From Scarcity to Plenty: Give What You Have

Matthew 14 begins with Jesus hearing the bad news about John the Baptist, his dear friend who has died, and Jesus withdraws by boat to a deserted place by himself. The deserted place is not just a quiet chapel or a favorite oak tree. The desert is the place where the Hebrews wandered, the place where Jesus was tempted, the place where no one would dare follow. But the crowds do follow, because they are so taken by Jesus that they go out into the wilderness after him.

Jesus sees the great crowd and has compassion. Jesus heals the sick, loves the people, and keeps caring for them even when the day grows late. The disciples see the same crowd, but they see danger. The disciples see hungry people, no stores, no villages nearby, and not enough food. Fear makes them turn inward. Scarcity makes them say, “Send them away.”

The text places that old dilemma right in front of the church. The deserted place reveals whether fear will make people protect themselves or whether faith will make people share whatever is in their hands. Wallets can look too small. Houses can look too small. Even the mirror can say, “I’m not enough.” The disciples look at five loaves and two fish and decide that someone else will have to help.

Jesus offers another way to see. Jesus turns outward. Jesus looks at the same hungry crowd and sees plenty: plenty of time, plenty of food, plenty of possibility. Jesus does not begin by asking the disciples to calculate the need. Jesus says, “You give them something to eat.” As ludicrous and audacious as that sounds, Jesus trains their eyes by calling them to give.

The five loaves and two fish become more than lunch. The miracle provides food, but it also changes the people who see it. Jesus performs miracles not only to provide for people, but to change people so that they can see the world through the eyes of the one who performs miracles. A meager gift, given away, can tell somebody in the desert that they are not alone.

The little potato rolled under the prison fence speaks the same word. “The body of Christ” can come through something small, ordinary, and almost laughable. A hand to hold, a phone call, a forgiveness, a prayer, or a shoulder to cry on may look like almost nothing. But to someone in a deserted place, that little gift may feel like a banquet, because even in the desert, God’s grace is enough for everybody.

##

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. Scarcity turns disciples inward Fear teaches the heart to protect itself before it loves anybody else. The disciples saw the hungry crowd and immediately measured the need against their limited supply. The problem was not only that food was scarce, but that scarcity became the lens through which they saw people. [42:03]
• 2. Jesus sees plenty in the desert Jesus looked at the same wilderness and the same hungry crowd, but he saw possibility where the disciples saw danger. The deserted place did not limit his compassion or shrink his imagination. Faith does not deny the need, but it refuses to let need have the last word. [46:33]
• 3. Giving trains eyes for faith Jesus commanded the disciples to give before they understood how anything could work. That command exposed their fear and invited them into a different way of seeing. Sometimes the act of giving is not the overflow of confidence, but the very practice by which confidence is born. [47:24]
• 4. Miracles change the beholder Jesus’ miracle fed the crowd, but it also reshaped the disciples. Provision was not the only gift on the grass that evening. The disciples were being taught to see the world through the eyes of the one who blesses, breaks, and gives. [48:39]
• 5. Small gifts can become banquets A piece of bread, a fish, a potato, a phone call, or a prayer can look painfully small beside someone’s suffering. Yet the gift does not need to solve everything in order to speak grace. In a deserted place, even a small sign of love can tell someone, “You are not alone.”
  
  ## [52:43]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [35:30] - Matthew 14 Reading and Prayer
• [37:33] - School Rules and Bringing Enough
• [40:28] - The Disciples’ Desert Dilemma
• [42:03] - Fear, Scarcity, and Turning Inward
• [43:03] - A Subway Story About Fear
• [45:47] - Jesus Turns Outward in Faith
• [47:24] - The Call to Give What Little There Is
• [48:39] - Miracles That Change How People See
• [50:10] - The Potato and the Body of Christ
• [52:43] - What Can Be Given in the Desert
• [53:40] - God’s Grace Is Enough for Everybody

Bible Reading

Matthew 14:13-21
“Now when Jesus heard this, he withdrew from there in a boat to a deserted place by himself. But when the crowds heard it, they followed him on foot from the towns. When he went ashore, he saw a great crowd; and he had compassion for them and cured their sick. When it was evening, the disciples came to him and said, ‘This is a deserted place, and the hour is now late; send the crowds away so that they may go into the villages and buy food for themselves.’ Jesus said to them, ‘They need not go away; you give them something to eat.’ They replied, ‘We have nothing here but five loaves and two fish.’ And he said, ‘Bring them here to me.’ Then he ordered the crowds to sit down on the grass. Taking the five loaves and the two fish, he looked up to heaven, and blessed and broke the loaves, and gave them to the disciples, and the disciples gave them to the crowds. And all ate and were filled; and they took up what was left over of the broken pieces, twelve baskets full. And those who ate were about five thousand men, besides women and children.” [31:43] [35:30] [36:12]

Observation questions

1. What does Jesus do when he sees the crowd in the deserted place, and what do the disciples ask him to do instead? [42:03]
2. What reasons do the disciples give for sending the crowd away, and what small amount of food do they say they have?
3. In this passage, what does Jesus physically do with the loaves and fish before the crowd eats?
4. What kinds of small gifts are named as things that can matter deeply to someone in a deserted place? [52:43]

Interpretation questions

1. The disciples look at the crowd through fear and scarcity, while Jesus looks at the same situation through faith and possibility. What does that contrast reveal about the difference between turning inward and turning outward? [45:47]
2. Jesus says, “You give them something to eat,” before the disciples understand how it could possibly work. Why might Jesus call people to give before they feel ready or sufficient? [47:24]
3. The miracle feeds the crowd, but it also reshapes the disciples. In what ways can God’s provision change not only a situation, but also the way people learn to see others? [48:39]
4. A small gift does not have to solve everything in order to speak grace. How can something ordinary, like bread, a potato, or a phone call, become a sign that a person is not alone? [50:10]

Application questions

1. When fear or pressure rises, where is the strongest temptation to say, “Send them away” in ordinary life right now—at home, at work, in church, or with a neighbor? What does turning inward look like there? [42:17]
2. Many people quietly live with the feeling, “I’m not enough.” Where does that feeling show up most often right now, and how might it be affecting the willingness to share time, attention, money, or care with others? [43:08]
3. Jesus sees plenty of possibility even in the desert. Where is one place in life that looks empty or hopeless right now, and what might it mean to look at that place with faith instead of scarcity? [46:33]
4. “Give what little you have” can sound unrealistic until it becomes concrete. What is one small thing that could honestly be given this week—a meal, a ride, a text, a prayer, a listening ear, or forgiveness? [47:24]
5. Sometimes the smallest act of love feels like a banquet to someone else. Can the group remember a time when a simple gesture carried much more weight than it seemed to have? What made it so meaningful? [53:03]
6. Even a person standing in a deserted place still has something to give. If life feels heavy right now, what kind of gift still feels possible to offer without pretending everything is fine? [52:43]
7. God’s grace is enough for everybody. What would it look like for this group to live that out in a practical way together over the next few weeks? [53:40]