8. Jesus, Truth, & Spin [Matthew] - Tim Mackie (The Bible Project)

Jesus is inaugurating the kingdom—God’s loving rule breaking into our world to reclaim and renew people. In Matthew 5–7, he isn’t offering behavior tweaks; he’s forming a people whose inner life is transformed so that their outward life becomes truly human again. Today I pressed on the deep issue beneath lying and oath-taking: our impulse to bend reality to manage how others perceive us. With an iceberg image, I invited us to see that what shows above the surface—oaths, spin, embellishment, religious language—hides a massive unseen core: fear, insecurity, and the need to control.

In Jesus’ world, people swore by heaven, earth, Jerusalem, even their own heads—semantic loopholes meant to sound devout while keeping wiggle room. Jesus cuts through the maze: let your yes be yes and your no be no. The issue isn’t ancient oath formulas; it’s how we use words to impress, to manipulate, to bypass another’s honest discernment. Dallas Willard called it verbal manipulation—spin that violates love by taking away another person’s freedom to truly see, weigh, and respond.

We explored contemporary forms: advertising that trades on borrowed emotions; name-dropping and embellished origin stories when we’re new; the religious trump card—“I prayed about it,” “God gave me peace,” “God called me”—used at times to shut down input. I shared my own embarrassing moment trying to sound competent before 300 funeral directors when the truthful answer was, “I don’t know.” Beneath all this is fear: fear of insignificance, fear of being known, fear of exposure. And fear breeds hiding.

The gospel’s answer is not willpower but love. First John says God’s love came among us in Jesus—his life for us, his death for us—so that we might live through him. Perfect love drives out fear. When Jesus’ unearned, initiating love settles into our bones, our worth is no longer negotiated by public opinion. That frees us to be simply honest—no smoke screens, no borrowed holiness, no managing outcomes. This is how Jesus heals communities: by remaking people whose words line up with reality, so love can actually take root.

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. Let your yes be yes Simple truthful speech honors others’ ability to weigh reality without pressure or polish. Jesus doesn’t ban legal oaths as much as he exposes the heart that needs them to sound serious. The kingdom invites us into a life where words correspond to reality because we’re no longer hustling for approval. [18:35]
• 2. Manipulation corrodes genuine relationships Spin looks efficient, but it hollows out trust by overriding the judgment of others. When I inflate, airbrush, or borrow someone’s credibility, I’m using people rather than loving them. Love tells the whole truth at a pace mercy can bear. [20:04]
• 3. Fear hides; love frees honesty The deep engine beneath our spin is fear—of being small, seen, or rejected. In Jesus, God’s initiating love defines our worth and covers our failures. Perfect love drives out fear, loosening our grip on image-management so we can be known and still be safe. [40:16]
• 4. Stop using God as cover Religious language can become camouflage to avoid counsel or accountability. “God called me” is sometimes a way to end conversation rather than invite wisdom. Integrity means letting Jesus’ name sanctify our honesty, not our agendas. [31:46]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [01:17] - King Jesus and the kingdom’s dawn
• [02:15] - What renewed humans look like
• [03:35] - The kingdom’s highest ethic: love
• [04:37] - The iceberg beneath our words
• [08:27] - Surface behavior vs root causes
• [10:10] - Oaths in Israel’s story
• [15:30] - Swearing by heaven, earth, Jerusalem
• [16:36] - Jesus exposes loopholes and legalism
• [19:23] - Willard on manipulation and spin
• [21:22] - Modern spin: ads, airbrushed selves
• [27:18] - “I don’t know”: a hard lesson
• [29:13] - Using God-language as a shield
• [34:20] - Hiding, fear, and the playground bully
• [36:34] - Perfect love casts out fear
• [43:48] - Communion: praying for honest hearts

Bible reading
Read Matthew 5:33–37 (ESV)

33 “Again you have heard that say to those of old, ‘You shall not swear falsely, but shall perform to the Lord what you have sworn.’ 34 But I say to you, Do not take an oath at all, either by heaven, for it is the throne of God, 35 or by the earth, for it is his footstool, or by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King. 36 And do not take an oath by your head, for you cannot make one hair white or black. 37 Let what you say be simply ‘Yes’ or ‘No’; anything more than this comes from evil.

Observation questions (3–4)

1. After reading Matthew 5:33–37, what single command does Jesus give about ordinary speech and oaths? (Focus on verse 37.)
2. What ancient practices did people use to make their words seem weighty (examples: swearing by heaven, earth, Jerusalem, or one’s own head)? How did those practices try to get around the command not to misuse God’s name? [15:55]
3. What modern forms of verbal “spin” or manipulation were named as examples (advertising that borrows emotions, name‑dropping, embellished personal stories, using religious language as a trump card)? [21:22]
4. How does 1 John describe God’s action toward us and the effect it should have on fear? (Listen for the phrase “perfect love casts out fear.”) [40:16]

Interpretation questions (3–4)

1. What does “let your yes be yes and your no be no” mean for how a community should make and keep commitments? How would this shape everyday trust and conflict within a church or small group? [18:35]
2. Why does invoking something else (especially God) to make one’s words seem weighty become a form of manipulation rather than love? What freedom and dignity does such honesty preserve for the listener? [20:04]
3. How does fear operate as the unseen engine under the iceberg of spin—pushing people to control impressions, to embellish, or to bully? In what ways does fear produce hiding rather than honest relating? [36:02]
4. When John says “perfect love casts out fear,” is that presented as an immediate fix or as part of being remade by Jesus over time? What does this say about the process of becoming a person whose words line up with reality? [41:11]

Application questions (4–7)

1. Name a recent situation when you used words to manage how someone else perceived you (a small exaggeration, name‑dropping, or a defensive “spin”). What fear was underneath that choice? How might you tell that story differently next time? [26:17]
2. Identify one decision you’re tempted to present as “God told me” in order to avoid counsel or push people away. Who are two wise people you can invite into honest input before you move forward, and how will you invite them? [29:13]
3. Think of the last time you felt pressure to sound competent and instead said more than you knew (the “I don’t know” moment). What would practicing a simple “I don’t know” look like for you this week in one concrete conversation? [27:18]
4. What specific, small practice could your group try to encourage simple truthful speech (for example: a monthly vulnerability check‑in, agreed ground‑rules for candid feedback, or an accountability pair)? How will you start it? [44:52]
5. Which fear most drives you to airbrush your story—fear of insignificance, of being known, or of rejection? What truth about God’s initiating love do you need to hold onto this week to loosen that fear? [41:58]
6. Give one concrete example of a “yes” or “no” you will simplify this week so your words line up with reality (e.g., decline a request without over‑explaining; tell a truthful brief account of a mistake). When will you do it and who will hold you accountable? [18:35]