Joshua arrives at Shechem cleaned up for a speech, but the road behind him runs through blood. The book of Joshua names God as commander of an army that destroyed city after city, leaving “no one remaining.” That terrible claim cannot be softened into something polite. It forces the question: is this really the word of God?
Paul brings a different offense in Ephesians. Wives are told to be subject to husbands, while husbands are told to love their wives as their own bodies and give themselves up as Christ gave himself up for the church. Paul’s words challenged men who treated wives and children as property, yet those same words still leave hard questions in the room. Scripture does not hand over only agreeable texts.
Jesus raises the offense even higher in John 6. Jesus calls himself living bread, then speaks of flesh to be chewed and blood to be guzzled. The image sounds like a butcher shop, not a sanctuary, and it violates everything faithful Jews had been taught about blood. When disciples call the teaching difficult, Jesus does not make it easier. Jesus asks whether they, too, wish to go away.
Peter stays, not because he finds Jesus easy to understand or pleasant to approve. Peter stays because he has seen something in Jesus that he cannot turn away from. Peter has glimpsed God. “Lord, to whom can we go?” becomes the cry of someone willing to struggle with a box full of snakes rather than abandon the truth he has found.
The church remains an offense in much the same way. Churches carry hypocrisy, sexism, liberals, conservatives, bureaucracy, arguments over hymn books, fundraising, and plenty more besides. Yet the desire for a community that agrees on everything leaves only a church of one member. Wherever people are people, there will be things that offend.
Christ’s body joins flawed people to one another as surely as it joins them to him. The church gives ugly, difficult texts, but it also gives the prodigal son, the twenty-third psalm, and a liturgy that can take the breath away. The church needs other people to save it from self-righteousness and keep it in shape for God. Where else can anyone go, when this is where the words of eternal life have been heard and the Holy One of God has been known?
Key Takeaways
- 1. Hard texts must not be sanitized. Joshua’s violence cannot be made harmless by skipping over the details. Scripture sometimes confronts faith with claims that disturb moral instincts and resist easy answers. Honest faith does not pretend those texts are not there, nor does it rush to explain away the horror. [27:44]
- 2. Jesus does not always make belief easier. Jesus hears the disciples call his words difficult, yet he does not dilute the language of flesh and blood. His call reaches beyond mere intellectual approval or personal comfort. Faith sometimes means remaining before Christ when the mind wants a cleaner, safer version of him. [32:28]
- 3. Peter stays because he has seen God. Peter is not pictured as enjoying the thought of gnawing flesh and drinking blood. Peter stays because Jesus has become the place where eternal life is found. A faith that has truly glimpsed God can endure confusion without calling confusion the final truth. [35:57]
- 4. No church can agree on everything. The demand for a community that perfectly matches personal convictions ends in isolation. Imperfect communities can wound, frustrate, and offend, but they also expose self-righteousness and teach patience with sincere disagreement. The church becomes Christ’s body precisely among people who cannot make themselves into one mind. [37:53]
- 5. The church holds eternal-life treasures. The church carries much that wears people down, yet it also bears the words of eternal life. Its worship, Scripture, sacraments, and shared confession point beyond its many failures to the Holy One of God. Those treasures change the question from whether offense exists to what offense love can bear. [41:07]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [25:14] - Scriptures That Offend Everyone
- [25:43] - Joshua and the Violence of Conquest
- [27:44] - Is This Really the Word of God?
- [28:13] - Wives, Husbands, and Ephesians
- [30:02] - Jesus, the Bread of Heaven
- [31:24] - Flesh to Chew and Blood to Drink
- [32:28] - When Jesus Will Not Make It Easier
- [34:45] - Peter’s Question: Where Else Can We Go?
- [36:28] - The Temptation to Leave Church
- [37:53] - The Myth of the Perfect Church
- [39:55] - Kept in Shape for God
- [40:46] - Words of Eternal Life