Understanding Tragedy Through God's Sovereign Purpose
Summary
In the wake of America's declaration of war on terrorism, we are reminded that wars often stem from conflicting ideas and beliefs. This conflict of ideas is not just a political or social issue but also a spiritual one, as it challenges our understanding of divine providence. The events of September 11, 2001, have been described using terms like "catastrophe" and "tragedy," but the frequent use of "senseless tragedy" is troubling. This phrase suggests a worldview incompatible with Christian thought, which holds that nothing is truly senseless if God is sovereign and purposeful.
Reflecting on my college days, I recall a biology class where the professor dismissed questions of purpose, focusing only on the mechanics of life. This approach contrasts sharply with the Christian worldview, which insists that everything, even tragedies, has a purpose in God's plan. The question of "why" is central to our understanding of events like September 11, and while some, like Jerry Falwell, rushed to label it as divine judgment, we must be cautious. The truth is, we cannot always discern God's specific purposes, but we can trust that He is involved and that His plans are ultimately for good.
The story of the man born blind in John 9 illustrates this point. The disciples assumed his blindness was due to sin, but Jesus corrected them, revealing that it was to display God's works. This teaches us not to rush to judgment about the causes of suffering. The book of Job further emphasizes that suffering is not always a direct result of personal sin. Job's trials were not due to his guilt but served a greater purpose in God's plan.
Ultimately, for Christians, there are no true tragedies. God promises that all things work together for the good of those who love Him. Our sufferings are temporary and pale in comparison to the eternal glory that awaits us. This perspective transforms our understanding of tragedy, reminding us that God's providence is at work even in our darkest moments.
Key Takeaways:
1. The Conflict of Ideas and Divine Providence: Wars and conflicts often arise from differing ideas and beliefs, challenging our understanding of divine providence. As Christians, we must remember that nothing is truly senseless if God is sovereign and purposeful. Our worldview should reflect the belief that God has a purpose for everything, even in the midst of tragedy. [00:22]
2. The Danger of Rushing to Judgment: In the aftermath of tragedies, it's tempting to assign blame or divine judgment. However, we must be cautious and humble, acknowledging that we cannot always discern God's specific purposes. Our role is to trust in His sovereignty and goodness, even when we don't understand. [07:54]
3. Lessons from the Man Born Blind: The story of the man born blind in John 9 teaches us not to assume that suffering is always a result of sin. Jesus revealed that the man's blindness was to display God's works, reminding us that God's purposes are often beyond our understanding. [13:02]
4. The Book of Job and the Mystery of Suffering: Job's story illustrates that suffering is not always a direct result of personal sin. His trials served a greater purpose in God's plan, challenging us to trust in God's wisdom and sovereignty, even when we face inexplicable hardships. [19:51]
5. The Christian Perspective on Tragedy: For Christians, there are no true tragedies. God promises that all things work together for the good of those who love Him. Our sufferings are temporary and pale in comparison to the eternal glory that awaits us, transforming our understanding of tragedy. [22:57]
Youtube Chapters:
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:22] - Conflict of Ideas and Divine Providence
- [00:58] - The Phrase "Senseless Tragedy"
- [02:04] - Worldview and Christian Thought
- [02:49] - College Biology and Teleology
- [05:21] - The Question of "Why"
- [06:30] - Reflections on September 11
- [07:54] - The Danger of Rushing to Judgment
- [10:05] - The Man Born Blind
- [12:15] - The Fallacy of the False Dilemma
- [13:02] - Jesus' Response to the Disciples
- [14:17] - The Purpose of Suffering
- [17:40] - Lessons from the Book of Job
- [19:51] - The Mystery of Suffering
- [22:57] - The Christian Perspective on Tragedy
Study Guide
### Bible Study Discussion Guide
#### Bible Reading
1. John 9:1-7 - The story of the man born blind.
2. Job 1:6-12 - The beginning of Job's trials.
3. Romans 8:28 - "And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose."
---
#### Observation Questions
1. In John 9, what question do the disciples ask Jesus about the man born blind, and how does Jesus respond? [11:35]
2. How does the sermon describe the phrase "senseless tragedy," and why is it considered problematic from a Christian perspective? [02:04]
3. What was the initial reaction of Job's friends to his suffering, and how does this relate to the disciples' assumptions about the blind man? [19:51]
4. According to the sermon, what is the Christian perspective on the events of September 11, 2001, in terms of divine providence? [05:52]
---
#### Interpretation Questions
1. How does Jesus' response to the disciples' question in John 9 challenge common assumptions about the relationship between sin and suffering? [13:02]
2. In what ways does the story of Job illustrate the complexity of understanding God's purposes in suffering? [19:51]
3. How does the sermon suggest Christians should approach the concept of tragedy in light of Romans 8:28? [22:57]
4. What are the potential dangers of rushing to judgment about the causes of suffering, as illustrated by the sermon’s discussion of Jerry Falwell's comments? [07:54]
---
#### Application Questions
1. Reflect on a time when you faced a personal tragedy. How did your understanding of God's sovereignty influence your response? [22:57]
2. How can you cultivate a mindset that seeks to understand God's purposes in difficult situations, rather than rushing to judgment? [07:54]
3. In what ways can the story of the man born blind in John 9 encourage you to see God's work in unexpected places in your life? [13:02]
4. How might the lessons from the book of Job help you support someone who is experiencing suffering without making assumptions about their situation? [19:51]
5. Consider the phrase "senseless tragedy." How can you reframe your understanding of events that seem senseless in light of your faith? [02:04]
6. How can you apply the promise of Romans 8:28 to a current challenge you are facing, trusting that God is working for your good? [22:57]
7. Identify a specific area in your life where you struggle to see God's purpose. What steps can you take to seek His guidance and trust in His plan? [05:52]
Devotional
Day 1: Divine Providence in Conflict
Conflicts often arise from differing beliefs, challenging our understanding of divine providence. As Christians, we are called to remember that nothing is truly senseless if God is sovereign and purposeful. This perspective encourages us to see beyond the immediate chaos and recognize that God has a purpose for everything, even in the midst of tragedy. By trusting in His sovereignty, we can find peace and assurance that His plans are ultimately for good. [00:22]
"For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, declares the Lord. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts." (Isaiah 55:8-9, ESV)
Reflection: Think of a current conflict in your life. How can you trust in God's sovereignty and purpose in this situation today?
Day 2: Caution Against Rushing to Judgment
In the aftermath of tragedies, it is tempting to assign blame or divine judgment. However, we must be cautious and humble, acknowledging that we cannot always discern God's specific purposes. Our role is to trust in His sovereignty and goodness, even when we don't understand. This humility allows us to approach situations with grace and patience, recognizing that God's wisdom far surpasses our own. [07:54]
"Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment." (John 7:24, ESV)
Reflection: Recall a time when you rushed to judgment. How can you practice humility and patience in similar situations moving forward?
Day 3: Understanding Suffering Through the Man Born Blind
The story of the man born blind in John 9 teaches us not to assume that suffering is always a result of sin. Jesus revealed that the man's blindness was to display God's works, reminding us that God's purposes are often beyond our understanding. This challenges us to view suffering not as a punishment but as an opportunity for God's glory to be revealed in unexpected ways. [13:02]
"As he passed by, he saw a man blind from birth. And his disciples asked him, 'Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?' Jesus answered, 'It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.'" (John 9:1-3, ESV)
Reflection: Consider a personal struggle you are facing. How might God be using this situation to display His works in your life?
Day 4: The Mystery of Suffering in the Book of Job
Job's story illustrates that suffering is not always a direct result of personal sin. His trials served a greater purpose in God's plan, challenging us to trust in God's wisdom and sovereignty, even when we face inexplicable hardships. This perspective encourages us to remain faithful and patient, knowing that God's plans are ultimately for our good and His glory. [19:51]
"Behold, I go forward, but he is not there, and backward, but I do not perceive him; on the left hand when he is working, I do not behold him; he turns to the right hand, but I do not see him. But he knows the way that I take; when he has tried me, I shall come out as gold." (Job 23:8-10, ESV)
Reflection: Reflect on a time when you faced inexplicable hardship. How can you trust in God's wisdom and sovereignty in your current challenges?
Day 5: The Christian Perspective on Tragedy
For Christians, there are no true tragedies. God promises that all things work together for the good of those who love Him. Our sufferings are temporary and pale in comparison to the eternal glory that awaits us, transforming our understanding of tragedy. This perspective allows us to face life's challenges with hope and confidence, knowing that God's providence is at work even in our darkest moments. [22:57]
"For this light momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison, as we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen. For the things that are seen are transient, but the things that are unseen are eternal." (2 Corinthians 4:17-18, ESV)
Reflection: How can you shift your focus from temporary sufferings to the eternal glory that awaits you? What practical steps can you take today to cultivate this perspective?
Quotes
"In light of America’s declaration of war on terrorism, we have seen that wars are provoked in the final analysis by the conflict of ideas -- that war begins in the mind -- and hostilities break out when people come to different conclusions on how to live and how to function." [00:01:05]
"And one of the words that I hear perhaps more often than any other is the word “tragedy.” But what has concerned me somewhat in the public use of vocabulary is that I keep hearing this one phrase over and over and over again describing these events and that is the phrase “senseless tragedy.”" [00:52:39]
"Because for something to be defined in the final analysis as being tragic there has to be some standard of good for something to be deemed tragic, vis-à-vis that. And if things happen in a way that is senseless, there could not be anything that’s really a tragedy or a blessing. It would just simply be a meaningless event." [01:31:67]
"And if God is God and if God is a God of providence and if God is sovereign, then nothing ever happens that in the final analysis is senseless. I remember when I was in college, and I had to take an introductory course in lab biology. If fact, it was called Bonehead Biology because it was the biology course for non-science majors." [02:49:97]
"Now, one of the great quests of the history of philosophy is an investigation into the meaning and to the purpose of life and of human existence and not only of human existence but of animal existence, of flower existence, of the existence of rocks and everything else. That is philosophy is profoundly interested in questions of purpose and meaning." [04:19:84]
"Because Christians do not allow for meaningless events to take place. Because at the heart of the Christian life and worldview is that everything in history has a purpose in the mind of Almighty God -- that God is a purposive God. God is not chaotic. God does not play dice as Albert Einstein once remarked." [06:04:80]
"Now, one of the things that took place in the early days of reflection about the events of September the 11th were comments from some well-known preachers, particularly Jerry Falwell. And with and assist from Pat Robertson, Falwell made the observation that the why for this tragedy was that this was God’s act of judgment upon America for America’s immorality, for abortion, and the destruction of the human family and other moral issues of our day." [06:42:10]
"The only honest answer I could give, simply is, “I don’t know.” I can’t read God’s mind. Now, if you ask me, “Was God involved?” -- Yes. Because I’m committed to the Christian doctrine of providence, I’m convinced that God was involved in this act, that it was according to God’s purpose." [07:57:69]
"And so now the disciples see a person who is a grown adult and they know that that person was born blind and had suffered total blindness for many, many years. Now, if anything would seem senseless, it would be the experience of the man born blind. And so they come to Jesus and they say to Him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”" [11:00:10]
"Jesus answered, “Neither this man nor his parents sinned, but that the works of God should be revealed in him. I must work the works of Him who sent Me while it is day; the night is coming when no one can work. As long as I am in the world, I am the light of the world.”" [13:06:73]
"Because the purpose of Job’s suffering had absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with his personal guilt. But again even his friends who made that assumption, made it because they did understand that there were times in history where God does visit judgment on people and afflict them with pain and suffering as an execution of justice." [20:24:74]
"Because God has promised by Himself that all things that happen in this world -- all pain, all suffering, all tragedies are but for a moment. And that God works in and through those events for the good of those who endure them. That’s why the apostle said -- the pain, the suffering, the affliction that we bear in this world isn’t worthy to be compared, isn’t worthy to be mentioned in the same breath with the glory and the blessedness that God has stored up for His people." [23:11:17]
Chatbot
-
I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Jun 16, 2021. Do you have any questions about it?