Embracing the Promise of Paradox: Strong and Broken

Jan 18, 2026

Devotional

Day 1: Living in the Tension of Being Strong and Broken

We often view our internal contradictions as problems to be solved or equations to be balanced. However, life is rarely that simple, and we frequently find ourselves feeling powerful one moment and inadequate the next. Instead of trying to eliminate these tensions, we are invited to live into the complexity of our own stories. Recognizing that we are both made in God's image and prone to human folly allows us to stop fighting our reality. By embracing this paradox, we begin to find the wholeness that comes from being honest about our entire selves. [33:14]

For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate. (Romans 7:15)

Reflection: When you look at your life this week, where do you feel the most tension between who you want to be and how you are actually acting?

Day 2: Rejecting Self-Righteousness and Shame for Honest Grace

When faced with our own shortcomings, we often gravitate toward two extremes: self-righteousness or despair. Self-righteousness suggests we are fine and everyone else is the problem, while shame tells us we are fundamentally beyond repair. Both of these are false choices that prevent us from experiencing the transformative power of God's grace. True growth happens when we refuse to minimize our harm or diminish our belovedness. By standing in the middle of this paradox, we open ourselves to a grace that doesn't just excuse us but actually changes us. [38:41]

So I find it to be a law that when I want to do right, evil lies close at hand. For I delight in the law of God, in my inner self, but I see in my members another law at war with the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin that dwells in my members. (Romans 7:21-23)

Reflection: Which "false choice" do you tend to lean toward—blaming others to protect yourself, or falling into self-criticism—and how might God be inviting you to a middle path of honest grace today?

Day 3: Rummaging for God Through the Prayer of Examen

Spiritual growth begins with the simple act of telling the truth about our lives without self-attack. The prayer of examen offers a way to look back at our day and rummage for God’s presence in both our strengths and our shadows. We can ask where we lived from our God-given gifts and where we acted from our fear or ego. This practice isn't about passing judgment, but about bringing everything into the light of grace. When we name our patterns honestly, we create fertile ground for the Holy Spirit to work within us. [47:07]

Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! (Romans 7:24-25a)

Reflection: As you look back over the last twenty-four hours, what is one moment where you felt fully aligned with your God-given gifts, and what is one moment where you felt led by your "shadow self"?

Day 4: Finding Peace in Being Already Held by God

In moments of frustration or regret, our first instinct is often to try to fix ourselves through sheer willpower. Yet, change fueled by shame rarely lasts, while change fueled by grace has true staying power. We can adopt a simple mantra to remind ourselves that God’s grace is a starting point, not a reward for our efforts. Whispering the words "I am already held" can shift our perspective from panic to peace. This allows us to face our unresolved tensions knowing that we are already secure in God's love. [50:16]

So then, I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin. (Romans 7:25b)

Reflection: When you feel the pressure to "fix" your spiritual life or your personality, what would it feel like to pause and simply tell yourself, "I am already held"?

Day 5: Practicing Wholeness Within a Grace-Filled Community

We are often tempted to present a curated, sanitized version of ourselves to the world and even to our church community. However, the promise of paradox suggests that we are most alive when we bring our whole, complicated selves into the light. Community is the place where we practice being honest about our struggles without the need for immediate resolution. When we stop choosing only our "good" parts to show others, we reject fragmentation and embrace the wholeness God intends for us. We are deeply loved, fully seen, and still becoming. [54:53]

Let love be genuine. Abhor what is evil; hold fast to what is good. Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honor. (Romans 12:9-10)

Reflection: Think of a relationship where you usually feel the need to say "everything is fine." What is one small, honest truth about your current struggle that you could share with that person this week?

Sermon Summary

The Promise of Paradox opens by naming a paradox at the heart of human life: people are simultaneously strong and broken. Drawing from Romans 7, the text shows how desire and ability often pull in opposite directions—wanting the good but repeatedly doing what harms. That tension resists tidy solutions; it is not evidence of moral failure alone nor a reason to abandon formation. Instead, the paradox is an invitation to live honestly with contradiction: to hold capacity and limitation together, to refuse both self-righteous certainty and despair that erases giftedness.

Three false responses are identified and critiqued. Self-righteousness overplays strength, shuts down listening, and resists repentance. Shame or despair minimizes God’s claim of belovedness and prevents contribution. A third distortion, “grace without growth,” treats grace as permission to remain unchanged, emptying transformative grace of its power. Each of these responses offers a tempting but inadequate way of escaping internal conflict.

Practical disciplines are proposed to inhabit the paradox faithfully. A modified examen invites a regular, gentle inventory of where one lived from gifts and where one acted from fear or shadow, naming both without self-attack and allowing grace to inform future steps. A simple mantra—“God’s grace is already here” or “I am already held”—reframes change as beginning in assurance rather than driven by shame. Repentance is reframed not as transaction but as return to relationship: sincere apology, repair, and making amends become liberative acts that participate in God’s repairing work. Finally, a communal posture is urged: people are encouraged to show up not as curated, fixed versions of themselves but as whole, complicated persons, so that the church can be a field where paradox is held and holiness practiced.

The horizon of this work is not mastery over contradiction but truer life within it. Strength without humility and brokenness without hope both fail to reflect the biblical witness that humans are made in God’s image and called to change. The promise of paradox is that one may be deeply loved and actively becoming at the same time—held now by grace and invited into transformation. This posture allows for honest living, faithful growth, and mutual healing amid unresolved tensions.

Key Takeaways

1. Humans are strong and broken Honest spirituality names capacity and limitation together. Seeing both prevents the false extremes of moral superiority or despair, allowing realistic appraisal of gifts and failures. This clarity frees the work of repentance and formation to begin without shame. [31:17]
2. Grace initiates, not rewards change Change rooted in shame will not endure; change begun in the assurance of grace has staying power. Remembering that grace is present reframes efforts as responses to a loving initiative rather than attempts to earn acceptance. This keeps transformation hopeful and sustainable. [50:16]
3. Repentance is return to relationship Repentance reframed as relational turning restores connection rather than satisfying a ledger of guilt. Apology, repair, and amends become concrete practices that heal communities and free individuals from isolation. This approach values reconciliation over punishment. [51:08]
4. Practice honest self-examination daily The examen is a disciplined, nonjudgmental looking-back that spots where gifts and shadows shaped action. Naming consolations and desolations without self-attack creates fertile ground for change and for noticing God’s movement. Regular practice turns insight into steady growth. [46:29]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[01:59] - Announcements & connection
[03:46] - Phishing Kyle: scam warning
[07:31] - Introducing the series
[30:56] - Scripture reading: Romans 7
[32:36] - What paradox means
[35:09] - Framing strong and broken
[38:01] - False choices explained
[42:22] - Interpreting Paul's words
[46:29] - Practice: The Examen
[49:22] - Practice: Mantra of grace
[51:08] - Repentance as return
[52:08] - Community: show whole self
[54:53] - Assurance: loved and becoming
[67:31] - Closing blessing

Bible Study Guide

Bible reading

Romans 7:15-25 (ESV)
For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate. Now if I do what I do not want, I agree with the law, that it is good. So now it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me. For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh. For I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out. For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing. Now if I do what I do not want, it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me.

So I find it to be a law that when I want to do right, evil lies close at hand. For I delight in the law of God, in my inner being, but I see in my members another law waging war against the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin that dwells in my members. Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin.

Observation questions

In the reading from Romans 7, how does Paul describe the conflict between his desire to do good and his actual ability to carry it out?
The sermon identifies three "false choices" or responses we often use to try to escape the tension of being both strong and broken. What are these three responses? [37:34]
How is "grace without growth" defined, and what does this mindset strip grace of? [40:23]
What specific daily practice was proposed to help us look back and identify where we lived from our gifts and where we acted from our "shadow self"? [46:11]

Interpretation questions

Paul exclaims, "Wretched man that I am!" and then immediately shifts to "Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!" How does this rapid transition illustrate the idea that we are invited to live within a paradox rather than trying to solve a problem?
Change fueled by shame will never last, but change fueled by grace has staying power. [50:16] Why is shame an ineffective motivator for long-term transformation compared to the assurance of being held by God?
Repentance is often viewed as a transaction where we pay for our guilt. How does reframing repentance as a "return to relationship" change the way we approach making amends with God and others? [50:38]

Application questions

We often feel the tension of being "strong and broken"—competent in some areas but reactive or impatient in others. [34:22] Which side of this paradox do you tend to focus on more: your capacity and gifts, or your limitations and failures? How does that focus shape your daily life?
When you face internal conflict, do you tend to drift toward self-righteousness ("I'm fine, they are the problem"), despair ("I'm broken beyond repair"), or grace without growth ("God loves me, so I don't need to change")? [37:34] What usually triggers that response in you?
A "mantra of grace" can help ground us when we feel overwhelmed or frustrated. [49:22] Phrases like "God's grace is already here" or "I am already held" were suggested. What is a short phrase you could use this week to remind yourself that grace is the starting point, not the reward?
We are encouraged to show up in community not as curated versions of ourselves, but as whole, complicated people. [52:08] Is it difficult for you to answer honestly when someone asks, "How are you?" What holds you back from sharing your struggles or your "shadow self" with your church community?
You are deeply loved, fully seen, and still becoming. [54:36] How does knowing that God is not waiting for you to be "fixed" before loving you change how you view your current struggles?

Sermon Clips

26s

#AlreadyHeld

“``Or a simpler and perhaps my favorite version of this is to just whisper to yourself, I am already held. I am already held. I don't have to fix this. I'm already held. In other words, grace is the starting point instead of the reward for our efforts. Because change fueled by shame will never last, but change fueled by grace has staying power.”

24s

#EmbraceParadox

“Because friends, it is actually good news that we're not strong enough to fix ourselves. Just like it's good news that we're never beyond the transformative reach of God's redeeming and refining power. To embrace these paradoxes of the self is to receive the promise of wholeness that we would reject fragmentation, that we would stop choosing our parts and instead live as a whole complicated people that we are.”

27s

#LiveInTheTension

“So the goal of life is not to solve a paradox or an equation. It's not to put the puzzle piece altogether, and it's not a game or a quest that God is asking to see if we can level up to the next challenge. We're not meant to tidy up that which was never intended to be resolved, but instead to live fully in the midst of it. And that's actually the promise that comes with our strength and weakness, that there is grace in our goodness and in God's desire for us to grow.”

26s

#RepentanceIsRelationship

“Another practice for embracing the promise of paradox is repentance as a return to relationship. You see, very often we reduce, repentance to a sort of a transaction But this is an important reframing. Repentance isn't about transaction and it's not about punishment. It's never about shame. Instead, it's about turning back towards relationship. When you've wandered away, it's about turning and moving towards repair and realignment.”

26s

#MakeAmendsMatter

“It's a turn towards light and life away from disconnection and darkness. And when we understand that, practicing a sincere apology without defensiveness is possible. Making amends becomes a liberative act both for ourselves and for others and a tiny participation with God in the repairing and remaking of all things. It reminds us that even small acts matter and that repentance is relationship is relational and not transactional.”

28s

#LovedAndCalled

“So how we might say it in theological terms is this, we are loved and we are also called to change. God's care and dream and hopes for us don't stop now. God wants more and deeper and fuller and that requires us to change, which for me helps me understand this paradox that we're talking about today. If you're like me, the question is not, are we good or are we bad? That is just too reductionist and too simplistic.”

26s

#BeliefIsAction

“And when we live in this way, belief becomes an intellectual ascent and a divinely granted exceptionalism or get out of trouble free card. It becomes a permission giving badge that we wear rather than a response to a participation demanding call from God. And it is far too content to leave things settled as they are, which prevents us from embracing the fullness of what God wants for us and for the world.”

32s

#WrestleWithContradictions

“But whatever Paul's original intent, these words give voice to something that we know deep in our bones. What it is to be absolute and resolute and fully committed to one thing only to find ourselves actually doing the opposite. We know what that means to be stuck between patterns and demands that both seem equally beautiful and necessary, and yet at the same time mutually exclusive where we have to pick our desire to create wholeness and shalom, and yet our propensity to create and participate in chaos and hurt.”

23s

#BelovedNotBroken

“And it sounds like this. I'm broken fundamentally and beyond repair. I'm a liability to the people around me. I don't have gifts that are worth offering, and none of that will ever change. It emphasizes our failure and our weakness and the sin, that that we participate in at the expense of our belovedness, which God has already declared to be true and unwavering.”

27s

#ShowUpAuthentic

“We believe and work towards being good people. However, we define that. And yet, we're also increasingly aware of our own complicity and systems that cause great harm. One of our deepest desires is to be accepted as we are, and yet we refuse to present our authentic selves more often than not. We oscillate between self confidence and self criticism, pride and shame, assurance, and absolute confusion or directionlessness.”

29s

#FaceYourContradictions

“And and as I was thinking about where to start this series, it seemed to me that that we didn't have to look far, that we could look simply in the mirror, and that would be a good starting place. Because in so many ways, you and I are walking contradictions. We fear change even when we know that what we have isn't working. We want simplicity, but we keep choosing complexity over and over again. It seems like the more connected we get in this digital age, the the more the more lonely we feel.”

31s

#MadeInGodsImage

“The scriptures narrate over and over of humanity's great strength and capacity and independence for both better and worse. The scriptures open with an affirmation that we are made in God image God's image and that we have been declared good. And our scriptures are shaped by stories of human folly and weakness and the consequences of separation. We have tremendous capacity to perpetuate harm, and we know that over and over again, call God calls us out of these patterns and behaviors that don't promote life.”

17s

#DontHideYourGifts

“And the costs here also are great. We fail to show up fully which prevents our gifts from being shared with the world. It causes us to stop looking for and hoping for progress and transformation and that short changes the grace of God that is making all things new.”

41s

#StrongAndBroken

“So you and I know ourselves to be strong and broken. If you're anything like me, you know what it is to feel powerful beyond measure and then overwhelmed by a sense of inadequacy. And sometimes the distance between those feelings is like three heartbeats. They they can happen in close proximity to one another. I resonate with these words of Paul when he says, for the desire to do good lies close at hand, but not the ability. We know what that feels like. We are competent at our work. We are trusted among our peers, and we're striving to be generous neighbors. And yet too often, we're reactive and defensive and impatient in the most important relationships of our lives.”

30s

#GraceIsAlreadyHere

“In other words, capture a simple phrase that when you find yourself feeling powerless in a circumstance or frustrated by the decisions that you're making when you're beating yourself up or about something that's happened or you're you're digging in and entrenching and finding yourself defensive, when you're tempted to throw up your hands and say this is just how it will always be, then instead of doing any of those things, we could begin with a mantra of grace. So it might sound like this, just reminding yourself out loud, God's grace is already here.”

35s

#GodIsRescuingNow

“And maybe you just wanna say that God's grace is already here. I'm frustrated. I feel alone. I see where this is going. I'm regretful of what's happened. God's grace is already here. Not somewhere else. Not after I do something else. God's grace is already here. Maybe we wanna adopt the words of Paul and and say thanks be to God who is rescuing me from whatever pattern, whatever tendency you're talking about. And we name that as a present reality. God is currently doing that, not in the future, not God is going to fix it, but right now, in the midst of the frustration and the tension and the unresolved, God is rescuing me from this.”

22s

#GentleSelfHonesty

“And as we're be bringing this this into the discussion, I think it's important to say that the sort of truth telling we're talking about here comes without self attack. So when you read through Paul's words, what's clear is that he's being honest about who he is without passing a lot of judgment on himself. He brings all of it to light without demeaning himself.”

21s

#GraceInTheMess

“Paul names the contradictions and the confusion without needing to diminish himself, and he brings it all into the light of grace. He names his capacity and his desire while also naming his failure and his frustrating patterns, and he puts all of that before the divine and finds that the divine shows up right in the midst of it, not when everything is resolved and not somewhere else.”

30s

#CourageToShowUp

“That that's a paradox, that's a tension that I'm experiencing right now. I want us to be honest and to be able to say that. And it doesn't mean you have to, like, trauma bleed all over each other, but, like, just to to bring the full tension of who we are and to recognize that God is big enough to hold all of that in God's community, God's church ought to be big enough to learn how to lean into that. And sometimes the the most faithful we can thing we can do is acknowledge the courage it takes to honestly show up like that, to say those things when we've been taught to just say everything is fine.”

30s

#BeginWithGrace

Ask a question about this sermon

St. Paul's United Methodist Church, Lenexa, KS This sermon · AI assistant

Why is it so hard to be who I want?

What practices help embrace paradox of self?

How should repentance function beyond shame and transaction?

Embracing the Promise of Paradox: Strong and Broken

Devotional

Day 1: Living in the Tension of Being Strong and Broken

Day 2: Rejecting Self-Righteousness and Shame for Honest Grace

Day 3: Rummaging for God Through the Prayer of Examen

Day 4: Finding Peace in Being Already Held by God

Day 5: Practicing Wholeness Within a Grace-Filled Community

Sermon Summary

Key Takeaways

Youtube Chapters

Bible Study Guide

Sermon Clips

Embracing the Promise of Paradox: Strong and Broken

Share