Navigating AI: Ethics, Faith, and Human Distinctiveness

Devotional

Sermon Summary

Bible Study Guide

Sermon Clips

And when we think about the question what we can live with, my mind immediately goes back to two famous dystopias, George Orwell's 1984 and Huxley's Brave New World. And a brilliant analysis of those two books was given by Neil Postman who said... [00:03:21]

Orwell warns that we will be overcome by an externally imposed oppression. But in Huxley's vision, no big brother is required to deprive people of their autonomy, maturity, and history. People will come to love their oppression and to adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think. [00:03:39]

We have paleolithic emotions, medieval institutions and godlike technology. And it's terrifically dangerous until we answer those huge questions of philosophy that the philosophers abandoned a couple of generations ago. Where do we come from? Who are we? Where are we going? Rationally, we are on very thin ground. [00:04:26]

Now, if that were simply a statement coming from the science fiction area, we would probably all ignore it. But this kind of thinking is part and parcel of some of the statements of the most brilliant scientists on our planet. [00:05:33]

The real risk with AI isn't malice, but competence. A super intelligent AI will be extremely good at accomplishing its goals. And if those goals aren't aligned with ours, we're in trouble. [00:06:28]

And they argue that just as physics shows the impossibility of constructing a perpetual motion machine, so the mathematics of complex systems show that it is not possible nor will it be to engineer AGI machines even at the cognitive level of a crow and that therefore the singularity will never happen. [00:07:42]

Algorithms are already undermining people's capacity to make judgments, enjoy serendipitous encounters, and hone critical thinking. The human species will survive such losses. Can we live with it? He thinks so. But our way of existing will be impoverished in the process. [00:09:15]

Regulation will be critical and will take time to figure out. Although current generation AI tools aren't very scary, I think we are not that far away from potentially scary ones. [00:09:50]

First of all, restricted AI systems goals only to maximizing the realization of human goals. Secondly, keep the AI uncertain about what those goals are so that it must keep asking. insist that the AI tries to understand the nature of those goals by constant observation of human behavior and there is a plethora of role of rules being rolled out from various sources because it's quite obvious that the regulation problem is related to the control problem and we can't regulate what we can't control and some people are very worried about it. [00:10:15]

Everybody could be required to wear a security bracelet that combines the functionality of an Apple Watch with continuous uploading of position, health, status, and conversations overheard. Unauthorized attempts to remove or disable it would cause it to inject a lethal toxin into the forearm. [00:12:37]

Beware of taking all of that simply as symbols because as CS Lewis pointed out long ago, symbols are used to represent realities. And the reality that stands behind this, I reckon, is explicitly in plain text told us in two Thessalonians where Paul writes this, "For that day will not come unless the rebellion comes first." [00:15:22]

Transhumanism. The fundamental idea is that humans become gods by trusting technology. And you notice that movement turning humans into gods. Little G, super intelligent gods. What is the answer to it? The answer to it is a movement in the reverse direction. The central message of the Christian faith is that God became human. [00:19:49]

So that when people talk to me about their hope for AI solving the problem of human death, which is one of the main propositions, and transforming the nature of human happiness, I smile and say, "You're too late." They say, "What do you mean? We haven't even got there yet." [00:21:01]

Because the problem of human death was solved 20 centuries ago when God raised Jesus Christ from the dead. And secondly, you're hoping to upload your brains onto silicon or something else so that you're going to have eternal life. Oh, there's something infinitely better than that, which I call the divine upgrade. [00:21:21]

No matter what stage AI gets to in your lifetime or your children's lifetime or your grandchildren's lifetime or not, let's lift up our heads as Christians and reaffirm our faith that this world that throughout God's son when he visited 20 centuries ago has not heard the last of him. [00:22:09]

Ask a question about this sermon