Understanding Paul's Struggle: Law, Sin, and Grace
Summary
In this evening's reflection, we delve into the profound and often debated passage from Romans 7:14, where Paul states, "For we know that the law is spiritual, but I am carnal, sold under sin." This section of scripture is renowned for its complexity and the diverse interpretations it has inspired throughout church history. The central question revolves around the identity of the man Paul describes: is he unregenerate, regenerate, or a regenerate man in the early stages of his spiritual journey?
Historically, the early church fathers predominantly viewed this passage as describing an unregenerate man. However, St. Augustine, a pivotal figure in Christian theology, initially shared this view but later revised his stance, asserting that it describes a regenerate man, even at his best. This interpretation was largely adopted by the Protestant Reformers and Puritans. Conversely, those aligned with Arminian theology often interpret it as depicting an unregenerate man.
The passage challenges us to approach scripture with humility and openness, avoiding the pitfalls of a party spirit that clings rigidly to doctrinal systems. Instead, we are encouraged to examine the text with an open mind, guided by the Holy Spirit, to discern its true meaning. The Apostle Paul, in this section, is not merely sharing personal experience but is deeply concerned with elucidating the nature and limitations of the law. He emphasizes that while the law is spiritual, it cannot justify or sanctify us; rather, it reveals sin and, due to human sinfulness, can become a minister of death.
Paul's use of the present tense in describing his struggle with sin is not necessarily autobiographical but serves as a dramatic representation to illustrate the ongoing conflict between the spiritual law and the carnal nature. This passage invites us to reflect on our own spiritual journey, recognizing the tension between our desire to follow God's law and the reality of our human frailty.
Key Takeaways:
1. Humility in Interpretation: Approaching scripture with humility is crucial. We must be open to the Holy Spirit's guidance, recognizing that no doctrinal system is perfect. This openness allows us to discern the deeper truths of scripture beyond our preconceived notions. [11:59]
2. The Law's Spiritual Nature: The law is spiritual, originating from God, and is intended to lead to life. However, due to human sinfulness, it often reveals our shortcomings and cannot justify or sanctify us. This understanding calls us to rely on God's grace for true transformation. [25:28]
3. The Carnal Struggle: Paul's description of being "carnal, sold under sin" highlights the ongoing struggle between our spiritual aspirations and our human weaknesses. This tension is a common experience for believers, reminding us of our need for continual reliance on God's strength. [38:17]
4. Avoiding Party Spirit: A party spirit, which rigidly adheres to a particular doctrinal stance, can blind us to the broader truths of scripture. We must prioritize truth over allegiance to any theological system, allowing scripture to speak for itself. [10:39]
5. The Role of the Holy Spirit: The Holy Spirit plays a vital role in illuminating scripture and guiding us into all truth. As believers, we are called to seek the Spirit's anointing and wisdom, trusting that God will lead us into a deeper understanding of His word. [12:17]
Youtube Chapters:
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:14] - Introduction to Romans 7:14
- [00:35] - The Famous Passage
- [01:08] - Approaching with Humility
- [01:46] - Dividing the Chapter
- [02:39] - Three Main Views
- [04:31] - Historical Interpretations
- [06:14] - Augustine's Change of Mind
- [07:35] - Protestant Reformers' View
- [08:25] - Arminian Perspective
- [09:12] - Avoiding Party Spirit
- [10:21] - Open-Minded Approach
- [12:31] - Method of Interpretation
- [14:18] - General Analysis
- [19:46] - Main Thrust of the Section
- [25:28] - The Law's Limitations
- [30:21] - Change in Tense
- [34:23] - Understanding "Carnal"
- [38:17] - Key Statement: "I am Carnal"
- [46:09] - Conclusion and Reflection
Study Guide
Bible Study Discussion Guide
Bible Reading:
- Romans 7:14
- 1 Corinthians 3:1-3
- 2 Corinthians 3:5-6
---
Observation Questions:
1. What are the three main views regarding the identity of the man Paul describes in Romans 7:14? ([02:39])
2. How did St. Augustine's interpretation of Romans 7:14 change over time, and what does this tell us about his approach to scripture? ([06:14])
3. What does Paul mean when he says, "the law is spiritual, but I am carnal, sold under sin"? How does this statement set the tone for the rest of the passage? ([38:17])
4. How does the sermon describe the role of the Holy Spirit in understanding scripture? ([12:17])
---
Interpretation Questions:
1. How does the sermon suggest we should approach scripture to avoid a "party spirit"? What are the dangers of adhering too rigidly to a particular doctrinal stance? ([09:12])
2. In what ways does the sermon explain the limitations of the law, and how does this understanding affect our reliance on God's grace? ([25:28])
3. How does the sermon interpret Paul's use of the present tense in Romans 7:14, and what does this imply about the nature of the struggle between the spiritual law and the carnal nature? ([31:36])
4. What does the sermon suggest about the importance of humility in interpreting complex passages of scripture like Romans 7:14? ([11:59])
---
Application Questions:
1. Reflect on a time when you approached scripture with preconceived notions. How can you cultivate a more open-minded and humble approach in your future Bible study? ([11:59])
2. The sermon emphasizes the spiritual nature of the law and its inability to justify or sanctify us. How can you rely more on God's grace for transformation in your daily life? ([25:28])
3. Consider the ongoing struggle between spiritual aspirations and human weaknesses. How can you remind yourself to rely on God's strength in moments of personal struggle? ([38:17])
4. How can you ensure that your theological beliefs do not become a "party spirit" that blinds you to the broader truths of scripture? What steps can you take to prioritize truth over allegiance to a particular system? ([09:12])
5. The sermon highlights the role of the Holy Spirit in illuminating scripture. How can you seek the Spirit's guidance more intentionally in your Bible study and prayer life? ([12:17])
6. Reflect on the concept of being "carnal, sold under sin." How does this resonate with your own spiritual journey, and what practical steps can you take to address areas of weakness? ([38:17])
7. How can you apply the lesson of humility from the sermon in your interactions with others, especially when discussing differing interpretations of scripture? ([11:59])
Devotional
Day 1: Humility in Scriptural Interpretation
Approaching scripture with humility is essential for spiritual growth. It requires an openness to the Holy Spirit's guidance, acknowledging that no doctrinal system is flawless. This humility allows believers to discern the deeper truths of scripture beyond their preconceived notions. By setting aside rigid adherence to specific theological stances, individuals can engage with the Bible in a way that prioritizes truth and understanding. This approach fosters a deeper connection with God and a more profound comprehension of His word. [11:59]
"For the wisdom of this world is folly with God. For it is written, 'He catches the wise in their craftiness,' and again, 'The Lord knows the thoughts of the wise, that they are futile.'" (1 Corinthians 3:19-20, ESV)
Reflection: In what areas of your spiritual life do you find yourself clinging to preconceived notions? How can you invite the Holy Spirit to guide you into a deeper understanding of scripture today?
Day 2: The Spiritual Nature of the Law
The law, originating from God, is inherently spiritual and intended to lead to life. However, due to human sinfulness, it often reveals our shortcomings and cannot justify or sanctify us. This understanding calls believers to rely on God's grace for true transformation. The law serves as a mirror, reflecting our need for a savior and highlighting the limitations of human effort in achieving righteousness. By recognizing the law's spiritual nature, individuals are encouraged to seek God's grace and strength for genuine change. [25:28]
"For by works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight, since through the law comes knowledge of sin." (Romans 3:20, ESV)
Reflection: How does recognizing the spiritual nature of the law change your perspective on your own shortcomings? In what ways can you rely more on God's grace for transformation today?
Day 3: The Ongoing Carnal Struggle
Paul's description of being "carnal, sold under sin" highlights the ongoing struggle between spiritual aspirations and human weaknesses. This tension is a common experience for believers, reminding them of their need for continual reliance on God's strength. The struggle between the desire to follow God's law and the reality of human frailty is a part of the spiritual journey. By acknowledging this struggle, believers can find comfort in knowing they are not alone and can seek God's help in overcoming their weaknesses. [38:17]
"For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate." (Romans 7:15, ESV)
Reflection: What is one area of your life where you feel the tension between your spiritual aspirations and human weaknesses? How can you invite God's strength into this struggle today?
Day 4: Avoiding a Party Spirit
A party spirit, which rigidly adheres to a particular doctrinal stance, can blind individuals to the broader truths of scripture. Believers are encouraged to prioritize truth over allegiance to any theological system, allowing scripture to speak for itself. This openness fosters a more comprehensive understanding of God's word and prevents division within the body of Christ. By avoiding a party spirit, individuals can engage in meaningful dialogue and grow in their faith through diverse perspectives. [10:39]
"I appeal to you, brothers, to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them." (Romans 16:17, ESV)
Reflection: Are there any theological stances you hold that might be causing division or preventing you from seeing the broader truths of scripture? How can you approach these beliefs with an open mind today?
Day 5: The Role of the Holy Spirit
The Holy Spirit plays a vital role in illuminating scripture and guiding believers into all truth. As followers of Christ, individuals are called to seek the Spirit's anointing and wisdom, trusting that God will lead them into a deeper understanding of His word. The Holy Spirit acts as a teacher, revealing the mysteries of scripture and empowering believers to live out their faith. By relying on the Spirit's guidance, individuals can experience a more profound connection with God and a greater comprehension of His will. [12:17]
"But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I have said to you." (John 14:26, ESV)
Reflection: How can you invite the Holy Spirit to guide you into a deeper understanding of scripture today? What steps can you take to be more receptive to the Spirit's teaching in your daily life?
Quotes
"Therefore this is a subject obviously which we approach I trust with a good deal of caution and certainly with a maximum amount of humility. Now the dispute of course has always been with regard to this question: who is this man whom the Apostle is describing in this section?" [00:01:18]
"Augustine was a very great man and he gave proof of that by changing his mind on this. Now I'm not saying that he proved he was a great man by adopting the second opinion. I say the mark of greatness was that he was big enough to change his mind." [00:06:34]
"Party spirit is always wrong, always. We should be concerned about the truth and not a party that represents a particular view of Truth. In other words, let me put it like this: though we all of necessity must hold a particular point of view, though we must adhere to some system of Doctrine, we can't evade that." [00:09:19]
"We must never allow that to turn into a party Spirit. We must never say now the one thing that I must do is that I must arrive at an exposition that fits in with that. Now that is what is so fatal. Though this is true of us, we must come to every particular statement of the scripture with an open mind." [00:10:34]
"We must believe that we have the unction of the Holy Spirit. We must believe that no teachers in the church have had a monopoly of Truth, a complete Monopoly. We must realize that at certain points the best systems can be and indeed are somewhat defective." [00:11:30]
"Now then, let's take a general analysis. I suggest you it can be divided like this: verse 14, here the Apostle makes a general statement about the position and the condition of the man described, whoever he was. He is giving a general description of this man." [00:15:23]
"Now then, what he says here is I am carnal. He doesn't say that the flesh that remained in him was carnal. He doesn't say that there was something that was still within him that was carnal. He says that he himself is carnal. I am carnal." [00:40:18]
"Now those are the only two uses of this word carnal that we find in the scripture. Yet here is a statement made: we know that the law is spiritual, but I am carnal. Are we not already in a position to draw a deduction, an inference?" [00:44:06]
"Very well, my time has gone, and I'm afraid we've got to leave it at that this evening. But it's not a bad point to stop it. We know that the law is spiritual, all right, but I—who is this? Well, all I know about it is this: he is somebody who is carnal." [00:46:12]
"Let us look at these words, these terms. Let us compare scripture with scripture. Let's follow these terms and words through the scriptures wherever we find them so that we shall eventually be able to try to arrive at some kind of a conclusion." [00:47:47]
"We come to thee again, our heavenly Father, and we come to acknowledge and to recognize the Marvel and the Mystery of thy ways, the greatness of thy truth. Oh Lord, we feel that left to ourselves we are indeed utterly hopeless." [00:48:11]
"We thank thee above all for their pattern and example of godliness and Holiness and righteous living. Oh Lord, keep us, we pray thee, ever with a single eye to thy Glory, a concern to Know Thee and the Lord Jesus Christ by the spirit." [00:49:56]
Chatbot
-
I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from May 24, 2017. Do you have any questions about it?