God's Unfailing Mercy: Hope for All
Summary
Have you ever wondered if God has given up on someone you love—or even on you? The story of God’s mercy is far more surprising, sovereign, and purposeful than we often imagine. Paul, after celebrating the unstoppable love of God in Romans 8, immediately turns to deep anguish over his own people, Israel. He’s wrestling with the apparent failure of God’s promises to Israel, asking if God’s mercy has run out for them. Yet, the narrative of Romans 9 reveals that God’s mercy is not about exclusion, but about creating new opportunities for redemption, even in the midst of failure.
God’s calling of Israel was never about ethnic privilege, but about vocation—a calling to bless all nations. Even when Israel failed, God preserved a remnant and ultimately brought forth Jesus, the Messiah, through them. The story of the two brothers, Jacob and Esau, and the stubborn Pharaoh, shows that God’s choices are not arbitrary, but serve His redemptive plan. Election is about being chosen for a mission, not for boasting. God’s mercy is not limited by human effort or failure; He can reshape even the most marred clay for His glory.
The imagery of the potter and the clay reminds us that as long as we remain soft and responsive, God can continually reshape us, no matter how broken or marred we feel. Hardening, like Pharaoh’s, comes when we resist God’s mercy, but even then, God’s purposes move forward. The scattered tribes of Israel, once “not my people,” are being restored as God calls both Jews and Gentiles into one new people—vessels of mercy from every nation.
This is not just a story about ancient Israel, but about us. Where are we resisting God’s shaping? Are we willing to be remade, to trust His timing, and to believe that no one is too far gone for His mercy? God’s sovereign, surprising, and purposeful mercy invites us to hope for those we’ve written off, to trust that He is still at work, and to become vessels of mercy ourselves. The cross is not God’s plan B—it is the ultimate display of His mercy, calling us to soften our hearts and share that mercy with others.
Key Takeaways
- God’s Mercy Is Always Greater Than Human Failure
No one is beyond the reach of God’s mercy—not even those we’ve written off as “too far gone.” Paul’s anguish for his people reflects God’s own heart, longing for restoration rather than rejection. Even when we see only failure, God is still at work, creating new opportunities for redemption and hope. [03:54]
- Election Is About Mission, Not Privilege
Being chosen by God is not a reason for pride, but a call to serve. Israel was chosen to bless the nations, and now, through Christ, all who respond to God’s call—regardless of background—are invited into this mission. Our identity as God’s people is rooted in His purpose, not our performance or heritage. [18:48]
- God Reshapes Marred Lives for His Glory
The potter and clay image shows that God is patient and persistent, working with our failures and rebellion to form us into vessels of mercy. As long as we remain soft and responsive, He can remake us, no matter how broken we feel. Hardening comes when we resist, but God’s desire is always to restore and repurpose us for His glory. [26:30]
- Mercy Can Soften or Harden Hearts—The Choice Is Ours
God’s mercy is meant to lead us to repentance, but it can also harden us if we persist in resistance, like Pharaoh. The same mercy that saves can become a stumbling block if we refuse to be shaped by it. The invitation is to remain moldable, to let God’s kindness soften our hearts rather than harden them. [46:02]
- Hope for the “Not My People”
God’s plan has always included bringing outsiders in—calling “not my people” His people, and the unloved His beloved. The restoration of Israel is happening as God gathers people from every nation, making us all vessels of mercy. This hope challenges us to pray for those we’ve given up on and to trust that God’s mercy is still reaching, still restoring, and still calling us to join His mission. [32:53]
Youtube Chapters
[00:00] - Welcome
[03:54] - God’s Mercy: Sovereign, Surprising, Purposeful
[07:08] - The Lost Tribes and God’s Covenant
[09:26] - Israel’s Calling and the Story of Election
[10:07] - The Privilege and Responsibility of God’s People
[11:54] - Who Truly Belongs to God’s Family?
[15:17] - Jews and Gentiles at the Same Table
[16:39] - God’s Surprising Choice: The Story of Isaac
[18:01] - Jacob and Esau: Election and Mission
[22:33] - Pharaoh’s Hardening and God’s Power
[24:14] - Mercy as the Occasion for Hardening
[26:30] - The Potter and the Clay: God’s Right to Shape
[31:03] - Restoration: Not My People Become My People
[34:59] - Play-Doh Parable: Staying Moldable
[38:43] - Becoming Vessels of Mercy
[42:48] - Trusting God’s Timing and Mercy
[46:02] - Responding to Mercy: Soften or Harden
[46:37] - Prayer and Communion
Study Guide
Bible Study Discussion Guide: God’s Surprising, Sovereign, and Purposeful Mercy (Romans 9)
---
### Bible Reading
- Romans 9:1-29
- Jeremiah 18:1-6 (The potter and the clay)
- Hosea 2:23; Hosea 1:10 (“Not my people” will be called “my people”)
---
### Observation Questions
1. In Romans 9, what is Paul’s emotional state as he thinks about his fellow Israelites, and what does he say he would be willing to give up for them? ([03:54])
2. According to the sermon, what was the original purpose of God choosing Israel? Was it about privilege or something else? ([10:07])
3. What does the image of the potter and the clay in Jeremiah 18 teach us about God’s relationship to His people? ([26:30])
4. In Hosea, what does God promise to those who were once called “not my people”? ([32:53])
---
### Interpretation Questions
1. Why does Paul use the stories of Jacob and Esau, and Pharaoh, in Romans 9? What point is he making about God’s choices and mercy? ([18:48])
2. The sermon says that “election is about mission, not privilege.” What does it mean for us to be chosen by God for a purpose rather than for status? ([18:48])
3. How does the potter and clay image challenge the way we think about our failures and God’s ability to use us? ([34:59])
4. What does it mean that God’s mercy can either soften or harden hearts, depending on our response? ([24:14])
---
### Application Questions
1. Paul expresses deep anguish for people he loves who seem far from God. Is there someone in your life you’ve given up on spiritually? What would it look like to pray for them again, trusting God’s mercy? ([03:54])
2. The sermon challenges us to see being “chosen” as a call to serve, not to boast. In what areas of your life do you tend to see your faith as a privilege rather than a mission? How could you shift your mindset this week? ([18:48])
3. The potter and clay image is about staying soft and moldable. Where in your life do you sense God trying to reshape you? Are there areas where you’re resisting? What would it look like to surrender those to Him? ([34:59])
4. The sermon says that even marred or broken clay can be reshaped for God’s glory. Can you share a time when God used a failure or weakness in your life for something good? ([36:36])
5. God’s mercy can either soften or harden us. Are there ways you’ve become hardened—maybe through disappointment, pride, or hurt? What would it look like to let God’s kindness soften your heart again? ([24:14])
6. The story of “not my people” becoming “my people” is about God bringing outsiders in. Is there someone in your life or community you’ve written off as “too far gone”? How could you reach out to them or pray for them this week? ([32:53])
7. The cross is described as the ultimate display of God’s mercy. How does remembering the cross help you trust God’s timing and purpose, especially when you don’t see immediate results? ([45:24])
---
Closing Prayer Suggestion:
Ask God to soften your heart, to help you trust His mercy for yourself and others, and to make you a vessel of mercy in your relationships and community.
Devotional
Day 1: Mercy Beyond Failure and Despair
God’s mercy reaches deeper than human shortcomings and brokenness. Even when people seem lost or beyond hope, God’s heart longs for restoration, not rejection. The anguish over apparent failure is not a sign that God has given up, but a reflection of His persistent love that continually creates new paths for redemption. When you feel overwhelmed by failure—your own or others’—remember that God’s mercy is unstoppable and sovereign, working behind the scenes to bring hope and healing. Trust that no one is too far gone for God’s redeeming grace to reach them. [03:54]
“Remember not the former things, nor consider the things of old. Behold, I am doing a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it? I will make a way in the wilderness and rivers in the desert.”
— Isaiah 43:18-19 (ESV)
Reflection: Who in your life feels “too far gone” or beyond hope? How can you begin to pray for God’s mercy to break through in their situation today?
Day 2: Chosen to Serve, Not to Boast
Being chosen by God is not about privilege or status but about a mission to bless and serve others. Israel’s calling was never an exclusive ethnic honor but a vocation to bring God’s blessing to all nations. Today, through Christ, this mission extends to all who respond to God’s call, regardless of background. Your identity as God’s beloved is rooted in purpose, not performance or heritage. Embracing this mission means setting aside pride and stepping into a life of humble service, joining God’s work of redemption in the world. [18:48]
“For many are called, but few are chosen.”
— Matthew 22:14 (ESV)
Reflection: In what ways might you be tempted to view your faith or calling as a privilege rather than a responsibility? How can you actively live out your mission to bless others this week?
Day 3: Soft Clay in the Potter’s Hands
God’s work in our lives is like a potter shaping clay—patient, persistent, and purposeful. No matter how marred or broken you feel, God desires to reshape you into a vessel of mercy and glory. This process requires remaining soft and responsive to His touch. Resistance hardens the heart, but openness invites transformation. Even when you stumble or rebel, God’s hands are ready to mold you anew. The invitation is to trust His timing and remain pliable, knowing that your brokenness is not the end but the beginning of God’s creative work. [26:30]
“But the pot he was shaping from the clay was marred in his hands; so the potter formed it into another pot, shaping it as seemed best to him.”
— Jeremiah 18:4 (ESV)
Reflection: What areas of your heart feel hardened or resistant to God’s shaping? What practical step can you take today to soften and surrender those areas to Him?
Day 4: Mercy’s Invitation: Harden or Soften
God’s mercy is a powerful invitation that can either soften hearts toward repentance or harden them through persistent resistance. Like Pharaoh, who resisted God’s mercy and hardened his heart, we too face a choice in how we respond. Mercy is not automatic; it requires a willing heart to receive and be transformed. The same kindness that saves can become a stumbling block if rejected. The daily challenge is to choose softness—to allow God’s kindness to melt defenses and open us to His renewing work rather than closing off in stubbornness. [46:02]
“The Lord said to Moses, ‘When you go to return to Egypt, see that you do before Pharaoh all the miracles that I have put in your power. But I will harden his heart, and though I multiply my signs and wonders in the land of Egypt,’”
— Exodus 7:3-4 (ESV)
Reflection: Reflect on a recent moment when you felt resistant to God’s mercy or correction. How can you invite God’s kindness to soften your heart instead of hardening it?
Day 5: Restoring the “Not My People”
God’s redemptive plan includes bringing outsiders in—transforming those once called “not my people” into His beloved family. The restoration of Israel is a powerful symbol of God’s inclusive mercy, now extended to all nations. This hope challenges believers to pray for those they have given up on and to trust that God is actively gathering a diverse people for His glory. You are called to be a vessel of mercy, joining God’s mission to restore and unite, reflecting His heart for reconciliation and belonging. [32:53]
“And I will say to the north, Give up, and to the south, Do not withhold; bring my sons from afar and my daughters from the end of the earth.”
— Isaiah 43:6 (ESV)
Reflection: Who have you written off as “not my people” in your community or relationships? What is one way you can begin to embody God’s mercy toward them this week?
Quotes
But, let's see, but what if God, willing to demonstrate his wrath and make known his power, has endured with much patience the objects of wrath prepared for destruction? You know, and so, so obviously you get a tear or something like that and the patient reworking of the king, of the potter, to say, okay, we're going to actually work this, we're going to work this, work this. Because it's not hardened yet, it can be changed. And what if willing to make known the wealth of his glory and the objects of his mercy that he's prepared beforehand for glory, right? He's like, okay, this one's got to be better than that. I'm going to make it, I'm going to make this even better. It doesn't have to look like an ashtray, right? He can, well, maybe a little bit. Just put that little thing. Maybe a little bit. Okay, so it can still be, he's just refining with great patience these vessels of mercy, instruments for his mission. How many of you would love to be a vessel of mercy? [00:38:01] (60 seconds)
But he's going to insist that God hasn't failed and that there is purpose and there is hope. There is mercy. There's a mystery of it, but there is mercy. God's not in the mode of excluding people. He's actually, in mercy, he's creating new opportunities. Even in failure, we'll see that he wants to advance the mission. Your own failure, my failure. He wants to advance this mission. Because he's, just because he's called a people, Israel, and they had a real specific job. Called, there's a vocation, right? They've been called into, to a job. And they've, for the most part, failed. Now, I was reminded the other day by a friend, Matt, who's a rabbi in a messianic. [00:03:54] (51 seconds)
God's mercy means that he keeps working with the clay as long as it's not hardened in the kiln. So I think a hardening is. Even now, I assume he's called not only from the Jews, but also from the Gentiles. Jews and Gentiles together forming one new united people. The remaking of the clay is about getting to people all that are going to respond to this mercy. [00:39:13] (28 seconds)
But God is patient, not wanting anyone to perish at all, should come to repentance. And he also says in Hosea, I will call those who are not my people, my people. So I'm going after the not my people, people, and I'm going to call them my people, people. I will call her who is unloved, my beloved. And Hosea, remember he was talking to the ten northern tribes. This is what Paul's thinking, like, what about? Has God failed in his promises to all the people? The ten tribes, the twelve tribes? In the very place it was said to them, you are not my people. They will be called sons of the living God. [00:32:37] (38 seconds)
So for the scripture says to Pharaoh, you guys remember Pharaoh, some of you watch Prince of Egypt, some of those, you know, some of the stuff, right? The scripture says to Pharaoh, for this purpose I've raised you up, that I may demonstrate my power in you, that my name may be proclaimed in all the earth. So then, God has mercy on whom he chooses to have mercy, hardens whom he chooses to harden. And you'll say to me, and Paul's really into all these questions. If you look up the questions, there's just tons of questions. He expects feedback from you guys. He expects like, well, wait a minute. Well, what about this? And hey, wait a minute. What about this? You'll say to me then, well, why does he still find fault? Who has ever resisted his will? [00:22:43] (42 seconds)
The potter can reshape it any time he wants, right? Just like, I get to choose. I'm like, no, I think I'm going to actually switch it up. We're going to do this. And the clay is like, you can't do that. I was like, well, I kind of can, right? This is the thing he wants to do. God's plan, I mean, he, I don't know if you've felt this, and it's hard because we have all these conversations about sovereignty and what does that mean? And do I have any agency? Do I have whatever? But he seems to, God seems to go with my mistakes and says, okay, we're going to work with that now. And we're going to work with that now. We're going to work with that. And you're rebellion. Okay, are you going to return to me? Are you going to repent and return to me? Yeah, okay, so let's just go. He seems to be flexible and responsive to us. [00:37:15] (47 seconds)
And remember the stories that Paul would tell and he'd say, don't harden your heart. In Hebrews, it's like there's a day coming. As long as it's still called today, like soften your heart and respond. Don't harden your hearts like the people that did this at this one place and don't harden your hearts. Only God knows who's ready just to get busted up and thrown in the landfill. So trust that he knows what he's doing. If you embrace this, you actually begin to be a vessel of hope and life. And as tough as it is, the cross wasn't plan B. This is actually God's mercy right here on us. [00:45:12] (40 seconds)
the absolute longest reading of Romans 9 1 -29 but I think God's mercy is sovereign he knows how to work with people who even will rebel against him he knows how to make this he knows how to make these things work he knows what he's up to it's sovereign it's choosing Jacob not Esau not arbitrarily but to serve the redemptive plan he calls surprisingly not my people he says now you're going to be called my people even you you're outsiders called into his family and then purposeful he's like no you're now part of the whole thing you're part of the calling to tell the nations that as an all call you can come back to Christ you can come back to the God who made you so I want to take I want to go through just a few of the other verses here that it's going to start with the you who find fault in me right here at the bottom of that and I just I brought my Play -Doh with me because we need to do this one we just need to do this right so [00:33:42] (75 seconds)
Chatbot
-
I'm an AI bot trained specifically on the sermon from Apr 28, 2025. Do you have any questions about it?