Faithful Conflict: Restoring Relationships with Grace

The Easter ham story shows how little things can sully human relationships. Grandma’s habit of cutting the ham had nothing to do with the proper way to make Easter dinner. It came from a roasting pan that was too small. Yet that old habit became the thing two sisters could argue about again and again, because conflict is often not just one thing. It is a confluence of things, until one small thing breaks the camel’s back.

Jesus gives the church a pattern not for avoiding every argument, but for living faithfully when conflict happens. The church is not a utopian place where everybody always gets along. Jesus seems to assume that people will offend each other, hurt each other, and sometimes sin against each other. The question is not whether conflict will come. The question is what faithful people do when it does.

Jesus begins with the hardest step: go directly to the person. Direct conversation requires vulnerability. The offended person must risk saying, “You hurt me,” and the offending person must risk hearing, “I was wrong.” The goal is not to gather a campaign against somebody, win an argument, or prove who is right. The goal is to restore a relationship.

Jesus widens the circle only when necessary. Two or three others can bring wisdom, accountability, and a wider circle of relationship, but Jesus does not begin by bringing a private hurt before everybody. The pattern starts small, directly, and humbly, because chances are there are two parties at fault, not just one.

Matthew frames conflict between the lost sheep and Peter’s question about forgiveness. The good shepherd goes looking for the one sheep. Jesus calls for forgiveness not seven times, but seventy-seven times. Grace and mercy therefore frame hard conversations, even while truth and accountability still matter. The central question becomes not, “Who wins?” but, “How might this relationship be healed?”

Jesus promises to be present where two or three gather in his name, not only when worship is roaring and everything is beautiful. Christ is present in the mud and muck of life, when a community is unraveling and people are struggling with each other. The church stands not on facades of perfection, but on grace. Jesus therefore calls hurting people to go, talk, listen, and keep mercy and grace in the room.

##

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. Go directly, humbly, and truthfully. Jesus makes direct conversation the first step because relationships cannot be restored through side conversations and quiet resentment. Vulnerability is difficult because both hurt and fault may be present on more than one side. Humility leaves room for repentance, listening, and a truth that is bigger than personal vindication. [19:13]
• 2. Widen the circle only when needed. Jesus does not turn every conflict into a public matter. The circle grows from one person to two or three only when restoration requires more wisdom and accountability. Restraint protects both the relationship and the community from turning pain into a campaign. [20:33]
• 3. Grace frames hard conversations. Matthew places conflict between the lost sheep and seventy-seven-fold forgiveness. Mercy does not make truth unimportant, and accountability does not cancel grace. Grace changes the aim of conflict from naming a loser to seeking healing for someone who has wandered or been wounded. [21:51]
• 4. Christ meets people in the muck. Jesus promises his presence not only in full sanctuaries and happy gatherings, but in the difficult work of reconciliation. Conflict can expose the shaky facades of perfection, yet Christ remains present there. His presence gives the church reason to stay in the hard conversation rather than walk away.
  
  ## [22:39]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [15:57] - The Easter Ham Argument
• [18:11] - Conflict Happens in Every Community
• [19:13] - Go Directly to the Person
• [20:33] - Bringing Two or Three Others
• [20:53] - Lost Sheep, Conflict, and Forgiveness
• [22:11] - Grace and Mercy in the Room
• [22:39] - Christ Is Present in the Muck
• [23:30] - The Church Is Built on Grace
• [24:04] - Restoring Grace Upon Grace

Bible Reading

Matthew 18:15–20

Verse 15: “If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained your brother.” [19:13]

Verse 16: “But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses.” [20:33]

Verse 17: “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.”

Verse 18: “Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.”

Verse 19: “Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven.”

Verse 20: “For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them.” [22:39]

Observation questions

1. What is the first action Jesus tells a person to take when someone sins against them, and what does Jesus say is gained if that person listens? [19:13]
2. How does the circle of people involved in a conflict grow in Matthew 18:15–17? What does this gradual pattern seem to protect?
3. In the Easter ham story, what was the real reason Grandma cut the ham, and why had it become such a repeated argument between the sisters? [16:42]
4. What words describe the goal of a hard conversation: winning, gathering supporters, proving someone wrong, or restoring a relationship? [20:02]

Interpretation questions

1. Jesus tells the offended person to go privately first. Why might a direct conversation be more difficult than talking about the situation with friends or other church members? What kinds of harm can side conversations create? [19:53]
2. The instruction to bring one or two others comes only after a private conversation has not worked. What might wise and trustworthy helpers contribute to a difficult conversation, and how could they help keep restoration possible? [20:36]
3. Matthew places this teaching about conflict between the lost sheep and Jesus’ command to forgive seventy-seven times. How do seeking the lost and offering abundant forgiveness shape the way Christians should approach someone who has caused hurt? [21:05]
4. Jesus promises to be present when two or three gather in his name. How does that promise change the meaning of this verse when it is read in the middle of conflict and reconciliation? [22:48]

Application questions

1. Is there a conflict in which you have been carrying hurt quietly, talking around the person, or hoping the problem will simply disappear? What might it look like to take one humble first step toward a direct conversation? [23:43]
2. When you feel hurt, which is harder for you: saying, “You hurt me,” or admitting, “I may have been wrong”? What would help you enter a conversation with more honesty and humility? [19:43]
3. Small disagreements can carry deeper frustrations, grief, old wounds, or unmet expectations. What “Easter ham” issues—small things that have come to represent something bigger—can show up in families, friendships, or churches? [17:51]
4. Think about a recent disagreement. Did you approach it mainly with the question, “Who is right?” What could change if the question became, “How might this relationship be healed?” [22:17]
5. When would it be appropriate to invite one or two mature, trustworthy people into a conflict? What qualities should those people have so they bring wisdom and accountability rather than fuel gossip or take sides? [20:43]
6. Where do you need to keep both truth and grace in the room right now? How can you speak truthfully without treating the other person as an enemy or a problem to be defeated? [22:08]
7. Jesus is present not only when relationships are easy, but also in the mud and muck of hard conversations. How might trusting Christ’s presence give you courage to listen, stay engaged, or seek forgiveness this week? [23:06]