Navigating the Church-State Relationship: A Biblical Perspective

 

Summary

In our exploration of Romans 13:1-7, we delve into the complex relationship between the Christian and the state, a topic that has perplexed believers throughout history. This passage is pivotal in understanding how Christians should relate to governing authorities, emphasizing that all power is ordained by God. Historically, the church has struggled with the balance between aligning with the state and maintaining its distinct spiritual mission. The New Testament clearly delineates the roles of church and state, suggesting that neither should control the other. This separation is crucial, as attempts to merge the two often lead to the distortion of the gospel message.

We examined the historical context, particularly the shift that occurred during Constantine's reign, which marked a departure from early church practices. This shift led to the Roman Catholic Church's dominance over state affairs, a trend that was perpetuated by Protestant reformers who failed to critically evaluate this tradition. The danger of traditionalism, as opposed to tradition, is highlighted as a significant threat to the church's mission. Traditionalism can obscure the truth of God's word, as seen in the Pharisees' adherence to their traditions over the scriptures.

In today's world, we face similar challenges as we navigate the pressures of modernity and the ecumenical movement. It is imperative for Christians to remain vigilant, evaluating all traditions and teachings against the scriptures. The call is for an open mind, not bound by denominational loyalty, but committed to the truth of God's word. This approach mirrors the reformers' spirit, who prioritized scripture over centuries of tradition.

The sermon concludes with a reflection on the role of the state, questioning whether its function is purely negative or if it has a positive role in promoting Christian values. While some advocate for the state to Christianize society, this notion is challenged as it contradicts the biblical teaching that true Christian living is only possible through regeneration. The historical evidence supports this, showing that societal improvements following revivals are temporary and not indicative of a gradual Christianization of the world.

Key Takeaways:

1. The Distinction Between Church and State: The New Testament teaches that the church and state are distinct entities, with no scriptural basis for one controlling the other. This separation is vital to preserve the integrity of the gospel and prevent the distortion of its message. [03:00]

2. The Danger of Traditionalism: Traditionalism, unlike tradition, can obscure the truth of God's word. It leads to a rigid adherence to human teachings, which can paralyze spiritual growth and understanding. This was evident in the Pharisees' approach, which prioritized tradition over scripture. [12:02]

3. The Role of the State: The state's function is primarily negative, maintaining order and justice, rather than promoting a Christian agenda. The idea of Christianizing society is a misunderstanding of the gospel, which requires personal regeneration for true Christian living. [30:03]

4. The Fallacy of Gradual Christianization: The notion that society can be gradually Christianized contradicts both scripture and historical evidence. True transformation comes through spiritual revival, which impacts society temporarily but does not lead to a permanent Christianization. [38:01]

5. The Call for Scriptural Evaluation: Christians are urged to evaluate all traditions and teachings against scripture, maintaining an open mind to the truth. This approach mirrors the reformers' spirit, who prioritized scripture over centuries of tradition. [27:13]

Youtube Chapters:

- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:11] - Introduction to Romans 13:1-7
- [01:04] - Historical Context of Church and State
- [02:25] - Distinction Between Church and State
- [03:34] - The Danger of Traditionalism
- [05:09] - Historical Errors of Church-State Unity
- [06:48] - Relevance to Modern Christians
- [08:20] - Lessons from Church History
- [10:39] - The Importance of Tradition
- [12:02] - Traditionalism vs. Tradition
- [14:00] - Pharisees and Traditionalism
- [17:22] - The Rigidness of Traditionalism
- [19:40] - The Spirit of Fear in Traditionalism
- [21:00] - Denominational Loyalty and Its Dangers
- [25:35] - Evaluating Tradition with Scripture
- [30:03] - The Role of the State
- [38:01] - The Fallacy of Gradual Christianization
- [43:30] - Historical Confirmation of Scriptural Teaching
- [47:58] - Closing Prayer

Study Guide

Bible Study Discussion Guide

Bible Reading:
- Romans 13:1-7
- Matthew 15:1-9
- 1 Peter 2:13-17

---

Observation Questions:

1. According to Romans 13:1-7, what is the relationship between Christians and governing authorities? How does this passage describe the source of governmental power? [00:11]

2. In the sermon, what historical shift during Constantine's reign is highlighted, and how did it affect the relationship between the church and the state? [04:22]

3. What distinction does the sermon make between tradition and traditionalism, and how does this relate to the Pharisees' approach to scripture? [13:23]

4. How does the sermon describe the role of the state according to the New Testament, and what is its primary function? [30:03]

---

Interpretation Questions:

1. How does the sermon suggest that traditionalism can obscure the truth of God's word, and what are the potential consequences for spiritual growth? [12:02]

2. What are the implications of the sermon’s assertion that the state’s role is primarily negative, and how does this align with the biblical teaching on the separation of church and state? [30:03]

3. How does the sermon challenge the notion of gradual Christianization of society, and what historical evidence is used to support this view? [38:01]

4. In what ways does the sermon encourage Christians to evaluate traditions and teachings against scripture, and how does this reflect the reformers' spirit? [27:13]

---

Application Questions:

1. Reflect on your own experiences with church traditions. Have you ever encountered a tradition that seemed to obscure the truth of scripture? How did you respond, and what did you learn from that experience? [12:02]

2. Consider the current relationship between your church and the state. How does your church navigate this relationship, and what challenges or benefits have you observed? [03:00]

3. The sermon emphasizes the importance of evaluating all teachings against scripture. How can you cultivate a habit of scriptural evaluation in your daily life? What resources or practices might help you in this endeavor? [27:13]

4. Think about a time when you felt pressure to conform to a traditional belief or practice within your church. How did you handle it, and what role did scripture play in your decision-making process? [25:35]

5. The sermon warns against the dangers of traditionalism. How can you ensure that your faith remains dynamic and open to the leading of the Holy Spirit, rather than becoming rigid and closed off? [16:57]

6. How do you perceive the role of the state in promoting Christian values in society? Do you agree with the sermon’s view that the state’s role is primarily negative? Why or why not? [30:03]

7. Reflect on the idea of personal regeneration as essential for true Christian living. How does this understanding impact your approach to evangelism and discipleship? [37:04]

Devotional

Day 1: The Distinction Between Church and State
The New Testament provides a clear distinction between the roles of the church and the state, emphasizing that neither should exert control over the other. This separation is crucial to maintaining the integrity of the gospel message and preventing its distortion. Historically, when the church has aligned too closely with the state, it has often led to a compromise of its spiritual mission. The church's primary role is to focus on spiritual matters, while the state is tasked with maintaining order and justice. Understanding this distinction helps believers navigate their responsibilities as citizens without compromising their faith. [03:00]

"For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer." (Romans 13:3-4, ESV)

Reflection: In what ways can you actively participate in your community while ensuring that your actions align with your faith and the gospel message?


Day 2: The Danger of Traditionalism
Traditionalism poses a significant threat to spiritual growth by prioritizing human teachings over the truth of God's word. Unlike tradition, which can enrich faith, traditionalism leads to a rigid adherence that can paralyze understanding and spiritual development. This was evident in the Pharisees' approach, where their strict adherence to tradition overshadowed the scriptures. Believers are encouraged to evaluate traditions critically, ensuring they align with biblical teachings and do not hinder their relationship with God. [12:02]

"Thus making void the word of God by your tradition that you have handed down. And many such things you do." (Mark 7:13, ESV)

Reflection: Identify a tradition you follow that may not align with scripture. How can you adjust your perspective to prioritize God's word over this tradition?


Day 3: The Role of the State
The state's primary function is to maintain order and justice, rather than promoting a Christian agenda. The idea of Christianizing society through the state is a misunderstanding of the gospel, which teaches that true Christian living is only possible through personal regeneration. Historical evidence shows that societal improvements following revivals are temporary and do not lead to a gradual Christianization of the world. Believers are called to focus on personal transformation and living out their faith authentically. [30:03]

"Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God." (Romans 13:1, ESV)

Reflection: How can you contribute to justice and order in your community while recognizing the limitations of the state's role in promoting Christian values?


Day 4: The Fallacy of Gradual Christianization
The notion that society can be gradually Christianized contradicts both scripture and historical evidence. True transformation comes through spiritual revival, which impacts society temporarily but does not lead to a permanent Christianization. Believers are reminded that the gospel calls for personal regeneration and transformation, rather than relying on societal changes to reflect Christian values. This understanding encourages Christians to focus on their spiritual growth and witness to others through their lives. [38:01]

"For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking but of righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit." (Romans 14:17, ESV)

Reflection: Reflect on your personal spiritual journey. How can you focus on your own transformation and witness to others, rather than expecting societal changes to reflect your faith?


Day 5: The Call for Scriptural Evaluation
Christians are urged to evaluate all traditions and teachings against scripture, maintaining an open mind to the truth. This approach mirrors the reformers' spirit, who prioritized scripture over centuries of tradition. By doing so, believers can ensure that their faith is rooted in the truth of God's word, rather than human interpretations or denominational loyalties. This commitment to scriptural evaluation fosters spiritual growth and a deeper understanding of God's will. [27:13]

"Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so." (Acts 17:11, ESV)

Reflection: What is one tradition or teaching you follow that you need to evaluate against scripture? How can you begin this process today?

Quotes

The church and state in New Testament teaching are entirely distinct and that there is no warrant from the New Testament teaching whatsoever for either controlling the other no warrant for the church controlling the state as the Roman Catholic church has done and would always like to do but equally no warrant for the state controlling the church as happens under erastianism and every state Church. [00:02:50]

The danger of trying to put the new wine of the gospel and the new dispensation into the old bottles of the Old Testament and Old Testament teaching and are failing to see as we do that the uniqueness of the position of the children of Israel for there the state and church consisted of the same people. [00:03:34]

What happened at the time of Constantine was not only a departure from the New Testament teaching but also a departure from the practice of the early church that I think is the most crucial point it has been the failure to realize that that has accounted for so much of the history that we've been considering. [00:04:12]

Traditionalism now you notice I'm not saying the danger of tradition I am saying the danger of traditional ISM what is the difference between tradition and traditionalism well it is this tradition in and of itself is something that is good a man who dismisses the whole of the past is behaving in a very foolish manner. [00:08:43]

The Pharisees were religious people they were the religious teachers they were very serious people this was their life they believed of all men that they were honoring God and living to their Glory as Paul says of them they have a Zeal they have a Zeal of God now it's a very great mistake to think of the Pharisee as a dishonest man. [00:13:57]

The whole tragedy of the poor Pharisees that he fools himself and doesn't realize what he's doing and it's a very Insidious and a very subtle process you see what happened was this these men studied their scriptures and they made comments on it and so a body of Doctrine and of teaching came into being. [00:14:29]

This body of teaching which has come into being in the way I have described it becomes fixed it becomes set it becomes hardened it becomes aifi if you like and becomes quite rigid and the people who are influenced by this and dominated by it there are people generally who refuse to consider anything else. [00:17:15]

There is always the danger of regarding the Fathers as divinely inspired and infallible now we as Protestants we object to the doctrine of papal infallibility we don't believe in it we don't believe in an infallible church or an infallible Pope at the head of it and we're very strong on this. [00:21:57]

The Christian should have an open mind in this sense that he's not bound by tradition he's open only to the scripture and he evaluates all else in the light of that and his understanding of it I do trust that as we've been examining this matter of the relationship between the church and the state. [00:27:24]

It is always wrong to talk about christianizing anything I would describe that as heresy there is no such thing as christianizing anything in other words you are either a Christian or you are not a Christian it is only the Christian who can live the Christian Life it is only the Christian who can understand the Christian teaching. [00:36:50]

There is no greater fallacy than the fallacy of thinking that you can permeate the whole life of society by Christian teaching it's not only opposed I suggest to you to the teaching of Our Lord himself and the teaching of the Apostles and particularly The Book of Revelation it is something that is negatived entirely and completely by the long history of man. [00:47:14]

We rejoice in the certain knowledge that whatever may be happening at this present time that thine ultimate purpose is sure and safe and certain oh Lord receive our prayers and continue we humbly beseech thee to deal with us by thy spirit and to give us enlighten ment and understanding Above All We humbly pray thee open our eyes to the present position. [00:48:36]

Chatbot

  • I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from May 25, 2017. Do you have any questions about it?

Transcript
What was the most surprising thing in this sermon?
Were there any personal stories shared?