Naming Names: Discernment in Addressing False Teachings

Devotional

Day 1: Distinguishing Between Wrong and Heretical Teachings

Understanding the difference between wrong and heretical teachings is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the faith. A wrong teaching might stem from a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of scripture, but it does not necessarily lead people away from salvation. Heretical teachings, on the other hand, are those that fundamentally distort the core tenets of Christianity, potentially leading believers astray from the path of salvation. This distinction is vital because it informs how one should respond to different teachings. Addressing heretical teachings requires a more urgent and direct approach to protect the community of believers. [01:30]

2 Peter 2:1-2 (ESV): "But false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, even denying the Master who bought them, bringing upon themselves swift destruction. And many will follow their sensuality, and because of them the way of truth will be blasphemed."

Reflection: Consider a teaching you have encountered that seemed off. How can you discern whether it is simply wrong or truly heretical, and what steps can you take to address it?

Day 2: Biblical Precedent for Naming Names

The Bible provides examples where naming individuals is necessary to protect the church from harmful influences. The Apostle Paul, for instance, named Hymenaeus and Alexander when addressing false teachings. This practice serves as a warning to the community and helps maintain doctrinal purity. Naming names can be a difficult decision, but it is sometimes necessary to prevent the spread of dangerous ideas that could lead believers astray. It is important to approach this with a spirit of love and concern for the well-being of the church. [03:29]

1 Timothy 1:19-20 (ESV): "Holding faith and a good conscience. By rejecting this, some have made shipwreck of their faith, among whom are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan that they may learn not to blaspheme."

Reflection: Think of a situation where you felt the need to call out a false teaching. How can you ensure that your approach is both loving and protective of the community?

Day 3: Instances of Withholding Names

There are times when it is more appropriate to address false teachings without naming individuals. The Bible provides examples, such as the "certain men" from Judea, where names are withheld. This approach can be beneficial in situations where naming names might cause unnecessary division or harm. It requires discernment to know when to address the issue without identifying individuals, focusing instead on correcting the teaching itself. This method can help maintain unity while still addressing the problem. [09:17]

Acts 15:1-2 (ESV): "But some men came down from Judea and were teaching the brothers, 'Unless you are circumcised according to the custom of Moses, you cannot be saved.' And after Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and debate with them, Paul and Barnabas and some of the others were appointed to go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and the elders about this question."

Reflection: Reflect on a time when you chose not to name someone while addressing a false teaching. How did this decision impact the situation and the people involved?

Day 4: Guidance of the Holy Spirit

The decision to name names or not should be guided by the Holy Spirit. There is no strict biblical rule, and each situation requires discernment and sensitivity to the leading of the Spirit. This guidance helps ensure that actions are taken in love and with the best interest of the community in mind. By seeking the Holy Spirit's direction, believers can navigate these complex situations with wisdom and grace, ensuring that their actions align with God's will. [14:24]

John 16:13 (ESV): "When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth, for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come."

Reflection: In what ways can you cultivate a deeper sensitivity to the Holy Spirit's guidance in your life, especially when faced with difficult decisions?

Day 5: Graciousness and Understanding

Believers should be gracious towards those who handle the issue of naming names differently. Whether one chooses to name names or not, the focus should be on addressing the issue in love and seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit. This approach fosters unity and understanding within the community, allowing for diverse perspectives while maintaining a commitment to truth. By showing grace to others, believers can create an environment where open dialogue and growth are encouraged. [15:05]

Ephesians 4:2-3 (ESV): "With all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace."

Reflection: How can you practice graciousness and understanding towards others who may approach the issue of false teachings differently than you do?

Sermon Summary

In today's discussion, we explored the nuanced topic of whether it is appropriate to call out other Christian teachers, leaders, or preachers by name when they teach false doctrines or dangerous ideas. This is a complex issue with biblical examples supporting both sides. On one hand, there are instances in the New Testament where the Apostle Paul names individuals like Hymenaeus, Alexander, and Peter when addressing false teachings or misconduct. This suggests that there is a time and place for naming names, especially when it serves to protect the church from harmful teachings or behaviors.

However, there are also instances where names are deliberately withheld, such as the "certain men" from Judea in Acts 15 or the Rich Young Ruler in Luke 18. This indicates that there are times when it is more appropriate to address the issue without naming individuals. The key takeaway is that there is no strict biblical pattern for when to name names and when not to. Instead, this decision should be guided by the Holy Spirit, taking into account the specific context and the potential impact on the individuals and the broader church community.

This topic also calls for graciousness and understanding among believers who may approach this issue differently. Some may feel led to boldly name names, while others may focus on addressing the doctrinal issues without identifying individuals. Both approaches can be valid, and it is important to avoid judging others who may handle the situation differently. Ultimately, the goal should be to act in love and seek the guidance of the Holy Spirit in each unique situation.

Key Takeaways

1. Distinguishing Between Wrong and Heretical Teachings: It's crucial to differentiate between those who are simply wrong and those who are heretical. A heretic, in this context, is someone whose teachings, if believed, lead people away from salvation. Not every wrong teaching is heretical, and this distinction should guide our response. [01:30]
2. Biblical Precedent for Naming Names: The Apostle Paul provides examples of naming individuals when addressing false teachings, as seen with Hymenaeus and Alexander. This indicates that there is a biblical precedent for naming names when it serves to protect the church from harmful influences. [03:29]
3. Instances of Withholding Names: There are also biblical examples where names are withheld, such as the "certain men" from Judea. This suggests that there are times when it is more appropriate to address the issue without naming individuals, highlighting the need for discernment. [09:17]
4. Guidance of the Holy Spirit: The decision to name names or not should be guided by the Holy Spirit. There is no strict biblical rule, and each situation requires discernment and sensitivity to the leading of the Spirit. [14:24]
5. Graciousness and Understanding: Believers should be gracious towards those who handle this issue differently. Whether one chooses to name names or not, the focus should be on addressing the issue in love and seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit. [15:05]
** [15:05]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[00:16] - Introduction to the Topic
[01:02] - Defining Heresy and Wrong Teachings
[03:13] - Biblical Examples of Naming Names
[05:18] - Confrontation with Peter and Barnabas
[07:04] - Noting Those Who Cause Divisions
[08:14] - Instances of Withholding Names
[10:00] - The Phrase "Let No One"
[11:08] - The Rich Young Ruler
[12:05] - No Strict Pattern for Naming Names
[14:24] - Guidance of the Holy Spirit
[15:05] - Graciousness Towards Different Approaches
[16:29] - Avoiding Sensationalism
[17:07] - Romans 14:4 and Judging Others
[18:09] - Addressing Questions from the Audience

Bible Study Guide

Bible Study Discussion Guide

Bible Reading:

1 Timothy 1:20
Galatians 2:11-13
Acts 15:1-2

---

Observation Questions:

In 1 Timothy 1:20, who are the individuals Paul names, and what does he say about them? How does this relate to the concept of naming names in the church? [03:29]
What was the situation in Galatians 2:11-13 that led Paul to confront Peter and Barnabas by name? What does this tell us about the circumstances under which naming names might be appropriate? [05:18]
In Acts 15:1-2, how does the text describe the individuals who were causing dissension, and what decision was made about them? Why might their names have been withheld? [09:17]
How does the sermon describe the difference between someone who is wrong and someone who is heretical? Why is this distinction important? [01:30]

---

Interpretation Questions:

What might be the reasons Paul chose to name certain individuals in his letters, while at other times, names were withheld? How does this reflect the need for discernment in addressing false teachings? [12:05]
How does the guidance of the Holy Spirit play a role in deciding whether to name names or not? What are some ways believers can seek this guidance in their own lives? [14:24]
The sermon mentions the importance of graciousness and understanding among believers who handle the issue of naming names differently. How can this principle be applied in a church community? [15:05]
How does the example of the Rich Young Ruler in Luke 18 illustrate the decision to withhold names? What might be the reasons for this choice? [11:08]

---

Application Questions:

Reflect on a time when you encountered a teaching or idea that seemed wrong or dangerous. How did you respond, and what might you do differently in light of the sermon’s insights? [01:02]
Consider a situation in your church or community where naming names might be necessary to protect others. How would you approach this decision, and what steps would you take to ensure it is done in love and with discernment? [03:29]
How can you cultivate a sensitivity to the Holy Spirit’s guidance in your daily life, especially when faced with difficult decisions about addressing false teachings or behaviors? [14:24]
Think about a time when you disagreed with someone’s approach to handling false teachings. How can you practice graciousness and understanding towards those who handle such situations differently? [15:05]
Identify a specific area in your life where you need to distinguish between wrong and heretical teachings. How can you seek wisdom and guidance to make this distinction clear? [01:30]
How can you ensure that your actions and decisions in addressing false teachings are motivated by love rather than a desire for controversy or attention? [16:02]
Reflect on the role of community in discerning and addressing false teachings. How can you engage with others in your church to foster a supportive and discerning environment? [17:07]

Sermon Clips

There is a difference between people who are wrong about something and people who are heretical, people who are Heretics. Here's the way I would Define a heretic: a heretic is someone where if you believe what they teach, you'll go to hell. You're not going to go to heaven, you're going to go to hell if you believe what that person teaches. [00:01:20]

People can be wrong, they can be seriously wrong without being heretic. So every heretic is wrong, but not every person with a wrong teaching is a heretic. But whether we're talking about Heretics, whether we're talking about people who are just wrong about certain things, is it right to call them out by name? [00:02:52]

There is definitely a place for naming names, calling out specific false teachers, dangerous teachers. They might be bad guys, they might be good guys doing a bad thing, but there's a place for it. We see from this biblical pattern for calling them out. However, brothers and sisters, that's a big however. [00:07:41]

There is also a time to not name names. What do I mean by that? We'll just go back to that passage that we talked about in Galatians Chapter 2. You know those verses I read you, Galatians chapter 2: 11, 12, and 13, where Paul very dramatically called out Peter. [00:08:06]

Paul simply calls them in Acts 15 verse 1, well not Paul actually, it would be Luke, the one who wrote the book of Acts under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Luke calls them certain men from Judea. That's it. These men had names, they might have been known to people in the church, but he just calls them certain men. [00:09:41]

There is a time when it is appropriate to name names and call people out, but it's not all the time. There is a time when it's not appropriate to name names and call people out. And I have to be honest with you, as I look over these passages, it's difficult to detect a strict pattern here. [00:12:01]

This indicates that this is an area for the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Don't you think that's the main lesson from this? The Holy Spirit wants to speak to us, to a pastor, to a leader, to someone who has a voice in this particular situation, and the Holy Spirit wants to guide them whether or not they should call somebody out by name. [00:14:18]

This is an area for graciousness towards those in the body of Christ who do it differently. Maybe, and I'm just saying maybe, maybe you're one of those people, man, you kind of pride yourself on your boldness and you're out there naming names and you're out there calling people out. [00:14:48]

Do you despise your brother or sister in Christ who doesn't name names, who is much more talking about the particular doctrines that may be wrong without naming names? Do you just kind of look down on them? Listen, understand there's a place for both. [00:15:12]

Sometimes you have the feeling that that's why people are naming names, it's to get more hits, it's to get more clicks, it's to get more attention. And when it's done just for Sensational purposes instead of for the legitimate purpose of informing and warning as appropriate in the scriptures, then I think there's a problem with it. [00:16:03]

Romans 14:4 says this: who are you to judge another man's servant? To his own Master he stands or Falls. Indeed he will be made to stand, for God is able to make him stand. Listen, in an area like this where we have biblical examples of both sides, we have biblical examples of naming names, we have biblical examples of not naming names. [00:16:29]

Let's look to the Holy Spirit to guide us and be careful about judging our brothers and sisters who would do it differently than we do, and trust that if our brother or sister gets it wrong, which surely they do sometimes get it wrong, well, this is common to all of us on this side of Eternity. [00:17:07]

Ask a question about this sermon

Chatbot

Transcript

What was the most surprising thing in this sermon?

Were there any personal stories shared?

Naming Names: Discernment in Addressing False Teachings

Devotional

Day 1: Distinguishing Between Wrong and Heretical Teachings

Day 2: Biblical Precedent for Naming Names

Day 3: Instances of Withholding Names

Day 4: Guidance of the Holy Spirit

Day 5: Graciousness and Understanding

Sermon Summary

Key Takeaways

Youtube Chapters

Bible Study Guide

Sermon Clips

Chatbot

Naming Names: Discernment in Addressing False Teachings

Share