Reforming Ethics: A Christian Perspective on Morality

 

Summary

In our exploration of the foundational elements necessary to construct a Christian life and worldview, we have journeyed through epistemology, metaphysics, the character of God, and anthropology. Today, we delve into ethics, a uniquely human concern that shapes our behavior and societal norms. The question of whether ethics is a human-only concern or shared with other creatures, like beetles, is a playful yet profound way to highlight the distinctiveness of human moral reasoning.

Ethics, as we understand it, is deeply intertwined with our view of humanity. Our anthropology influences our ethics, and how we perceive the importance of humanity affects our behavior. C.S. Lewis, in "Mere Christianity," suggests that right and wrong are clues to the universe's meaning. Without a moral framework, life loses its significance, as Dostoyevsky and Kant have argued. Kant, despite his agnosticism, recognized the necessity of God for meaningful ethics, suggesting that without justice, ethics are meaningless.

The relativization of ethics in modern society has led to a cultural shift where preference replaces duty, and special interests replace law. This shift has resulted in a society where moral relativism prevails, yet it is a myth that cannot sustain a civilization. Every culture needs a unifying foundation, and ours has moved from a theological to a philosophical, and now to a mythological foundation, which is unstable.

Nietzsche's distinction between "master morality" and "herd morality" highlights the danger of conforming to societal norms without critical thought. The herd mentality leads to a culture where ethical standards are dictated by social conventions rather than a thoughtful meditation on God's law. This is evident in the rapid shift in societal norms regarding issues like sexual ethics and abortion.

The need for a reformation of ethics is urgent, not just in society but within the church. This requires moral courage, the kind exemplified by individuals like Boris Yeltsin, who stood against tyranny. Christianity calls us to seek God's kingdom and righteousness, an ethical mandate that challenges the myth of moral relativism. In a world where truth is often obscured, a Christian worldview seeks to establish the rules of thinking and discernment, ensuring that our lives are aligned with God's truth.

Key Takeaways:

1. The Uniqueness of Human Ethics: Unlike other creatures, humans grapple with questions of guilt, justice, and righteousness, which are central to our ethical framework. This distinctiveness underscores the importance of a moral compass in shaping our behavior and societal norms. [02:59]

2. The Necessity of God for Meaningful Ethics: Kant's argument highlights that without justice, ethics lose their meaning. A just God is essential for a moral framework that holds individuals accountable, ensuring that life has significance beyond mere existence. [06:14]

3. The Myth of Moral Relativism: Modern society's shift towards moral relativism is unsustainable, as it lacks a foundation in objective truth. This myth leads to internal conflict and societal instability, emphasizing the need for a return to a theologically grounded ethical framework. [13:54]

4. The Danger of Herd Morality: Conforming to societal norms without critical thought leads to a herd mentality, where ethical standards are dictated by social conventions rather than God's law. This results in a culture where right and wrong are fluid, based on the whims of the majority. [17:14]

5. The Call for Moral Courage: In a world where ethical standards are often compromised, Christians are called to exhibit moral courage, standing firm in God's truth. This involves seeking God's kingdom and righteousness, challenging the prevailing myth of moral relativism. [25:01]

Youtube Chapters:

- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:35] - Introduction to Ethics
- [01:09] - The Thinker's Pondering
- [02:17] - Do Beetles Have Ethics?
- [02:59] - Human Uniqueness in Ethics
- [03:41] - Anthropology and Ethics
- [04:14] - C.S. Lewis and Mere Christianity
- [05:29] - Kant's Moral Argument
- [06:14] - Justice and Ethics
- [07:11] - Manifest Injustice
- [08:05] - The Necessity of a Just Judge
- [09:16] - The Myth of Moral Relativism
- [10:54] - Legislation and Morality
- [12:38] - The Foundation of Civilization
- [13:54] - Mythological Foundation
- [15:48] - Nietzsche's Ethics
- [17:14] - Herd Morality
- [19:21] - Cultural Shifts in Ethics
- [21:03] - The Need for Ethical Reformation
- [22:02] - Moral Courage in Action
- [25:01] - Christianity's Ethical Mandate
- [27:01] - The Elements of a Christian Worldview

Study Guide

Bible Study Discussion Guide

Bible Reading:
1. Romans 2:14-15 - "For when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them."
2. Matthew 5:6 - "Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they shall be satisfied."
3. Proverbs 21:15 - "When justice is done, it is a joy to the righteous but terror to evildoers."

Observation Questions:
1. According to the sermon, what is the significance of ethics being a uniquely human concern? [02:59]
2. How does Kant's argument for the necessity of God relate to the concept of justice in ethics? [06:14]
3. What does the sermon suggest about the impact of moral relativism on society? [13:54]
4. How does Nietzsche's concept of "herd morality" contrast with the idea of a Christian ethical framework? [17:14]

Interpretation Questions:
1. How does Romans 2:14-15 relate to the sermon's discussion on the uniqueness of human ethics and moral reasoning?
2. In what ways does Matthew 5:6 challenge the notion of moral relativism discussed in the sermon? [25:01]
3. How might Proverbs 21:15 be used to understand the sermon's emphasis on the necessity of justice for meaningful ethics?
4. What are the implications of Nietzsche's "herd morality" for Christians seeking to live according to God's law? [17:14]

Application Questions:
1. Reflect on a time when you conformed to societal norms without critical thought. How can you ensure your ethical decisions are aligned with God's truth rather than the "herd mentality"? [17:14]
2. How can you cultivate moral courage in your daily life, similar to the example of Boris Yeltsin standing against tyranny? [24:21]
3. In what ways can you actively seek God's kingdom and righteousness in a world that often obscures truth? [25:01]
4. Identify an area in your life where you have been influenced by moral relativism. What steps can you take to ground your ethics in a theologically sound framework? [13:54]
5. How can you engage in thoughtful meditation on God's law to guide your ethical decisions, rather than relying on social conventions? [21:03]
6. Consider a situation where you felt the need for justice. How did you respond, and how might you respond differently in light of the sermon's teachings on justice and ethics? [07:11]
7. What practical steps can you take to discern truth in a world filled with conflicting messages, as discussed in the sermon? [27:01]

Devotional

Day 1: The Uniqueness of Human Ethics
Humans are unique in their capacity to grapple with ethical questions, such as guilt, justice, and righteousness. This distinctiveness is not shared with other creatures and underscores the importance of a moral compass in shaping our behavior and societal norms. Our ethical framework is deeply intertwined with our view of humanity, influencing how we perceive the importance of human life and our actions within society. This understanding calls us to reflect on the moral responsibilities that come with our human nature and the need for a guiding ethical framework. [02:59]

"For when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them." (Romans 2:14-15, ESV)

Reflection: Consider a recent decision you made. How did your understanding of justice and righteousness influence your choice?


Day 2: The Necessity of God for Meaningful Ethics
Kant's argument suggests that without justice, ethics lose their meaning, and a just God is essential for a moral framework that holds individuals accountable. This perspective emphasizes that life has significance beyond mere existence, as it is grounded in a moral order established by God. Without this foundation, ethical principles become arbitrary and lose their power to guide human behavior. The necessity of God in ethics challenges us to consider the role of divine justice in our understanding of right and wrong. [06:14]

"The Rock, his work is perfect, for all his ways are justice. A God of faithfulness and without iniquity, just and upright is he." (Deuteronomy 32:4, ESV)

Reflection: In what ways does your belief in a just God influence your daily ethical decisions?


Day 3: The Myth of Moral Relativism
Modern society's shift towards moral relativism is unsustainable, as it lacks a foundation in objective truth. This myth leads to internal conflict and societal instability, emphasizing the need for a return to a theologically grounded ethical framework. Without a unifying foundation, cultures become fragmented, and ethical standards become fluid, leading to confusion and discord. Recognizing the myth of moral relativism calls us to seek a stable and objective basis for our ethical beliefs, rooted in the truth of God's word. [13:54]

"Everyone then who hears these words of mine and does them will be like a wise man who built his house on the rock." (Matthew 7:24, ESV)

Reflection: Identify an area in your life where you have been influenced by moral relativism. How can you ground this area in objective truth today?


Day 4: The Danger of Herd Morality
Conforming to societal norms without critical thought leads to a herd mentality, where ethical standards are dictated by social conventions rather than God's law. This results in a culture where right and wrong are fluid, based on the whims of the majority. Nietzsche's distinction between "master morality" and "herd morality" highlights the danger of losing individual moral reasoning in favor of societal conformity. This calls us to critically evaluate the ethical standards we follow and ensure they align with God's truth. [17:14]

"Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect." (Romans 12:2, ESV)

Reflection: Reflect on a societal norm you have accepted without question. How can you critically evaluate this norm in light of God's law?


Day 5: The Call for Moral Courage
In a world where ethical standards are often compromised, Christians are called to exhibit moral courage, standing firm in God's truth. This involves seeking God's kingdom and righteousness, challenging the prevailing myth of moral relativism. Moral courage requires us to act with integrity and conviction, even when it is difficult or unpopular. By aligning our lives with God's truth, we become agents of change in a world that desperately needs a return to ethical clarity and righteousness. [25:01]

"Be strong and courageous. Do not fear or be in dread of them, for it is the Lord your God who goes with you. He will not leave you or forsake you." (Deuteronomy 31:6, ESV)

Reflection: Think of a situation where you need to stand firm in God's truth. What steps can you take today to exhibit moral courage in this area?

Quotes


Do other creatures in this world struggle with questions of guilt and of justice? Do other creatures in this world struggle with matters of righteousness? Do beetles care whether other beetles behave in a morally appropriate way? Or is the subject of ethics and morality uniquely a human concern? [00:02:43]

Immanuel Kant who in many regards dug the grave of the classical defense of Christian theology, in spite of his agnosticism with respect to proving the existence of God, Kant declared in his final writings, practically speaking as I mentioned before, "We must live as if there is a God." [00:05:19]

Kant argued in this fashion, "For ethics to be meaningful," this is a simplified shorthand version of it, "For ethics to be meaningful, there must be justice." That is, before anybody has a right to say "you must," "you ought" or "you should," and everyone in this room has said that to somebody else, "You ought to do this," and you've all heard people give you rules and regulations. [00:06:29]

Historians have told us that every civilization, every culture in world history has been built upon the foundation of a philosophy, a religion, or a mythology, something that gave unifying stability to the culture. We have gone through, I'm convinced, three stages in American history. [00:12:51]

Nietzsche made a distinction between what he called "master morality" and "herd morality." When he called for the Superman to come down and create a new civilization, he was asking that someone who would have the courage to do what he wanted to do, to live by his own rules, to live by his own standards. [00:16:02]

In his analysis of nineteenth-century Europe, he said that nineteenth-century Europe in the main, as a civilization, as a culture, lives according to a herd morality. Let me write that down, a herd morality. Where have we heard that before? "All we like sheep have been led astray." [00:17:08]

Most Christians, according to the Gallup polls that we've seen recently, live according to cultural, social conventions and not according to the law of God. Percentagewise, just as many evangelicals are having abortions as secular people, pagans. You can't tell the difference between a pagan and a Christian in our culture. [00:21:16]

If ever there was a need for a reformation of ethics, it's now, not only in government and in the school, but especially in the church, but for that to happen it requires, among other things, moral courage. [00:24:57]

One man, one man against the herd, one man steps out of the crowd, one man with courage, in the presence of tanks and an organized political coup, runs up and jumps on top of a tank and screams at the people who are there and said, "No!" He said, "This is wrong!" [00:24:00]

The bottom line of Christianity is that we are called to seek the kingdom of God and His righteousness. That's an ethical mandate. And if the rest of the world doesn't even believe there is such a thing as right or wrong, as I said, in a relativistic culture nobody's a consistent relativist, we know that. [00:25:09]

No, the myth of moral relativism is modern man's attempt to create an ethical license for sin, to call evil good and good evil. But, of course, if there is no God there is no good, there is no evil, and it doesn't matter who jumps on the tank and who jumps off. [00:25:58]

A Christian life and worldview seeks to establish the rules of thinking, the rules of determining how we know what is true because not everything that everybody says is true. Maybe that's what has him so preoccupied. Maybe he's sitting here wondering who in the world is speaking the truth. [00:26:32]

Chatbot

  • I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Jun 17, 2020. Do you have any questions about it?

Transcript
What was the most surprising thing in this sermon?
Were there any personal stories shared?