Mercy, Not Sacrifice: Jesus Welcomes the Outcasts

Jul 19, 2026

Devotional

Day 1: Jesus Calls from the Tax Booth, Not the Temple

Jesus doesn’t wait for polished resumes or perfect behavior. He interrupts Matthew mid-exploitation, mid-sin, mid-shame, and offers two words that rewrite a life: "Follow me." This isn’t a conditional invitation for the spiritually presentable. It’s a disruptive grace that meets people where they are, not where religion insists they should be. Matthew’s story dismantles the idea that God only recruits from the "in-group." Jesus bypasses the temple’s approval process and chooses a collaborator with empire. Mercy arrives unannounced, unearned, and utterly undeserved. [46:40]

"Jesus saw a man called Matthew sitting at the tax booth, and he said to him, 'Follow me.' And he rose and followed him." (Matthew 9:9, ESV)

Reflection: Who in your life feels "too far gone" for Jesus’ invitation? How might your assumptions about their spiritual eligibility limit your willingness to extend mercy?

Day 2: Dining with Those Religion Excludes

Matthew’s dinner party becomes a scandal not because of the menu, but the guest list. Jesus doesn’t just tolerate the excluded—he actively centers them. The table flips religion’s seating chart: those deemed "unclean" get front-row seats, while the self-assured critique from the sidelines. This isn’t charity work; it’s kinship. Jesus’ presence declares that belonging isn’t earned through moral résumés but received through mutual need. The real miracle isn’t the meal—it’s the mingling of mercy. [48:58]

"And as Jesus reclined at table in the house, behold, many tax collectors and sinners came and were reclining with Jesus and his disciples. And when the Pharisees saw this, they said to his disciples, 'Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?'" (Matthew 9:10–11, ESV)

Reflection: Whose presence at your "table" (literal or metaphorical) would feel uncomfortable? What fears or judgments might that discomfort reveal about your own boundaries?

Day 3: Mercy Over Sacrifice: God’s Heartbeat in Hosea 6:6

Religious systems love measurable sacrifices—donations, rituals, perfect attendance. But God’s longing cuts deeper: "I desire mercy, not sacrifice." Jesus quotes this prophet to religious experts, exposing how their meticulous rule-keeping had hardened their hearts. Mercy isn’t a spiritual accessory—it’s the core. It costs more than any ritual: it demands dismantling superiority, sitting with the "unclean," and letting love override self-righteousness. True worship bleeds into the streets. [53:01]

"For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings." (Hosea 6:6, ESV)

Reflection: Where have you prioritized "sacrifice" (religious performance) over "mercy" (relational risk)? What practical step could shift that balance today?

Day 4: Bankers in Dockers at the Sinners’ Table

Nadia Bolz-Weber’s church welcomed drag queens and addicts—until bankers showed up. The discomfort reveals our hidden biases: we’ll embrace the "colorful" sinners but balk at the respectable ones. Jesus’ table unsettles everyone. The outcast and the upright both need grace, but only the broken-hearted know it. Mercy’s circle keeps widening, challenging our secret rankings of who’s "worthy." True community isn’t curated—it’s chaotic with need. [56:40]

"But when you give a feast, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, the blind, and you will be blessed, because they cannot repay you." (Luke 14:13–14, ESV)

Reflection: Who surprises you by their presence in God’s family? How might your unspoken rankings of sin hinder your ability to see others as equally loved?

Day 5: Sitting Uncomfortably: The Call to Listen Without Agenda

Jesus’ model isn’t outreach programs—it’s shared meals. He doesn’t fix the tax collectors; he feasts with them. The challenge isn’t to "save" people but to sit in unhurried solidarity. This means silencing our inner Pharisee—the voice that wants to correct, convert, or flee. Presence without performance is the hardest work of mercy. It means believing that love, not lectures, changes hearts. [01:00:12]

"Be merciful, even as your Father is merciful." (Luke 6:36, ESV)

Reflection: When did you last listen to someone "messy" without trying to fix them? What keeps you from seeing such moments as sacred obedience?

Sermon Summary

Matthew 9 places Jesus at a tax booth, right in broad daylight, where Matthew has made a career out of betraying his own people. Jesus does not wait for Matthew to clean up his act, pass a theological exam, offer character references, survive a probationary period, or make it through a membership class. Jesus says two words, “Follow me,” and Matthew gets up and follows.

Matthew’s table becomes a veritable who’s who of first century religious outcasts. Tax collectors and sinners, people told a hundred different ways that they did not belong at any kind of religious table, end up eating with Jesus. Jesus does not send regrets or suggest a more respectable venue. Jesus shows up, sits down, stays awhile, and listens.

The Pharisees are appalled, but they do not confront Jesus directly. The Pharisees ask the disciples why their teacher eats with tax collectors and sinners, because respectable religion has a guest list, and Matthew’s house is not on it. Jesus answers with the image of a doctor: those who are well have no need of a physician, only those who are sick. Jesus then sends the Pharisees back to their own Bible: “Go and learn what this means, I desire mercy, not sacrifice.”

Hosea 6:6 exposes the danger of religion that has become performance. The old sacrificial system was detailed, demanding, and manageable for people with money, access, and the know-how to navigate it. The poor, the uneducated, and the unhealthy often found themselves pushed outside the system. The Pharisees became performance champions, but Jesus says God is after mercy, not medals.

Performative religion knows the right words, the right behavior, and the right distance from the wrong people. A Baptist-shaped world of “who is in and who is out” can teach the Bible and community well, yet still draw boundaries around who God loves and who God merely tolerates. The old line, “love the sinner, hate the sin,” often carries an unspoken warning: do not love the sinner too much.

Mercy widens the circle without pretending prejudice only belongs to other people. The story of the House for All Sinners and Saints shows that even a room built for outcasts can develop its own hidden guest list when “bankers in Dockers” start showing up. Jesus does not write off the Pharisees either. Jesus gives them homework: unlearn religious performance and learn mercy.

The Jesus worldview asks the church to notice who is missing from the guest list. Jesus calls not the righteous, but sinners, especially the ones who know they are a mess and believe they do not deserve a seat at the table. Mercy has a simple shape: have a meal, a coffee, or a conversation with someone outside the usual circle, with no agenda to fix them, just sit and stay awhile.

Key Takeaways

1. Jesus calls before paperwork Jesus speaks only two words to Matthew: “Follow me.” The call comes before proof, polishing, membership process, or religious manageability. Grace does not wait until a person becomes respectable enough to be seen with Jesus. [46:40]
2. Mercy outruns religious performance Jesus quotes Hosea to people who already know the Scripture but have missed its heart. Sacrifice can become a manageable system for people with resources, while mercy moves toward the ones the system has excluded. God is not impressed by religious medals when the table has no room for sinners. [50:42]
3. The table reveals hidden boundaries Matthew’s dinner table shows where Jesus is willing to be seen. The Pharisees’ discomfort exposes a guest list shaped more by respectability than by the mercy of God. A table can become either a fence around the acceptable or a place where Christ makes room for the written off. [48:58]
4. Prejudice can hide inside welcome The Denver church story shows that even a community formed for outsiders can become uneasy when a different kind of outsider arrives. A hidden guest list is often most dangerous because it feels like discernment, not exclusion. Mercy has to keep widening the circle, even when the new guest is not the one expected. [56:40]
5. Mercy sits and listens first The weekly challenge is simple, but not small: share a meal, coffee, or conversation with someone outside the usual guest list. Jesus does not model fixing people at the table; Jesus models presence, welcome, and patient listening. Mercy begins when an agenda is set down long enough to see a person. [59:31]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[31:38] - Matthew Hears “Follow Me”
[34:49] - Mercy, Not Sacrifice
[37:57] - Baptist Jokes and Respectability
[40:22] - A Baptist Beginning
[42:47] - The Gospels Turn Things Upside Down
[44:31] - Jesus at the Edges
[45:13] - Matthew the Tax Collector
[46:40] - Two Words, No Probation
[48:58] - Dinner With Tax Collectors and Sinners
[50:42] - Hosea and the Heart of God
[53:49] - The Guest List Gets Larger
[54:14] - A House for Sinners and Saints
[57:02] - Unlearning Performative Religion
[59:31] - A Meal Outside the Usual Circle
[63:45] - Seeing With the Lens of Jesus

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading

Matthew 9:9-13

“As Jesus passed on from there, he saw a man called Matthew sitting at the tax booth, and he said to him, ‘Follow me.’ And he rose and followed him. And as Jesus reclined at table in the house, behold, many tax collectors and sinners came and were reclining with Jesus and his disciples. And when the Pharisees saw this, they said to his disciples, ‘Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?’ But when he heard it, he said, ‘Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. Go and learn what this means, “I desire mercy, and not sacrifice.” For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.’” [46:40]

Observation questions

In this passage, what does Jesus say to Matthew at the tax booth, and what does Matthew do next? [46:40]
Who shows up at the table in Matthew’s house, and who is disturbed by that dinner? [48:58]
When the Pharisees question what is happening, who do they speak to, and who actually answers them? [50:11]
What two images or phrases does Jesus use to explain why he is eating with tax collectors and sinners: the image of a doctor and the line from Hosea? [50:29]

Interpretation questions

Jesus calls Matthew before any cleanup, proof, or probation. What does that suggest about how grace works, and why might that have been so offensive to people shaped by respectability? [46:40]
Jesus says, “I desire mercy, and not sacrifice.” How can religious faith drift into performance, and why does mercy expose that drift so clearly? [50:42]
The Pharisees seem more concerned with the guest list than with the people at the table. What does that reveal about how people can confuse holiness with distance from the “wrong” kind of people? [49:52]
Jesus does not only challenge the sinners at the table; he also tells the Pharisees, “Go and learn.” What might that show about Jesus’ mercy even toward people who are rigid, proud, or exclusionary? [58:01]

Application questions

Most people have some version of a hidden guest list. Who tends to fall outside that circle in real life: a type of person, a social group, a political group, a neighbor, a coworker, or even a church person? What makes that boundary feel reasonable or justified? [58:36]
Jesus sat down without an agenda to fix people first. When conversations become uncomfortable, is there a temptation to correct, manage, or keep distance instead of simply listening? What would it look like to “sit and stay awhile” with someone who does not fit the usual circle? [01:00:07]
Mercy widens the circle, even when the new person at the table is not the kind of outsider expected. Is it easier to welcome some outsiders than others? What does that reveal about personal blind spots or quiet prejudices? [56:40]
Jesus says the sick need a physician, and he came to call sinners. Is it easier to identify with Matthew and the sinners in this story, or with the Pharisees guarding the table? Why? [59:13]
Religious performance can look polished while still building barriers between people and the love of God. What habits, attitudes, or church instincts can quietly send the message, “Do not come too close unless you become more respectable first”? [57:33]
Jesus’ call was simple: “Follow me.” Is there any place in life where shame, past choices, or fear of not being good enough has made that call hard to trust? What would it mean to believe that Jesus still calls before the paperwork is complete? [48:44]
What is one concrete step to take this week to practice mercy in the shape of a meal, coffee, or an honest conversation with someone outside the usual guest list? What might make that hard, and what might make it holy? [59:31]

Sermon Clips

64s

#DineAndListen

“And so, my friends, the challenge I want to offer you this week, should you choose to accept it, is simple. Have a meal, or coffee or just a simple conversation with someone not on your usual guest list. That's it. You've got seven days to accomplish this task. Someone maybe that religion has told you to avoid, somebody whose life looks different than yours or whose choices you simply don't understand, maybe somebody whose presence makes you a little bit uncomfortable. And in that conversation, don't fix them. Don't have an agenda. Just sit and stay a while and listen. This is what Jesus modeled for us as he sat with the tax collectors and the sinners, and may we go and do likewise.”

66s

#ComeAsYouAre

“The righteous don't think they need a doctor. The sinners that know they're a mess and think they don't deserve a seat at the table, that's the kind of people Christ came for. And so, my friends, the challenge I want to offer you this week, should you choose to accept it, is simple. Have a meal, or coffee or just a simple conversation with someone not on your usual guest list. That's it. You've got seven days to accomplish this task. Someone maybe that religion has told you to avoid, somebody whose life looks different than yours or whose choices you simply don't understand, maybe somebody whose presence makes you a little bit uncomfortable. And in that conversation, don't fix them. Don't have an agenda. Just sit and stay a while and listen.”

62s

#MercyNotSacrifice

“The Pharisees were expert navigators of this elaborate sacrificial system. They were performance champions, performative religion, they had medals galore. But over time, it's almost as if the performance of the religion had become the very point. And so Jesus knows that they know the scriptures, they know Hosea six six, and so Jesus quotes them right from their own scriptures, I desire mercy, sacrifice. This is God talking to the people of Israel, and the meaning is is simply this, that that God desires, not our religious performance, but our hearts, especially our hearts for those religion excluded.”

58s

#UnlearnPerformativeFaith

“This performance religion, I I got pretty good at it. Like I said before, I knew the right words, I knew how to act, I knew how to keep a polished distance from the wrong people. Frat boys in college stayed away from those guys. But what I was doing in the meantime is I was building a barrier between me and the people that God loved. The good news in this story is Jesus says to the pharisees, go and learn what this means. Jesus didn't write the pharisees off either, but he gave them some homework to unlearn their religious performance, to learn something else. You know what that thing was? Mercy. I require mercy, not sacrifice.”

50s

#CheckYourGuestList

“Mercy that sits down at the table with tax collectors and sinners and balcony sitters. Mercy Mercy mercy is what God requires of us, and so this Jesus worldview invites us to look at our own guest list and and to think about who is not on our guest list, not the obvious ones, but let's work on the more subtle ones. The people we're less enthusiastic being around, the ones we'd rather Jesus invite. As Nadia Boltz Weber discovered, maybe there's a surprise in there, maybe we have a hidden guest list, the prejudice we don't even know about.”

55s

#WidenTheCircle

“And then she recognized the irony in her own prejudice. She wanted the sinners, she was less comfortable with the saints, and she was tempted to kind of exclude them until she recognized it, named it, and widened her own circle. And that, friends, that's what the Jesus worldview requires all of us to do in some way or another. The uncomfortable question that we're being asked is, have we confused our performance of religion with the very point of our religion?”

40s

#FollowThenFeast

“See, there was this whole process in the Baptist church, and Jesus said two words to Matthew, what were they again? Follow That's it. Matthew got up and followed, and then he throws a dinner party. It was a veritable who's who of first century religious outcasts, tax collectors and sinners, people who have been told a 100 different ways that you do not belong at any kind of religious table, and that's where Jesus goes to dinner that night.”

31s

#SeeLikeJesus

“You will not always see clearly, none of us do. But keep returning to the source, keep trying on the lens, and when the world hands you its version of reality, its fear, its contempt, its scarcity, you are free to hand it back. Because you have seen something better, so go, see the world the way Jesus saw it, love the world the way Jesus loved it, and in this world, may we be like Jesus. Amen.”

Ask a question about this sermon

Chapel-By-The-Sea Clearwater This sermon · AI assistant

Who are the ones Christ came to call?

What does mercy prioritize over ritual religious sacrifice?

How can Christians unlearn performative religious habits?