Jesus: Messiah or Myth?

Devotional

Day 1: Enemies as Witnesses: The Historical Reality of Jesus

The question of Jesus’ existence isn’t a modern debate. Ancient critics—Roman senators, Jewish historians, and hostile officials—wrote about Him as a real person, not a myth. Tacitus, a Roman senator who despised Christians, documented Jesus’ execution under Pontius Pilate. Josephus, a Jewish historian, referenced James as “the brother of Jesus called the Messiah.” Even Jesus’ fiercest opponents never denied He lived; they argued over His identity, not His existence. History leaves no room for doubt: Jesus walked the earth. [09:38]

Now there was a man sent from God, whose name was John. He came as a witness, to bear witness about the light, that all might believe through him. He was not the light, but came to bear witness about the light. (John 1:6–8, ESV)

Reflection: How does knowing Jesus’ existence is affirmed by both friends and enemies strengthen your confidence in sharing Him? What historical detail about Jesus’ life resonates most deeply with you?

Day 2: The Unavoidable Choice: Liar, Lunatic, or Lord

Jesus’ bold claims to divinity force a reckoning. He didn’t leave room for neutral admiration. If He falsely claimed to be God, He’d be a liar. If He deludedly believed it, He’d be a lunatic. But His miracles, fulfilled prophecies, and resurrection validate His claim: He is Lord. A “good teacher” wouldn’t fabricate divinity; only God incarnate could back such a claim with authority over death itself. [12:23]

Jesus said to them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was, I am.” So they picked up stones to throw at him, but Jesus hid himself and went out of the temple. (John 8:58–59, ESV)

Reflection: When have you wrestled with Jesus’ identity? How does His resurrection resolve the tension between His claims and His character?

Day 3: A Spear, Blood, and Water: The Certainty of Jesus’ Death

Roman executioners were experts in death. When a soldier pierced Jesus’ side, blood and water flowed—a medical sign of hypovolemic shock and cardiac rupture. The Romans had no motive to fake His death; their careers depended on ensuring it. Even hostile historians like Tacitus confirm Jesus’ crucifixion. Without His death, there’s no payment for sin. Without His resurrection, there’s no hope. But the spear proves He died. [23:56]

But when they came to Jesus and saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs. But one of the soldiers pierced his side with a spear, and at once there came out blood and water. (John 19:33–34, ESV)

Reflection: Why is Jesus’ physical death essential to your faith? How does the soldiers’ brutal efficiency affirm the truth of the cross?

Day 4: Empty Tomb, Full Proof: The Resurrection’s Historical Weight

The empty tomb wasn’t quietly ignored. Roman guards spread a cover story: “His disciples stole the body.” But stolen bodies don’t transform cowards into martyrs. Over 500 witnesses saw the risen Jesus, including Saul, a persecutor who became Christianity’s boldest defender. Hallucinations can’t explain shared meals, physical touch, or Saul’s radical conversion. Only resurrection fits the evidence. [28:15]

While they were going, behold, some of the guard went into the city and told the chief priests all that had taken place. And when they had assembled with the elders and taken counsel, they gave a sufficient sum of money to the soldiers and said, “Tell people, ‘His disciples came by night and stole him away while we were asleep.’” (Matthew 28:11–13, ESV)

Reflection: Which resurrection account (the guards, the 500, or Saul) most dismantles doubt for you? How does the empty tomb shape your daily hope?

Day 5: From Evidence to Action: Living a Resurrection-Ready Life

Christianity isn’t blind faith. It’s built on historical events demanding a response. Peter urges believers to “always be prepared to give an answer” for their hope. This means studying the resurrection’s evidence, practicing its defense, and sharing its life-changing power. When friends ask, “How do you know?” point to the tomb, the witnesses, and the martyrs. Then invite them to meet the living Christ. [37:36]

But in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you. (1 Peter 3:15, ESV)

Reflection: What step will you take this week to deepen your understanding of the resurrection? Who in your life needs to hear, “He is risen,” with both evidence and love?

Sermon Summary

The resurrection stands as the hinge on which everything turns. If it did not happen, Christians stay guilty, still pay for sin, and have no hope. If it did happen, forgiveness, life, and confidence are on solid ground. So the question presses: Jesus, Messiah or myth?

History answers first. The Gospels read like reportage, not fairy tale. They fix Jesus inside verifiable coordinates with Pontius Pilate, Joseph Caiaphas, and Herod Antipas. Jesus’ enemies wanted him silenced, not erased, and none of them denied he existed. Tacitus, Josephus, and Pliny the Younger—no friends of the faith—write as if everyone already knows Jesus is real.

The question then becomes, who is Jesus? Jesus’ own claims force a choice. “The Father and I are one.” “Before Abraham was born, I am.” Asked if he is the Messiah, he says, “I am.” The trilemma stands: liar, lunatic, or Lord. A liar lies to avoid pain or gain power; Jesus’ claims bought him one thing, a cross. A lunatic speaks from instability; Jesus teaches with moral clarity, coherence, and mission, shaping nations and lives. Prophecy then seals it. Hundreds of years before his birth, over 300 messianic fingerprints are set down, and Jesus fulfills them—far beyond chance—signaling not myth but the promised Lord.

Roman execution answers the next question. Rome made a career of getting death right. Scourging with the flagellum drains the life. Six hours on a cross suffocates the body. A spear to the side draws “blood and water,” the telltale sign of catastrophic failure around heart and lungs. A soldier has every motive to confirm death because his own life is on the line. Death is certain, which is why resurrection can be meaningful.

The empty tomb opens the case for Sunday. A hurried “cover story” about disciples stealing the body only makes sense if the grave is bare. Saul’s about-face from persecutor to apostle tracks with an encounter the text treats as real, public, and corroborated. Five hundred eyewitnesses are invited for cross-examination—collective hallucination has no psychological footing. The martyrs finally speak loudest. People may die for what they mistakenly think is true; no one dies for what they know they made up.

First Peter 3:15 then names the assignment. The call to Christians is clear: prepare to give an answer with gentleness and respect. The call to those not yet trusting Christ is just as clear: the risen Jesus asks, “Who do you say I am?” Belief receives his death as payment and his life as Lord.

Key Takeaways

1. The resurrection holds everything together The claim is not a side issue; it is the center. If Jesus did not rise, guilt and death still own the last word. If he did, forgiveness and future are not wishful thinking but grounded reality. Hope becomes durable because it is tethered to an event. [02:25]
2. History anchors Jesus, not myth The Gospels tie Jesus to names, offices, and places that can be checked, while hostile sources mention him without apology. Enemies contest his claims, not his existence. The difference between fairy tale and history shows up in details only historians would bother keeping. [09:38]
3. Liar, lunatic, or Lord still stands Jesus claims God’s name and prerogatives, which rules out “just a teacher” or “only a prophet.” He gains no comfort or clout from the claim and shows none of the chaos of delusion. Prophecy fulfilled at scale further tilts the field toward Lord, not legend. [13:09]
4. Roman expertise confirmed real death Scourging, crucifixion, and a spear-thrust are not survivable theatrics. “Blood and water” match known pathology from massive trauma and hypovolemic shock. A soldier’s career, even life, depended on certifying death, which is why no honest path remains for swoon theories. [23:56]
5. The risen Jesus leaves footprints An empty tomb needs explaining, and the official “cover story” gives away more than it protects. A persecutor becomes an apostle after a public encounter, five hundred eyewitnesses defy the rules of hallucination, and martyrs refuse to recant what they saw. The trail is historical, personal, and costly. [28:15]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[00:33] - Messiah or myth?
[01:19] - Why the resurrection matters
[03:11] - Four-question roadmap
[03:42] - Was Jesus a real person?
[08:12] - Not a fairy tale, real history
[09:38] - Enemies and extra-biblical witnesses
[11:57] - Who is Jesus, really?
[12:23] - Liar, lunatic, or Lord
[17:34] - Prophecy fulfilled by Jesus
[21:18] - Did Jesus really die?
[23:56] - Blood, water, and Roman expertise
[27:21] - Did Jesus really rise?
[30:31] - Empty tomb, Saul, and the 500
[35:08] - Martyrs and the call to prepare
[39:05] - The question and a gospel invitation

Bible Study Guide

Bible reading
1 Peter 3:15 (ESV)
But in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect.

1 Corinthians 15:3-6 (ESV)
For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep.

Observation questions

The sermon mentions that Jesus’ enemies spread a “cover story” about disciples stealing His body (Matthew 28:11-15). Why would this story only make sense if the tomb was already empty?
According to the sermon, what three options does C.S. Lewis’ “trilemma” present about Jesus’ identity (liar, lunatic, or Lord)? How does the sermon argue against the first two options? [12:23]
In 1 Corinthians 15:3-6, Paul lists eyewitnesses of the resurrected Jesus. Why does he specifically mention the 500 people still alive at the time of his writing?

Interpretation questions

The sermon emphasizes Roman soldiers’ expertise in confirming death (e.g., scourging, spear thrust). Why would their professional reputation and accountability make Jesus’ survival implausible? [23:56]
When Jesus’ side was pierced, “blood and water” flowed out (John 19:34). How does this detail medically and historically reinforce the certainty of His death? [24:37]
The sermon argues that people might die for a lie they believe is true, but not for a lie they know is false. How does the apostles’ martyrdom challenge alternative explanations for the resurrection? [35:08]

Application questions

First Peter 3:15 calls believers to “always be prepared” to explain their hope. What practical step could you take this week to better understand or articulate the evidence for Jesus’ resurrection?
Jesus’ question, “Who do you say I am?” (Mark 8:29) is central to the sermon. How would you answer this question today, and how might that answer shape your priorities? [39:36]
The sermon highlights that doubters can investigate the resurrection’s historical claims (e.g., the 500 witnesses). How could you graciously invite someone skeptical to explore these facts with you?
If Jesus’ resurrection guarantees forgiveness and hope, what fear, guilt, or habit might you need to surrender to Him this week?
The sermon notes that martyrs refused to recant their testimony. What convictions about Jesus are worth holding onto even when it’s costly? [35:36]
How might living with “durable hope” (tethered to the resurrection) change the way you respond to suffering or uncertainty?

Sermon Clips

36s

“I mentioned that everybody's gonna stand in front of Jesus one day, and that means you as well. You're gonna stand in front of Jesus just the same as I'm gonna stand in front of Jesus, and Jesus is gonna ask us one question. And let me tell you what that question's not gonna be. That question is not gonna be, how good did you do? That question is not gonna be, did you balance the scales, good or bad? That question is not gonna be, did you try hard enough? That question is not gonna be, were you better than the next guy? That question is gonna be, what did you do with me? Who do you say I am?”

36s

“The martyrs. This one's short, this one's quick, and this one's powerful. Because here's the thing, most of the apostles suffered and died because they continued to preach the resurrection. But if they had made it up, go back to our cover story, if they had made up the resurrection, if they had brought Jesus out of the tomb themselves, they would never allow themselves to be tortured and killed for that. There's a lot of people who will die for something that they believe is true, but I've never met anybody who would die for something that they knew was a lie, much less a lie that they had created themselves.”

35s

“Like I mentioned earlier, our entire faith hinges on this one question. If Jesus really rose from the dead, then all of us who are Christians, we're saved. We're forgiven for our sins. We're good. We've got eternity in heaven to look forward to. But if Jesus died on the cross and did not rise from the dead later, we are out of luck. We are hopeless. We are doomed. So it's imperative that when we're sharing our faith, we know without a shadow of a doubt that Jesus rose from the dead because this is what we're asking people to put their faith in. And so, let's prove the resurrection.”

49s

“Romans were expert killers. They didn't play around with execution. They had mastered it. They knew what death looked like. And so, to avoid being punished or even killed himself, the Roman soldier confirmed without a shadow of a doubt that Jesus was dead. And this is a fact that both Christian sources like the bible and non Christian sources like Tacitus who we talked about earlier affirm. And again, the reason that this is so important is because you cannot have a resurrection without a death. But now here's the question. Cool. Jesus was a real guy. Jesus claims to be God. Jesus died on the cross, did Jesus really rise from the dead?”

Ask a question about this sermon

New Day Church This sermon · AI assistant

What historical evidence supports Jesus' existence?

How does liar lunatic or Lord argument work?

What are the strongest evidences for resurrection?

Jesus: Messiah or Myth? | Jack Duga