Don't Let Mysticism Steal Jesus from You

Paul sharpens the focus on a single threat: Jesus Christ can be subtly displaced from the center of faith without being openly denied. Colossians 2:18–19 exposes a particular strategy that masquerades as deeper devotion—mysticism—and describes how it creeps in through performative humility and a fascination with angels. What begins with true biblical truths about God's holiness and human sinfulness can slide into the conviction that extra, secret, or experiential access is required to approach the divine. That shift does not overturn doctrine outright; it reorders authority so that personal visions, emotional highs, and insider stories become the deciding voice.

The text names the markers of this deception: a humility that enjoys being seen as humble, detailed recounting of visions that takes the place of scripture as the final court of appeal, and a mindset puffed up by baseless notions. History shows how angel speculation moved from messenger theology into an entire system of spiritual ranking; the result remains the same—Christ loses functional primacy. Experience that cannot be tested by scripture becomes immune to correction and begins to govern relationships, leadership, and discernment. Where experience governs, ordinary discipleship appears mundane, and spiritual life grinds toward impatience, judgment, and pride.

The remedy lies in holding fast to Jesus as the head. Spiritual growth flows from connection to Christ, who supports and holds the body together; growth arrives as God causes it, not as a result of manufactured experiences or insider status. The call to daily vigilance asks believers to notice moments of pressure to prove spiritual depth, record them, and return those places to Christ in prayer. The pathway back to health centers on reorienting authority to scripture and the risen Lord, testing extraordinary claims against God’s word, and practicing humble steadiness—returning to simple, ordinary reliance on Jesus rather than chasing the next encounter.

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. False humility hides inward pride False humility performs modesty to gain influence; it looks humble but delights in the attention that humility brings. That inward satisfaction reorders motives, turning worship into status and making listeners vulnerable to claims of superior spiritual access. Recognizing this keeps discernment honest and prevents subtle spiritual theft. [46:50]
• 2. Experience must not become authority An intense vision or felt encounter can be genuine, but when it becomes the final court of appeal it displaces scripture as the measuring stick. Testing experiences against God’s word protects the church from claims that are untestable and uncorrectable. Holding scripture as the standard preserves communal accountability and theological clarity. [59:17]
• 3. Pride masquerades as spiritual depth Claims to deeper insight often cloak an elevation of self, producing impatience, judgment, and tiers among believers. Spiritual depth that leaves people feeling small is a sign of dominance, not discipleship. True maturity cultivates mercy, humility, and service rather than ranking others by experience. [70:42]
• 4. Stay connected to the Head Christ remains the source of growth; the body lives and grows as God causes it through its union with Jesus. Disconnection produces substitute systems—rules, visions, or ascetic practices—that promise more but shrink Christ’s centrality. Returning to daily dependence on Jesus realigns growth with God’s agency and steadies the soul. [77:16]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [40:49] - Worship and Biblical Teaching
• [41:28] - Entering the Colossians Series
• [42:31] - Paul Tightens the Focus
• [43:24] - From Legalism to Mysticism
• [46:50] - False Humility and Angel Fascination
• [59:17] - When Experience Becomes Authority
• [70:42] - Pride Masquerading as Depth
• [77:16] - Remain Connected to the Head
• [83:27] - Daily Challenge and Closing Prayer

Based on the sermon summary and transcript, the primary text is Colossians 2:18-19. The sermon also explicitly references and explains Revelation 19:10 and 1 John 4:1, which are crucial for understanding the warnings and the biblical remedy presented.

Bible reading
* Colossians 2:18–19 (ESV): Let no one disqualify you, insisting on asceticism and worship of angels, going on in detail about visions, puffed up without reason by his sensuous mind, and not holding fast to the Head, from whom the whole body, nourished and knit together through its joints and ligaments, grows with a growth that is from God.
* Revelation 19:10 (ESV): Then I fell down at his feet to worship him, but he said to me, “You must not do that! I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold to the testimony of Jesus. Worship God.”
* 1 John 4:1 (ESV): Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world.

Observation questions

1. According to Colossians 2:18, what are the specific markers or behaviors of the deceptive threat Paul is warning about?
2. What is the ultimate result for a person who engages in these behaviors, as described in Colossians 2:19?
3. In the account from Revelation 19:10, how does the angel correct John's action, and what reason does he give?
4. What clear command does 1 John 4:1 give believers regarding spiritual claims and experiences?

Interpretation questions

1. Why is a "humility that enjoys being seen as humble" [48:03] considered false and dangerous, rather than just a minor character flaw?
2. How can an intense spiritual experience or vision, which might be genuine, become a problem that "displaces scripture as the measuring stick"? [01:02:47]
3. The text says a person captivated by these things is "puffed up without reason by his sensuous mind" (Col. 2:18). How does a pursuit that seems so spiritual ultimately lead to pride and an "unspiritual mind"?
4. The remedy is to "hold fast to the Head." What does this connection to Christ provide that manufactured spiritual experiences or secret insights cannot?

Application questions

1. "False humility performs modesty to gain influence." [46:50] When have you been tempted to share a spiritual struggle or act of service in a way that was really a subtle attempt to appear humble or gain approval? What would it look like to turn that moment over to Christ in prayer instead?
2. "An intense vision or felt encounter can be genuine, but when it becomes the final court of appeal it displaces scripture." [59:17] How can you practice the command in 1 John 4:1 to "test the spirits" in your daily life? What is a recent claim, teaching, or personal feeling you should test against God’s word?
3. "Spiritual depth that leaves people feeling small is a sign of dominance, not discipleship." [01:10:42] Reflect on your recent conversations about faith. Do people walk away more aware of your experiences or more in awe of Jesus? What is one practical way to make Christ the center of your spiritual conversations this week?
4. "Christ remains the source of growth; the body lives and grows as God causes it through its union with Jesus." [01:17:16] Where have you been tempted to chase a spiritual high, a new conference, or a special experience, believing it would cause the growth that only God can give? How can you reorient your daily routine toward "simple, ordinary reliance on Jesus"?
5. The daily challenge was to ask, "Where did I feel the pressure to prove something spiritually today?" [01:23:47] What was one instance this week where you felt that pressure to perform, sound impressive, or prove your spiritual depth? What does that specific pressure reveal about what you are functionally adding to Jesus?