Joshua’s battle at Jericho is often remembered as a simple victory story: good guys win, bad guys lose, walls fall, and God makes a way where there is no way. But the ban, or herem, will not let the story stay that simple. The language of total destruction sounds like war crimes, and the death of men, women, children, and animals should make God’s people weep rather than cheer without thought.
Herem means something irrevocably set apart for God, either for sacred use or for judgment. The ban declares that victory belongs to the Lord, not to Israel’s military power, and it confronts idolatry that had become deeply destructive. But the text itself complicates any reading that assumes every person was literally annihilated. Deuteronomy commands total destruction, then gives instructions about not intermarrying with the very people who supposedly would not remain. Joshua declares the city destroyed, then immediately rescues Rahab, her family, and all who belonged to her.
Conquest literature also helps explain the language. Ancient kings regularly claimed that enemies had been utterly destroyed forever, even when those enemies plainly still existed. Hyperbole belonged to the way victory stories were told. That does not mean nobody died or that the violence becomes easy, but it does mean “utter destruction” does not automatically mean every living thing was killed.
The commander of the Lord’s army brings the deepest challenge when Joshua asks, “Are you for us or for our enemies?” and receives the answer, “Neither.” God is not recruited to Israel’s side merely because Israel bears his name. Rahab, a Canaanite, chooses the Lord and is saved. Achan, an Israelite, turns from the Lord and faces judgment. The real question is not, “Are the good guys guaranteed victory?” but, “Whose side are you on?”
The ban is therefore about worship more than entitlement, and about God’s opposition to evil wherever it is found. God judges the entrenched idolatry of Canaan, but God also gives time, warnings, and a way out. Later generations of Israel discover that ethnic identity cannot protect a people who imitate Canaan’s idols. The same God who judges Canaan permits Babylon to judge Israel when Israel sacrifices children, embraces false gods, and abandons covenant faithfulness.
The Bible’s trajectory moves from physical warfare toward the spiritual battle named in Ephesians: the struggle is not against flesh and blood. Joshua cannot be used to justify colonization, violence, or genocide today. The hard parts remain hard, but God invites earnest questions rather than shallow categories. The battle of the gods continues, and the call remains clear: choose the Lord’s side.
Key Takeaways
- 1. Victory and grief belong together
The fall of Jericho calls for relief that God can overcome impossible odds, but it also calls for grief over death and destruction. Faith does not glorify violence simply because victory came through it. The hard truth should not be made palatable too quickly, because grief keeps power from becoming triumphalism. [39:25]
- 2. Herem belongs to God alone
The ban marks something as wholly set apart for God, beyond ordinary human ownership or gain. Israel was not permitted to treat conquest as a chance to enrich itself or prove its strength. The category warns every generation against claiming divine authority for personal, national, or religious ambition. [36:07]
- 3. God is not on tribal sides
The commander’s answer, “Neither,” breaks the assumption that God automatically backs those carrying his name. Rahab’s faith and Achan’s rebellion show that allegiance to God matters more than group identity. God stands against evil within his people just as surely as he stands against evil outside them. [48:55]
- 4. The real battle concerns worship
The conflict in Joshua is not finally about Israel defeating Canaan but about the true God confronting false gods. Idolatry forms people into communities where injustice and cruelty can flourish. The question beneath every conflict remains whether a life is being shaped by the Lord or by rival loyalties. [49:53]
- 5. Christians fight a different war
Ephesians refuses to make flesh and blood the enemy. The New Testament names evil spiritual powers as the true opposition and calls God’s people to faithfulness rather than violence. Joshua’s warfare cannot become a permission slip for harming others in God’s name. [55:14]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [29:01] - Growing Beyond Simple Categories
- [33:43] - Jericho’s Victory and Violence
- [35:20] - Understanding the Ban
- [36:50] - Deuteronomy’s Command of Herem
- [38:03] - Grieving the Destruction
- [40:22] - Why Total Destruction Is Not Simple
- [42:40] - Reading Joshua as Conquest Literature
- [47:41] - Limits on Applying Joshua Today
- [48:15] - Whose Side Are You On?
- [50:24] - Judgment, Idolatry, and Rahab’s Choice
- [53:16] - Choosing God Over Foreign Gods
- [54:32] - From Physical War to Spiritual Battle
- [56:14] - Wrestling Honestly With Jericho
- [57:06] - A Call to Surrender