Tough Questions - What about?

Antiques Roadshow imagery frames a theme: things that look old and irrelevant can hold great value. The Bible contains passages that feel like that same hidden treasure—verses that jar, shock, or seem out of step with modern sensibilities. Two foundational convictions anchor the approach: all Scripture comes from God and remains useful for teaching, correcting, and equipping; and taking Scripture seriously changes thinking, shaping values and revealing blind spots that demand reorientation toward God's will.

A practical four-step method guides reading difficult passages. First, identify what is being read: the Bible includes genres—poetry, prophecy, narrative—and each demands a different reading posture. Second, locate the historical moment: ask who wrote, to whom, and under what circumstances. Third, place the passage within the grand story of redemption that culminates in Christ, so that isolated lines do not override the overarching narrative. Fourth, consult the rest of Scripture: let clearer, recurring teaching interpret the harder texts rather than building doctrine on a single verse.

Psalm 137 provides a careful case study. Reading it as lament clarifies that the brutal language expresses the raw cries of a traumatized people, not divine prescription. The psalm emerges from the horrors of Jerusalem’s destruction and exile, where captors mocked grief and kin betrayed kin. Within that painful context, the psalmist speaks candidly, calling on God’s justice with imagery available at that moment. Placing the psalm in the broader biblical story shows that this outcry predates the cross; later revelation in Christ reconciles justice and mercy without endorsing retaliatory violence.

The New Testament models a different posture toward injustice: Jesus confronts evil without returning violence, teaches love for enemies, and invites trust that God sees and will ultimately vindicate wrongs. Hard passages therefore perform pastoral work: they give permission to bring honest grief to God, expose moral tensions, and drive readers toward deeper trust and transformation. Wrestling with difficult texts proves not a failure of faith but an act of faithfulness—one that trusts the Spirit to bring clarity and renewal over time. The Bible’s hardest lines remain part of God’s provision for growth; careful reading, historical grounding, narrative perspective, and cross-textual comparison unlock their value for formation and hope.

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. All Scripture is God-breathed and useful All parts of the Bible originate from God and serve practical purposes: teaching truth, exposing error, correcting course, and equipping for good works. Treating no passage as expendable preserves the integrity of Scripture and prevents cherry-picking the comfortable while dismissing the demanding. This conviction calls readers to humility: difficult verses belong within the canon’s formative work, not outside it. [05:19]
• 2. Scripture reshapes the way one thinks Reading Scripture invites cognitive and moral transformation, not mere information intake. Confrontation with biblical truth exposes blind spots and reorders affections so life aligns with God’s good, pleasing, and perfect will. The tension between cultural thinking and Scripture often signals the place where transformation begins. [07:59]
• 3. Identify genre and context first Recognize whether a text functions as poetry, lament, narrative, or law before forming conclusions about its meaning or application. Genre determines whether language speaks descriptively, prescriptively, metaphorically, or legislatively; misreading genre leads to misapplied doctrine or moral error. Grounding interpretation in context prevents forcing modern frameworks onto ancient speech. [12:57]
• 4. Bring raw grief honestly to God Laments model bringing anger, betrayal, and rage into God’s presence without pretending to neat theology. Honest cries allow wounded people to entrust pain to God and call on divine justice while refusing to convert trauma into sanctioned violence. The Bible invites candid petition and promises that ultimate vindication finds its shape in Christ. [16:19]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [00:19] - Antiques Roadshow Analogy
• [04:09] - The “What about?” Question
• [05:19] - All Scripture Is Useful
• [07:59] - Scripture Changes Thinking
• [12:57] - Four Steps For Hard Passages
• [14:41] - Reading Psalm 137 Aloud
• [16:19] - Lament: What It Means
• [18:32] - Historical Context: Exile Explained
• [21:58] - Where This Fits In The Story
• [24:33] - Jesus, Justice, And Nonviolence
• [26:43] - How To Approach Tough Texts
• [28:50] - Prayer and Closing

Bible reading
Psalm 137:1–9 (ESV)
By the waters of Babylon, there we sat down and wept, when we remembered Zion. On the willows there we hung up our lyres. For there our captors required of us songs, and our tormentors, mirth, saying, “Sing us one of the songs of Zion!” How shall we sing the Lord’s song in a foreign land? If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its skill! Let my tongue stick to the roof of my mouth, if I do not remember you, if I do not set Jerusalem above my highest joy! Remember, O Lord, against the Edomites the day of Jerusalem, how they said, “Lay it bare, lay it bare, down to its foundations!” O daughter of Babylon, doomed to be destroyed, blessed shall he be who repays you with what you have done to us! Blessed shall he be who takes your little ones and dashes them against the rock!

---

Observation questions

1. What specific historical event is the author of Psalm 137 responding to, and what emotions are expressed?
2. How do the Babylonians intensify the pain of the Israelites in verses 1–4?
3. What does the psalmist ask God to “remember” in verse 7, and what does he call for in response?
4. According to the sermon, what type of biblical writing is Psalm 137, and how should that shape our reading? [16:19]

---

Interpretation questions

1. Why is it significant that this psalm is a lament spoken *to* God rather than a command spoken *from* God?
2. How does understanding the historical context of exile and violence help make sense of the raw language used in this psalm? [18:32]
3. How does the psalmist’s cry for justice reflect their understanding of God’s character, even before the full revelation of Christ?
4. In what ways does the New Testament reaffirm the psalmist’s desire for justice while redirecting how God’s people respond to evil? [24:33]

---

Application questions

1. When have you felt tension or discomfort reading certain parts of the Bible? How can the four steps (identify genre, historical context, place in the big story, compare with other Scripture) help you engage rather than avoid those passages? [12:57]
2. The psalms give us permission to bring raw emotions to God. What would it look like for you to be more honest with God in prayer when you feel anger, grief, or confusion?
3. How can remembering that “all Scripture is God-breathed and useful” change your approach to reading parts of the Bible that seem difficult or outdated? [05:19]
4. In what areas of your life do you sense a tension between cultural values and biblical teaching? How might God be using that tension to reshape your thinking? [07:59]
5. When you see injustice in the world, how can you balance the desire for justice with Jesus’ call to love enemies and trust God’s ultimate judgment? [24:33]
6. How can you support others who are struggling with grief or anger by pointing them toward honest prayer, like we see in the psalms?