Understanding Grace: Navigating Law, Legalism, and Antinomianism
Summary
In our discussion today, we delved into the intricate and often misunderstood concepts of sanctification, legalism, and antinomianism within the Christian life. These themes are not merely theological abstractions but are deeply rooted in the practical outworking of our faith. The historical context of the Marrow Controversy in 18th century Scotland serves as a backdrop to understand these issues. This controversy highlighted the tension between legalism, which adds to the law of God, and antinomianism, which dismisses it. Both errors stem from a fundamental misunderstanding of God's grace and our union with Christ.
Legalism, in its various forms, often manifests as an attempt to earn God's favor through adherence to the law, while antinomianism dismisses the law's role in guiding Christian conduct. Both are rooted in a failure to grasp the fullness of the gospel and the transformative power of being united with Christ. This union is not just a theological concept but a living reality that shapes our obedience and sanctification. It is through this union that we are empowered by the Holy Spirit to live lives that reflect Christ's character.
The law, far from being a burden, is a reflection of God's character and a guide for our lives. It is fulfilled in us as we walk by the Spirit, not by our own strength. This understanding helps us navigate the Christian life without falling into the traps of legalism or antinomianism. Assurance of salvation, a concern for many believers, is found in the witness of the Holy Spirit and the fruit of our lives. It is through the Spirit's work that we cry out "Abba, Father," and it is through His discipline that we are reminded of our status as God's children.
Key Takeaways:
- Legalism and antinomianism are not opposites but errors stemming from a misunderstanding of God's grace. Both fail to appreciate the transformative power of our union with Christ, which is central to the Christian life. [05:19]
- The law of God is not a means to earn salvation but a guide for living in response to God's grace. It reflects His character and is fulfilled in us as we walk by the Spirit, highlighting the importance of understanding the indicative and imperative aspects of Scripture. [12:53]
- Assurance of salvation is rooted in the witness of the Holy Spirit and the fruit of our lives. The Spirit's work in us confirms our status as God's children and empowers us to live in obedience to His commands. [50:52]
- The Christian life is a journey of growing in grace, marked by the Spirit's work in conforming us to Christ's image. This process involves both the joy of obedience and the struggle against sin, reminding us of our dependence on God's grace. [31:52]
- Understanding our union with Christ is crucial for navigating the tensions between law and grace. This union empowers us to live out the imperatives of the gospel, grounded in the indicatives of what Christ has done for us. [23:21]
Youtube Chapters:
[00:00] - Welcome
[00:09] - Introduction to Sanctification
[01:15] - The Marrow Controversy Explained
[02:53] - Legalism and Antinomianism Defined
[05:19] - Errors of Legalism and Antinomianism
[09:24] - The Role of the Law in Christian Life
[12:53] - Indicative and Imperative in Scripture
[17:27] - Misunderstanding God's Character
[23:21] - Union with Christ as the Antidote
[31:52] - The Role of the Holy Spirit
[39:27] - Preaching and Teaching the Gospel
[49:35] - Assurance of Salvation
[56:30] - Comparing Our Sanctification
[58:56] - Exhortation to the Church
[01:06:33] - Closing Remarks
Study Guide
Bible Study Discussion Guide
Bible Reading:
1. Romans 8:1-4
2. Galatians 2:20
3. Romans 6:1-14
---
Observation Questions:
1. What are the key differences between legalism and antinomianism as discussed in the sermon? [05:19]
2. How does the sermon describe the role of the Holy Spirit in fulfilling the law in our lives? [16:41]
3. What historical context does the sermon provide to explain the tension between law and grace? [02:32]
4. According to the sermon, how does our union with Christ empower us to live out the imperatives of the gospel? [23:21]
---
Interpretation Questions:
1. How does the sermon suggest that a misunderstanding of God's character leads to both legalism and antinomianism? [17:27]
2. In what ways does the sermon explain that the law is a reflection of God's character and not a burden? [14:59]
3. How does the sermon describe the assurance of salvation through the witness of the Holy Spirit and the fruit of our lives? [50:52]
4. What does the sermon imply about the importance of understanding the indicative and imperative aspects of Scripture in the Christian life? [12:53]
---
Application Questions:
1. Reflect on your own life: Are there areas where you might be leaning towards legalism or antinomianism? How can you address this imbalance? [05:19]
2. How can you cultivate a deeper understanding of your union with Christ to empower your daily walk with God? What practical steps can you take this week? [23:21]
3. Consider the role of the Holy Spirit in your life. How can you be more attentive to His guidance and empowerment in fulfilling God's law? [16:41]
4. Assurance of salvation is rooted in the witness of the Holy Spirit. How can you become more aware of the Spirit's work in your life and the fruit it produces? [50:52]
5. The sermon discusses the importance of understanding both the indicative and imperative aspects of Scripture. How can you apply this understanding to your Bible study routine? [12:53]
6. Think about a time when you struggled with assurance of salvation. How did you find comfort in the witness of the Holy Spirit or the fruit of your life? [50:52]
7. How can you use the historical context of the Marrow Controversy to better understand and navigate the tensions between law and grace in your own faith journey? [02:32]
Devotional
Day 1: Understanding Grace Beyond Legalism and Antinomianism
Legalism and antinomianism are two sides of the same coin, both arising from a misunderstanding of God's grace. Legalism attempts to earn God's favor through strict adherence to the law, while antinomianism dismisses the law's role in guiding Christian conduct. Both errors fail to appreciate the transformative power of our union with Christ, which is central to the Christian life. This union is not just a theological concept but a living reality that empowers us to live lives that reflect Christ's character. By understanding this, we can avoid the pitfalls of both legalism and antinomianism and embrace a life of grace-filled obedience. [05:19]
Galatians 5:1-2 (ESV): "For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery. Look: I, Paul, say to you that if you accept circumcision, Christ will be of no advantage to you."
Reflection: In what ways have you found yourself leaning towards legalism or antinomianism in your walk with Christ? How can you embrace the freedom found in your union with Christ today?
Day 2: The Law as a Guide, Not a Burden
The law of God is not a means to earn salvation but a guide for living in response to God's grace. It reflects His character and is fulfilled in us as we walk by the Spirit. This understanding highlights the importance of recognizing both the indicative and imperative aspects of Scripture. The indicative tells us what God has done for us, while the imperative instructs us on how to live in response. By walking in the Spirit, we can fulfill the law in a way that is not burdensome but life-giving. [12:53]
Psalm 19:7-8 (ESV): "The law of the Lord is perfect, reviving the soul; the testimony of the Lord is sure, making wise the simple; the precepts of the Lord are right, rejoicing the heart; the commandment of the Lord is pure, enlightening the eyes."
Reflection: How do you perceive God's law in your life? Can you identify one area where you can allow the Spirit to guide you in fulfilling the law joyfully?
Day 3: Assurance Through the Spirit's Witness
Assurance of salvation is rooted in the witness of the Holy Spirit and the fruit of our lives. The Spirit's work in us confirms our status as God's children and empowers us to live in obedience to His commands. It is through the Spirit that we cry out "Abba, Father," and it is through His discipline that we are reminded of our identity in Christ. This assurance is not based on our performance but on the Spirit's ongoing work in our hearts, producing the fruit of righteousness. [50:52]
Romans 8:16-17 (ESV): "The Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God, and if children, then heirs—heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ, provided we suffer with him in order that we may also be glorified with him."
Reflection: Reflect on the fruit of the Spirit in your life. How does the Spirit's witness provide you with assurance of your salvation today?
Day 4: Growing in Grace Through the Spirit's Work
The Christian life is a journey of growing in grace, marked by the Spirit's work in conforming us to Christ's image. This process involves both the joy of obedience and the struggle against sin, reminding us of our dependence on God's grace. As we grow, we experience the transformative power of the Spirit, who empowers us to live out the imperatives of the gospel. This growth is not linear but involves continual reliance on God's grace and the Spirit's guidance. [31:52]
2 Corinthians 3:18 (ESV): "And we all, with unveiled face, beholding the glory of the Lord, are being transformed into the same image from one degree of glory to another. For this comes from the Lord who is the Spirit."
Reflection: In what areas of your life do you see the Spirit's transformative work? How can you cooperate with the Spirit in your journey of growing in grace?
Day 5: Union with Christ as the Foundation
Understanding our union with Christ is crucial for navigating the tensions between law and grace. This union empowers us to live out the imperatives of the gospel, grounded in the indicatives of what Christ has done for us. It is through this union that we are empowered by the Holy Spirit to live lives that reflect Christ's character. By embracing this union, we can live in the freedom and power of the Spirit, fulfilling the law in a way that honors God. [23:21]
Colossians 3:3-4 (ESV): "For you have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God. When Christ who is your life appears, then you also will appear with him in glory."
Reflection: How does your understanding of your union with Christ influence your daily life? What practical steps can you take to live out this union more fully today?
Quotes
"Legalism and antinomianism are not opposites or they're not at two different poles. They're essentially errors of the same sort. Both of them sort of grow out of a lack of understanding and a lack of appropriately valuing the grace of God and what the gospel does and our union to Christ by faith." [00:05:19]
"Legalism is a merit-based system in its greater form and in its lesser form it is trying to still earn God's love and in one sense God's favor by doing things for God meritoriously. So that's legalism at least in part. Antinomianism, of course, just roughly translated means anti-law or anti-lawism." [00:09:24]
"The law of God is never depersonalized. It is an expression of the character of our Heavenly Father given to us in the form in which we live to image him in his glory, namely as creatures who are entirely dependent upon him and sinners who need to be united to Christ and those who are frail and need to be filled with the Holy Spirit." [00:46:33]
"Assurance of salvation is rooted in the witness of the Holy Spirit and the fruit of our lives. The Spirit's work in us confirms our status as God's children and empowers us to live in obedience to His commands. It is through the Spirit's work that we cry out 'Abba, Father.'" [00:50:52]
"The Christian life is a journey of growing in grace, marked by the Spirit's work in conforming us to Christ's image. This process involves both the joy of obedience and the struggle against sin, reminding us of our dependence on God's grace." [00:31:52]
"Understanding our union with Christ is crucial for navigating the tensions between law and grace. This union empowers us to live out the imperatives of the gospel, grounded in the indicatives of what Christ has done for us." [00:23:21]
"The Holy Spirit unites us to Christ by faith. As a result of that, Paul is able to see what the law could not do because it was weakened through our flesh, God has done, sending his son in the likeness of the flesh of sin and for sin, in order that the just requirements of the law might be fulfilled in us." [00:16:12]
"The law, far from being a burden, is a reflection of God's character and a guide for our lives. It is fulfilled in us as we walk by the Spirit, not by our own strength. This understanding helps us navigate the Christian life without falling into the traps of legalism or antinomianism." [00:12:53]
"One of the chief ways as Dr. Ferguson deals with it, as we've already mentioned, is in the inward way, the spiritual way in which the Holy Spirit bears witness with our spirits and leads us to cry out 'Abba, Father.' That is one of the most foundational evidences that we are his." [00:51:52]
"Very few Christians actually come out directly and outrightly reject the third use of the law saying it doesn't apply to us. It's rather in the more practical and applicational aspects in preaching and living and writing. It's what they don't emphasize what is often most common in our day." [00:10:15]
"The Spirit is the one who is fighting within us and for us and helping us to fight the good fight as we kill sin as we mortify sin in the flesh. And so, Nathan, as you know, I preached a few years ago through James epistle and then and Sunday evenings through John's epistles." [00:39:27]
"Paul's key to both legalism and antinomianism, and fascinatingly here to deal with both, appears to be one and the same remedy or medicine. He takes both back to union with Christ. For example, the Galatians and the kind of legalism that they were in danger of falling prey to." [00:23:21]
Chatbot
-
I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Aug 24, 2016. Do you have any questions about it?