Exodus 11 and 12 forces the hardest question in the Old Testament: does God kill? The tenth plague leaves death throughout Egypt, from Pharaoh’s house to the prisoner’s cell and even among the livestock. The text gives no easy way around the horror that children, including babies, die in every Egyptian household.
God’s judgment comes after Pharaoh ordered the drowning of Hebrew babies in the Nile and refused every command to let the slaves go. The Exodus story reverses the world Pharaoh made: the first become last, and the last become first. Yet the killing of Egypt’s firstborn still violates a deep sense that babies should not suffer for the sins of their parents or rulers.
The Passover blood on the doorposts marks Israel’s deliverance, while Egypt’s loud cry answers the earlier cry of Hebrew slaves groaning under oppression. God’s liberation also sends Israel out with silver and gold, and Egypt’s giving becomes a model for Jubilee law. The Exodus story therefore supplies a biblical basis for not sending former slaves away empty handed, including the serious claim for reparations after generations of American slavery.
The Bible preserves these difficult pieces side by side rather than homogenizing them. The text contains liberation, covenant, violence, glory, honor, memory, legend, and conflicting voices from Israel’s tradition. The claim that the Old Testament has a wrathful God while the New Testament has a loving God must be abandoned, because both testaments contain violence and mercy, including the terrible violence of Revelation.
The tension between honor and glory helps name what is going on. Honor hears the cry of enslaved people and creates a covenant community where people are protected. Glory seeks to prove whose god is stronger, the God of the Hebrews or Pharaoh, ruler of the greatest empire on earth. The desire for divine glory looks more like the ancient culture of honor than the deepest character of God.
The Exodus story has a historical kernel, but archaeology gives little support for a massive slave population, a vast exodus, or a military conquest of the land. The enduring truth does not depend on literal historical fact. God’s preferential option for the poor, God’s covenant community, Isaiah’s vision of peace, and Jesus’ kingdom of God give the story its lasting meaning.
The killing of the firstborn becomes dangerous when literalized into a holy war story. God’s nonviolence seeks reconciliation, peace, and justice among all peoples. The church must trust people enough to tell the truth about Scripture, because a literalism that kills cannot be the final word.
##
Key Takeaways
- 1. God hears the oppressed cry [19:59] God begins the Exodus story by hearing people whose suffering has been ignored by the powerful. The cry of the enslaved is not background noise in Scripture but a summons that exposes Pharaoh’s whole social order. God’s justice is rooted first in liberation and the formation of a people who can live differently. [19:59]
- 2. Liberation includes material repair [17:38] The Exodus story does not picture freedom as merely being released from bondage with nothing in hand. Egypt’s silver and gold become a pattern behind Jubilee law, where a freed slave must be sent out with resources for a real future. Justice requires more than ending oppression; it must reckon with what oppression has taken. [17:38]
- 3. Scripture preserves difficult voices [18:42] The Bible does not flatten its traditions into a neat system that removes every contradiction. Its preserved stories carry the faith, fear, hope, violence, and moral struggle of generations who kept wrestling with God. Faithfulness includes refusing easy answers when the text itself will not permit them. [18:42]
- 4. Glory can distort justice [24:24] The drive to prove power can stand alongside the work of liberation and yet pull it in a dangerous direction. Honor protects the vulnerable and keeps covenant, while glory seeks victory over rivals. God’s name cannot be used to baptize domination, conquest, or the humiliation of enemies. [24:24]
- 5. Literalism can become deadly [32:28] The killing of the firstborn becomes a weapon when it is treated as a timeless blueprint for God’s enemies. White Christian nationalism and holy war both depend on claiming that God is on one side against another. Jesus’ kingdom points instead toward a reconciled community where peace and justice belong together.
## [32:28]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [11:50] - The Hard Question: Does God Kill?
- [13:16] - The Final Plague and Passover
- [16:33] - Pharaoh Humbled and Israel Released
- [17:19] - Jubilee Law and Reparations
- [18:42] - The Bible’s Conflicting Voices
- [19:22] - Justice, Pharaoh, and Egypt’s Children
- [22:27] - Rejecting the Old Testament God Myth
- [24:24] - Honor, Glory, and Imperial Power
- [28:09] - History, Legend, and Exodus
- [31:30] - God’s Preferential Option for the Poor
- [32:28] - Nonviolence and the Kingdom of God
- [34:58] - Telling the Truth About Scripture