1. Biblical Implications on Life's Beginning: While the Bible does not explicitly state that life begins at conception, the continuity between prenatal and postnatal life and the use of the same terms for unborn and born children suggest a biblical view that life begins at conception. This continuity challenges us to consider the sanctity of life from its earliest stages. [03:12]

2. Historical Consensus on Abortion: The early Christian church, as reflected in 'The Didache,' and theologians like Augustine and Aquinas, consistently viewed abortion as murder. This historical consensus underscores the church's longstanding commitment to the sanctity of life, urging us to reflect on the moral implications of abortion. [14:40]

3. Scientific Insights on Fetal Development: Modern science reveals that the genetic code is established at conception, and significant developmental milestones occur early in pregnancy. This scientific understanding challenges the notion of the fetus as merely potential life and invites us to reconsider the beginning of human life. [18:45]

4. Legal Challenges of Viability: The concept of viability, as a legal standard, is arbitrary and problematic. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's critique highlights the need for a consistent legal approach to protecting potential human life throughout pregnancy, prompting us to reflect on the ethical and legal responsibilities towards the unborn. [29:12]

5. Church and State Responsibilities: The state's responsibility to protect the unborn and the church's role in the abortion debate are intertwined. As we explore these responsibilities, we are called to consider how the church can influence and support ethical and legal frameworks that uphold the sanctity of life. [31:23]

Youtube Chapters:

- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:37] - Introduction to the Abortion Debate
- [01:09] - Biblical Perspective on Life's Beginning
- [02:33] - Scriptural Implications and Certainty
- [03:47] - Continuity of Prenatal and Postnatal Life
- [05:17] - Sermon on the Mount and Potential Life
- [06:22] - Psalm 139 and God's Knowledge of Life
- [08:04] - Biblical Language and Unborn Children
- [09:28] - Luke's Narrative and Prenatal Recognition
- [10:54] - Exodus 21 and Legal Implications
- [13:26] - Church History and Early Christian Views
- [15:57] - Natural Law and Scientific Insights
- [18:45] - Genetic Code and Fetal Development
- [21:16] - Ethical Considerations and Sanctity of Life
- [26:38] - Legal Perspectives and Viability
- [31:23] - Church and State Responsibilities

Study Guide

Bible Study Discussion Guide

Bible Reading:
1. Psalm 139:13-16
2. Luke 1:39-44
3. Exodus 21:22-25

---

Observation Questions:

1. In Psalm 139, what does the psalmist express about God's knowledge and involvement in human life before birth? How does this passage contribute to the understanding of when life begins? [06:22]

2. According to the narrative in Luke 1, what significant event occurs when Mary visits Elizabeth, and how does this event relate to the recognition of life in the womb? [09:28]

3. What does Exodus 21:22-25 suggest about the value and protection of unborn life in ancient Israelite law? How is this passage interpreted in the context of the sermon? [10:54]

4. How does the sermon describe the continuity between prenatal and postnatal life, and what biblical evidence is used to support this view? [03:12]

---

Interpretation Questions:

1. How does the use of the same terms for unborn and born children in both the Old and New Testaments influence the interpretation of when life begins according to the sermon? [07:21]

2. What implications does the historical consensus of early Christian theologians, as discussed in the sermon, have on the modern church's stance on abortion? [14:40]

3. How does the sermon address the scientific insights on fetal development, and what role do these insights play in the argument about the beginning of human life? [18:45]

4. What are the legal challenges associated with the concept of viability as discussed in the sermon, and how does this affect the ethical and legal responsibilities towards the unborn? [29:12]

---

Application Questions:

1. Reflect on Psalm 139:13-16. How does the understanding of God's intimate involvement in your creation affect your view of the sanctity of life? How can this perspective influence your conversations about life and abortion?

2. Considering the event in Luke 1:39-44, how might recognizing the presence and significance of life in the womb change the way you view and support expectant mothers in your community?

3. How can the historical views of theologians like Augustine and Aquinas inform your personal stance on abortion today? What steps can you take to educate yourself and others about these historical perspectives? [14:40]

4. In light of the scientific insights shared in the sermon, how can you engage in informed discussions about the beginning of human life with those who may hold different views? [18:45]

5. The sermon discusses the arbitrary nature of the legal concept of viability. How can you advocate for a more consistent legal approach to protecting potential human life throughout pregnancy? [29:12]

6. How can the church effectively influence and support ethical and legal frameworks that uphold the sanctity of life? What role can you play in this effort within your local church community? [31:23]

7. Reflect on your personal beliefs about when life begins. How do these beliefs align with the biblical, historical, and scientific perspectives discussed in the sermon? What actions can you take to align your life more closely with these beliefs?

Devotional

Day 1: The Continuity of Life from Conception
The Bible, while not explicitly stating that life begins at conception, provides implicit evidence through the continuity between prenatal and postnatal life. The use of the same terms for unborn and born children in Scripture suggests a biblical view that life begins at conception. This continuity challenges us to consider the sanctity of life from its earliest stages. The biblical narrative invites believers to reflect on the inherent value and dignity of life from the moment of conception, urging a deeper understanding of the divine image present in every human being. [03:12]

"For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother's womb. I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works; my soul knows it very well." (Psalm 139:13-14, ESV)

Reflection: How does recognizing the continuity of life from conception change the way you view the sanctity of life in your daily interactions and decisions?


Day 2: Historical Consensus on the Sanctity of Life
Throughout history, early Christian documents like 'The Didache' and theologians such as Augustine and Aquinas have consistently regarded abortion as murder. This historical consensus underscores the church's longstanding commitment to the sanctity of life from conception. The moral implications of abortion have been a significant concern for the church, urging believers to reflect on the ethical dimensions of life and the responsibility to protect it. This historical perspective challenges modern Christians to consider how they can uphold these values in a contemporary context. [14:40]

"Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you; I appointed you a prophet to the nations." (Jeremiah 1:5, ESV)

Reflection: In what ways can you actively participate in promoting the sanctity of life within your community, drawing from the historical teachings of the church?


Day 3: Scientific Insights into the Beginning of Life
Modern science reveals that the genetic code that defines a human being is established at conception, and significant developmental milestones occur early in pregnancy. This scientific understanding challenges the notion of the fetus as merely potential life and invites us to reconsider the beginning of human life. By acknowledging these scientific insights, believers are encouraged to integrate faith and reason, recognizing the divine handiwork in the intricate process of human development. This perspective calls for a renewed appreciation of life as a sacred gift from God. [18:45]

"For you have possessed my reins: you have covered me in my mother's womb. I will praise you; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made: marvelous are your works; and that my soul knows right well." (Psalm 139:13-14, ESV)

Reflection: How can the scientific understanding of fetal development deepen your appreciation for the miracle of life and influence your conversations about the beginning of life?


Day 4: Legal Challenges and the Concept of Viability
The legal concept of viability, as established in Roe v. Wade, is seen as arbitrary and problematic. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor critiqued this, arguing that potential life is consistent throughout pregnancy, not just at viability. This raises questions about the state's responsibility to protect potential human life from conception. Believers are prompted to reflect on the ethical and legal responsibilities towards the unborn, considering how laws can align with the moral imperative to protect life. This reflection encourages engagement in discussions about legal frameworks that uphold the sanctity of life. [29:12]

"Rescue those who are being taken away to death; hold back those who are stumbling to the slaughter. If you say, 'Behold, we did not know this,' does not he who weighs the heart perceive it? Does not he who keeps watch over your soul know it, and will he not repay man according to his work?" (Proverbs 24:11-12, ESV)

Reflection: How can you contribute to creating a legal and ethical culture that consistently protects human life from conception?


Day 5: The Intertwined Responsibilities of Church and State
The state's responsibility to protect the unborn and the church's role in the abortion debate are intertwined. As believers explore these responsibilities, they are called to consider how the church can influence and support ethical and legal frameworks that uphold the sanctity of life. This involves a collaborative effort between faith communities and governmental structures to advocate for policies that reflect the value of life. By engaging in this dialogue, Christians can play a pivotal role in shaping a society that honors and protects life at all stages. [31:23]

"Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute. Open your mouth, judge righteously, defend the rights of the poor and needy." (Proverbs 31:8-9, ESV)

Reflection: What steps can you take to actively engage with both church and state in advocating for the protection of life, and how can you encourage others to join in this mission?

Quotes

"Now, I know that many of my colleagues in the field of theology and certainly multitudes of Christians are convinced that the Bible unambiguously teaches that human life begins at conception. I personally am not persuaded that we can know with compelling certainty or at least that we know yet with compelling certainty from the source of Scripture that life begins at conception." [00:01:37]

"I think the Bible does teach that there's a continuity between prenatal and postnatal life. But is there anybody in the world that doubts that? One doesn't have to read the Bible to know that there's a -- I know that at one time I was a fetus, and that you were a fetus and you were a fetus and you were a fetus and everybody in this room and everybody that's watching on television at one time, you were a fetus." [00:03:40]

"Psalm 139 is often quoted as evidence from the Scripture that teaches that life begins at conception. We read in verse 13 of Psalm 139: 'For thou has possessed my reins, thou has covered me in my mother's womb. And I will praise thee; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Marvelous are thy works, And that my soul knows right well.'" [00:05:58]

"And, in fact, the Hebrew word that is used for a living born child is the same Hebrew word that the Old Testament uses for a fetus. The same is also true in the Greek New Testament, that the same word for a 'postnatal' human being is used to describe a 'prenatal' human being, so that both Testaments call unborn children 'children.'" [00:07:21]

"One of the most important texts for me is that found in the Old Testament book of Exodus in chapter 21. I don't have time to go into a detailed exegesis of Exodus 21 for you tonight. I'm simply going to say to you that even among theologians and Old Testament's scholars, there's considerable debate about the interpretation of Exodus 21 that talks about the law of Israel that is applied when men are fighting together." [00:10:43]

"The very minimum we get out of Exodus 21 is that the unborn child in Israel was protected by Jewish law and was considered to be extremely valuable. So, but it doesn't necessarily prove that it was given the same value as a human life. Let's turn now if we can quickly from the biblical considerations to the viewpoint of church history which involves the reflection of the best minds of the church on the biblical teaching." [00:13:09]

"And as I say it is one of the earliest catechetical instruction manuals that goes back probably to the first century itself, and this is not a book of the Bible. But what it does represent clearly to us is the understanding of the early Christian church on issues of this type because there is no ambiguity in The Didache. The Didache sets forth as a clear emphatic prohibition 'Thou shalt not commit murder by abortion.'" [00:13:54]

"First of all, when we look at nature and we're trying to make a scientific designation as when a person is a person; we're trying to discover discernible clear lines of demarcation. One of the most obvious simple and easy lines of demarcation that we can ever find is birth, and many people say 'There's no question about that. Once the umbilical cord is cut and that infant now is breathing on his own, is no longer dependent upon the nourishment system of his mother and is an individuated human being, then they're clearly alive.'" [00:15:52]

"But as I say the most obvious point of demarcation where the process of the production of a child begins is at conception. What has been important to the medical decision on this is a relatively recent discovery -- by recent, I don't mean last week but I mean twentieth century -- and that is that we understand in modern science that the entire genetic code that generates the individual particular characteristics, size, shape and development, all of that, of a personal human being that entire genetic code is established at conception." [00:18:04]

"Within 18 to 25 days after conception, there is a discernible heartbeat, and the beating of the heart, though in and of itself does not usually constitute the -- the cessation of the beating of the heart doesn't immediately constitute a cessation of life in the judgment in the medical community. The beating of the heart is a very significant consideration when we're talking about human life." [00:19:01]

"Now, viability means that time in the development of a child when if that child is born, prematurely or whatever, it has the ability to survive. It is livable. It is viable. And so the ruling of the court was that after viability, abortions are not permitted except under certain extenuating circumstances. Incidentally, the net effect have been that those circumstances are easily gotten around so that the abortions are in fact legal now all the way into the third trimester and are being done into the third trimester." [00:27:00]

"Accordingly, I believe that the state's interest in protecting potential human life exists throughout the entire pregnancy. See, once the court made the distinction between potential and actual human life, they are caught on the horns of dilemma. If the state is responsible to protect potential human life then as Sandra Day O'Connor says it is a potential human life at the moment of conception that it has potentiality moving to the direction to the natural conclusion of birth and to put the legal definition of life at the point of viability is an exercise in despair because of its implicit arbitrariness." [00:30:02]

Chatbot

  • I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Oct 04, 2018. Do you have any questions about it?

Transcript
What was the most surprising thing in this sermon?
Were there any personal stories shared?