Our minds are constantly interpreting events, assigning meaning, and creating narratives about why people act the way they do. These stories feel true because they make sense to us, but sense-making is not the same as truth. Once a story is in place, it begins to shape our emotions, our assumptions about others' motives, and ultimately, our relationships. Wisdom calls us to be aware of this automatic process. [05:04]
A fool takes no pleasure in understanding, but only in expressing his opinion. (Proverbs 18:2, ESV)
Reflection: Recall a recent interaction where you felt a strong negative emotion. What was the specific story you told yourself about the other person’s intentions? How might your feelings change if that story wasn’t entirely accurate?
True wisdom is characterized by patience and a willingness to live without an immediate answer. It resists the urge to rush to certainty and instead seeks to understand. This means stopping the habit of mind-reading—assuming we know what others are thinking—and choosing curiosity over judgment. Such slowness creates space for God to reveal what is actually true. [12:06]
The heart of the discerning acquires knowledge, for the ears of the wise seek it out. (Proverbs 18:15, ESV)
Reflection: Where in your life are you most tempted to react quickly instead of seeking understanding? What is one practical step you could take this week to create a pause between an event and your interpretation of it?
Bearing false witness begins not in a courtroom but in our own minds when we assign meaning to someone’s actions without verification. When we distort reality with our internal narratives, we damage relationships and create a counterfeit world where God has little room to speak. Emotional health requires a submission to reality, even when it is uncomfortable or unclear. [15:25]
You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor. (Exodus 20:16, ESV)
Reflection: Is there a relationship in your life where distance has been created by a story you’ve believed without checking? What would it look like to humbly question that narrative and seek the truth?
Mary models a vital spiritual posture: she treasured events in her heart and pondered them. This is not passive inaction but an active trust that refuses to rush to meaning before its time. It is a discipline of holding things together, turning them over, and making room for God to reveal Himself rather than flattening events with our own instant interpretations. [19:33]
But Mary treasured up all these things and pondered them in her heart. (Luke 2:19, ESV)
Reflection: When faced with uncertainty or pain, what is your default response? How might you practice “pondering” this week—holding a situation before God without demanding an immediate explanation?
Faith is not a means of controlling outcomes but a posture of continued trust when our plans fall apart. We all carry unconscious expectations of God about how our lives should turn out. Healing begins when we honestly bring our disappointment to Him, releasing our imagined agreements and receiving the life He is actually giving, which often looks different than what we expected. [37:41]
And he said to her, “Daughter, your faith has made you well; go in peace, and be healed of your disease.” (Mark 5:34, ESV)
Reflection: What is one area of your life where you have been holding onto a silent expectation of how God should act? What would it look like to release that expectation to Him and trust His character instead of your desired outcome?
Attention centers on how meaning-making shapes relationships and spiritual life. People naturally tell stories about others' words and actions, and those stories often harden into convictions that drive emotion and distance. Wisdom literature urges slowness: listen, receive, and resist the urge to interpret before facts are in. Bearing false witness begins not at trial but in the heart when assumptions replace reality; truth-loving community requires humility, curiosity, and a willingness to live for a time without immediate answers.
The talk contrasts two habits that fracture relationships: mind‑reading and unspoken expectations. Mind‑reading invents motives and then treats those inventions as fact; expectations operate as invisible standards that go unnamed until disappointment exposes them. Healthy relationships practice naming, negotiating, and when needed, grieving expectations—sometimes demoting an expectation into a hope and allowing space for loss and lament. Grief, rightly held, prevents cynicism and keeps the heart soft.
Scripture provides models and corrective: Proverbs commends patience and listening; Exodus forbids false testimony to protect communal reality; Mary’s posture—treasuring and pondering—models restraint that makes room for God’s voice. The Mark 5 narrative reframes prayerful faith: the synagogue leader and the marginalized woman both come with plans, but Jesus refuses to be managed by their urgency; what arrives is resurrection, not mere rescue. Faith, therefore, is not a mechanism of control but sustained trust when human plans unravel.
The invitation is practical and spiritual: stop mind‑reading, clarify expectations, cultivate humility, and bring unmet hopes into the light before God. Surrender is not passive resignation but an opening that lets God reorient desire and heal disappointment. The season of communal formation invites honesty with God, mutual confession, and asking the Spirit to separate truth from the lies that harden hearts. The work of emotional health is framed as discipleship—learning to love in reality rather than in imagined narratives.
Maybe some of the distance you have with folks in your life didn't begin with betrayal. Maybe not everybody's actually out to get you. Maybe, some of the distance that's happened in your life with the people around you is it began with some sort of certainty about we the way they are, what they're thinking about things, how they process the world, and god's inviting you. Hear this if you hear nothing else this morning to humility. God's inviting you to curiosity, to a willingness to delay judgment long enough to discover what's true, and then even then entrust them unto the lord.
[00:17:18]
(44 seconds)
#ChooseCuriosity
If you feel far from God, can I just remind you that there is nowhere you can go from his presence? You may have a whole lot of, like, calluses around your heart and mind. May have a whole lot of unbelief. But we are the ones who are distant, not God. I take so much relief in that. God is at the door inviting us. Hey, when you're ready, come on through.
[00:47:33]
(48 seconds)
#GodIsAlwaysNear
Human beings are meaning makers by default. We don't just see facts. We what? We we interpret them. We don't just observe behavior. We explain behavior. Your brain is constantly asking questions like, why did this happen? What did this mean? What does this say about me? What does this say about them? And it does this really fast and really automatically before you're even aware that a story has formed. And the story feels true because it makes sense, not necessarily because it's true.
[00:09:17]
(37 seconds)
#MindMakesMeaning
We expect people to be available in ways that no human can sustain. We expect leaders to see everything, friends to intuit our needs. Churches should be like acts two all the time, which, by the way, acts two is the beginning of the story, and the rest of the New Testament exists because community got really messy and conflicts happened and all the expectations failed. People are finite. Churches are made of sinners.
[00:27:57]
(23 seconds)
#PeopleAreFinite
And grief here as a follower of Jesus is a gift because grief is what keeps disappointment from turning into cynicism. When you we don't grieve, we get really hard. Our heart like calluses over. You start to, like at least I start to kinda spiritualize withdrawal. We sort of justify the distance that we have from other people. We protect ourselves from being hurt again. Anyone do that? In other words, we stop moving toward love.
[00:31:13]
(39 seconds)
#GriefProtectsLove
Somewhere along the way, disappointment settled in because your life did not turn out the way you had expected it to. And there's this distance. I know I've already said this, but God is not threatened by your honesty. God is not offended by your grief, and healing does not come from pretending you're fine.
[00:43:54]
(26 seconds)
#HonestyHeals
And so when we replace reality with the story we told ourselves, we don't just damage relationships. We also edge out god. Say with me. God does not exist in imagined versions of events. Right? God exists in truth, in reality, what actually is. And when we choose our narrative over reality, we create a counterfeit world, one where God has very, very, very little room to speak.
[00:16:15]
(28 seconds)
#TruthMakesSpaceForGod
We don't always call them expectations, but that's what they are. Underneath them is really something simpler, which is control. There's, like, a quiet transaction that we never really named. I will follow you. I will obey. I'll trust. And in return, you will fill in the blank. You will protect me. You will keep this from getting too painful. You'll make my progress more visible. We expect God to manage suffering,
[00:32:36]
(36 seconds)
#ExpectationsAreControl
I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Feb 10, 2026. Do you have any questions about it?
Add this chatbot onto your site with the embed code below
<iframe frameborder="0" src="https://pastors.ai/sermonWidget/sermon/stories-we-tell-ourselves-mook" width="100%" height="100%" style="height:100vh;"></iframe>Copy