THE HEART OF THE TITHER w/Pastor Melanie Craft

The call to cut the purse strings that bind the heart starts with freedom, not bondage. Christ has set His people free, and the tithe is not meant to jerk anybody around with guilt. The law of Moses gives the old foundation, and that foundation can feel lifeless at first because there are so many rules, offerings, and requirements. The Levitical tithe supported the house of God, the festival tithe made worship and community possible, and the poor tithe cared for widows, orphans, and those in need.

The Old Testament tithe shows God’s mercy because God told His people what He required of their hearts. Malachi brings the sharp word, “Will a man rob God?” and then gives the stunning invitation, “test me now in this.” Proverbs ties honor to firstfruits, barns filled with plenty, and vats overflowing with new wine. Creation itself keeps preaching seedtime and harvest, planting and reaping, because giving is built into the universe.

Money is not good or evil. Money is neutral, a tool, but the way money is handled reveals what is in the heart. Hezekiah becomes the big warning and the big mirror. Hezekiah came from an evil father, but he reached back and grabbed the righteous seed of David. He cleaned the temple, restored sacrifices, restored the tithe, and brought righteousness back to Judah. Yet when God blessed him, healed him, and even moved the shadow backward, Hezekiah failed to return glory to God and showed Babylon all his wealth.

The heart can deteriorate when it is not actively occupied, just like an empty house falls apart faster. God sometimes steps back, not to abandon His child, but to let the heart be seen. That same test can come through lack, repair bills, fear, or sudden need. Gratitude becomes the way back, because when people know God but neither honor Him as God nor give thanks, the mind gets dark.

The Scriptures keep showing money tests. The rich young ruler went away sad, Judas stole from Jesus’ purse, Israel carried Egypt’s gold into the wilderness and made an idol, Job lost everything and still showed that God had his heart, and Paul learned contentment with little or much. The goal is freedom, so the enemy cannot pull the strings through the pocketbook. Kingdom provision is not finally based on the economy, fear, or control. Holy Spirit, gratitude, stewardship, and obedience bring the heart back under God’s rule.

##

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. Money reveals the hidden heart Money is neutral, but the heart is never neutral toward it. The spending, withholding, fearing, and grasping all begin to show what has been occupying the soul. God does not need money in the way fear imagines, but He does want the place in the heart that money so often grabs. [30:12]
• 2. God tests hearts through provision Hezekiah’s story shows that blessing can test the heart just as surely as lack can. The danger was not simply having wealth, but receiving benefit without returning glory to God. God sometimes steps back so the heart can see what has been growing unnoticed. [36:30]
• 3. Gratitude amends the soil Gratitude is not a small emotional exercise. Gratitude brings the heart back to honoring God as God, especially when fear and control have begun to talk louder than trust. The soil of the heart receives the word differently when thanksgiving has softened it. [56:59]
• 4. The enemy pulls purse strings The enemy loves to jerk people around by the pocketbook because money can feel like safety, power, and control. The call to give is not about funding a need first, but about getting free from those strings. A heart ruled by God cannot be bought, threatened, or baited so easily. [51:50]
• 5. Kingdom provision outlives economies Kingdom provision does not cancel stewardship, work, or wisdom. It does put fear in its place by refusing to make the economy the final word over God’s people. God has proven Himself able to provide when natural math says the thing should not work.
  
  ## [65:46]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [20:39] - Cutting Purse Strings
• [22:23] - Old Testament Tithes
• [27:17] - Malachi and Testing God
• [28:28] - Seedtime, Harvest, and Money
• [30:12] - Money Reveals the Heart
• [30:51] - Hezekiah’s Money Test
• [37:14] - A Personal Tithing Testimony
• [44:45] - Biblical Money Tests
• [51:03] - Paul’s Contentment in Context
• [55:21] - When God Shows the Heart
• [56:59] - Gratitude as Repentance
• [60:54] - Giving in the New Testament
• [64:06] - Freedom From Financial Fear
• [67:43] - Prayer Exercise in Gratitude

Bible Reading

Malachi 3:8-10
“Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, ‘How have we robbed you?’ In your tithes and contributions. You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you. Bring the full tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. And thereby put me to the test, says the LORD of hosts, if I will not open the windows of heaven for you and pour down for you a blessing until there is no more need.” [27:12]

Proverbs 3:9-10
“Honor the LORD with your wealth and with the firstfruits of all your produce; then your barns will be filled with plenty, and your vats will be bursting with wine.” [28:07]

2 Chronicles 29-32
The story of Hezekiah's reign, including his reforms, restoration of the temple and tithe, his illness and healing, and his failure to give glory to God for his wealth when he showed it to the Babylonian envoys. [30:51]

Philippians 4:11-13
“Not that I am speaking of being in need, for I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content. I know how to be brought low, and I know how to abound. In any and every circumstance, I have learned the secret of facing plenty and hunger, abundance and need. I can do all things through him who strengthens me.” [51:03]

Romans 1:21
“For although they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their foolish hearts were darkened.” [57:06]

Observation questions

1. In Malachi 3:8-10, what does God say the people are withholding, and what invitation does He give them in response? [27:12]
2. In Proverbs 3:9-10, what is connected to honoring the Lord with wealth and firstfruits?
3. What are some of the things Hezekiah did right before his heart was exposed later on? [32:08]
4. In Philippians 4:11-13, what different financial or life situations does Paul say he has learned to live through? [51:03]

Interpretation questions

1. Malachi says withholding tithes and contributions is robbing God. What does that reveal about how God views giving—not just as a budget issue, but as a heart issue before Him?
2. Hezekiah restored worship, gave generously, and saw God move powerfully, yet later failed to return glory to God. What does that suggest about how blessing can test a person just as much as suffering can? [36:14]
3. Romans 1:21 connects not honoring God and not giving thanks with darkened thinking. How might gratitude protect a person from financial fear, control, or spiritual drift? [56:59]
4. Paul says he learned contentment in both little and much. How does that reshape the meaning of “I can do all things through Christ” when money and provision feel uncertain? [51:17]

Application questions

1. Money reveals what is happening in the heart. When financial pressure rises, what usually comes out first in this season—peace, fear, control, resentment, generosity, or something else? [30:25]
2. The enemy loves to pull people around through the pocketbook. Where does financial fear most often try to control decisions right now—giving, saving, spending, work, helping others, or trusting God for the future? [52:09]
3. Gratitude softens the soil of the heart. What is one specific way to practice gratitude this week when thinking about finances, needs, or uncertainty? [59:40]
4. Hezekiah received benefit but did not return glory to God. Is there an area of provision, success, or stability that has quietly become easy to take credit for or simply enjoy without thanking God? [33:18]
5. Paul learned contentment with little and with much. Which of those is harder right now—to trust God in lack or to stay humble and dependent in abundance? Why? [51:27]
6. Kingdom provision does not remove the need for wisdom, work, or stewardship, but it does put fear in its place. What would it look like to make one financial decision this month from faith and wisdom instead of anxiety? [01:06:55]
7. Giving is meant to lead into freedom, not bondage. What would freedom from money’s grip look like in real life for you or your household over the next few months? [01:04:08]