Staying Present in the Midst of Uncertainty

Uncertainty can make a person want answers right now, control right now, safety right now. Over the Garden Wall gives that feeling a strange little home in Pottsfield, where two lost brothers, Wirt and Greg, meet pumpkin-headed townsfolk, a giant scary figure, and an assignment to dig what look like graves. Wirt and Beatrice carry suspicion and fear, while Greg dances through the weirdness with a frog on his head and a pumpkin stuck to his foot. Pottsfield eventually reveals that its people are not dangerous at all. The town is a place for the dead to rise, put on pumpkins, and celebrate being together.

The unknown, however, still feels dangerous before its meaning is revealed. Discomfort starts driving behavior when people cannot make sense of what is happening. Certainty then begins to feel like a God-given right, something owed and something to obtain by any means necessary. That demand for clarification can become its own shallow kind of control.

Present uncertainty offers another way. Present uncertainty means staying honest about fear without allowing fear to run the whole show. Curiosity can return after discomfort is allowed to exist for a moment. Awe and wonder can then show up even in places that are creepy, inconvenient, or completely unclear.

First Kings places Elijah in a far more serious unknown. Elijah has confronted the prophets of Baal, called down fire, and seen the people recognize the one true God. Jezebel responds with a death threat, and Elijah runs into the mountains, exhausted, afraid, and hidden in a cave. God asks, “What are you doing in this cave?” and calls Elijah out to wait on the mountain.

God does not arrive in the mighty wind, the earthquake, or the fire. God comes after the loud displays of power in a sound thin and quiet. Elijah’s fear does not cancel his faithfulness. Elijah stays there, sweating and shifty and surely wanting the safety of the cave, until the quiet presence of God meets him.

The contrast between Pottsfield and Elijah holds an important tension. Pottsfield’s danger turns out to be only unknown danger, while Elijah faces real danger from a real queen. Presence remains the invitation in both places. Medical results, financial pressure, and the overwhelming uncertainty of the world may not come with a clear path forward, but the unexpected does not have to steal the present moment. The rhythm of the unexpected can still become the place where a person listens, settles, and discovers that being present is possible.

##

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. Certainty is not a human right Uncertainty often exposes the desire to control what cannot be controlled. That desire can make clarification feel morally necessary, when it may simply be anxiety demanding relief. Presentness loosens the grip of that demand and makes room for a more honest response. [48:35]
• 2. Stay present inside the discomfort Present uncertainty does not deny fear or pretend that hard situations are easy. Present uncertainty names the discomfort, sits with it, and refuses to let it dictate every next move. Curiosity can return when fear is no longer forced to disappear immediately. [49:18]
• 3. God is not always in spectacle Elijah expects God while surrounded by wind, earthquake, and fire. God passes by in a sound thin and quiet, after the dramatic signs have passed. Quiet attention may be more faithful than chasing a louder answer. [53:20]
• 4. Real danger does not cancel faithfulness Elijah’s fear is not treated as proof that he lacks faith. Elijah remains human, tired, hunted, and deeply unsure, yet he still steps out of the cave when God calls. Faithfulness can look like staying available to God when safety feels far away. [53:53]
• 5. The unexpected can hold wonder Pottsfield first looks threatening because its meaning is hidden. The strange town becomes a picture of community and celebration once the truth comes out. The unknown may still be hard, but it does not automatically deserve a fearful interpretation.
  
  ## [54:39]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [41:30] - Finding Sacred Truths in Cartoons
• [42:56] - Lost in Over the Garden Wall
• [43:33] - The Strange Town of Pottsfield
• [47:24] - When Discomfort Takes Control
• [49:18] - Learning to Be Presently Uncertain
• [49:57] - Elijah, Ahab, and Jezebel
• [51:27] - Elijah Runs to the Cave
• [53:20] - God in the Thin Quiet Sound
• [54:12] - Pottsfield’s Unexpected Truth
• [55:22] - Staying Present in Real Uncertainty
• [56:05] - The Beauty of Not Knowing

Bible Reading

1 Kings 19:9-13
“And there he came to a cave and lodged in it. And behold, the word of the Lord came to him, and he said to him, “What are you doing here, Elijah?” He said, “I have been very jealous for the Lord, the God of hosts. For the people of Israel have forsaken your covenant, thrown down your altars, and killed your prophets with the sword, and I, even I only, am left, and they seek my life, to take it away.” And he said, “Go out and stand on the mount before the Lord.” And behold, the Lord passed by, and a great and strong wind tore the mountains and broke in pieces the rocks before the Lord, but the Lord was not in the wind. And after the wind an earthquake, but the Lord was not in the earthquake. And after the earthquake a fire, but the Lord was not in the fire. And after the fire the sound of a low whisper. And when Elijah heard it, he wrapped his face in his cloak and went out and stood at the entrance of the cave. And behold, there came a voice to him and said, “What are you doing here, Elijah?” [51:55]

Observation questions

1. What question does God ask Elijah when he is hiding in the cave, and what does Elijah’s answer reveal about his state of mind? [52:01]
2. What powerful events happen on the mountain before the thin, quiet sound, and how does the passage distinguish those events from God’s presence? [53:14]
3. What details make Pottsfield seem dangerous to Wirt and Beatrice, and how does Greg respond differently to the same strange setting? [47:12]
4. What difference is drawn between the uncertainty in Pottsfield and the uncertainty Elijah faces? [54:19]

Interpretation questions

1. Why might God ask Elijah what he is doing in the cave instead of immediately removing the threat from Jezebel or giving Elijah a detailed plan?
2. What does God’s presence in the thin, quiet sound suggest about the ways people may expect God to show up during fearful or confusing seasons? [53:20]
3. Elijah had just witnessed an extraordinary display of God’s power, yet he still ran in fear. What does this reveal about the relationship between faithfulness, fear, exhaustion, and real danger? [52:50]
4. Why can the demand for immediate clarity become a form of control rather than an expression of trust? [48:26]

Application questions

1. What uncertainty is most likely to make you demand answers right away—health concerns, finances, relationships, work, family, or something else? How does that demand affect your thoughts, choices, or relationships? [48:35]
2. When fear rises, what does “the cave” look like in your life? Is it withdrawing from people, overplanning, scrolling, numbing out, trying to fix everything, or something else?
3. Elijah steps out and remains available to God even while the danger is real. What would it look like for you to take one faithful next step without pretending that your fear is not real? [53:53]
4. Where might you be looking for God only in something dramatic—a quick answer, a big sign, or a complete solution—while overlooking quieter ways God may be present? [53:24]
5. What practice could help you stay present when uncertainty shows up this week: a short prayer, a walk without distractions, naming your fear honestly, calling a trusted person, or sitting quietly before God?
6. Pottsfield was frightening because its meaning was unknown, though it was not truly dangerous. Is there a current situation where you may be assuming the worst before you have all the information? How could curiosity and patience change your response? [54:34]