Sergei Bulgakov’s life is a powerful testimony to the way faith can radically transform not only our personal convictions but also our understanding of society and economics. Once a Marxist economist, Bulgakov’s journey to Orthodox Christianity did not erase his concern for poverty and injustice; instead, it deepened it. He came to see that economics is not a neutral or purely technical field, but one that is deeply intertwined with theology, the church, and the calling of every human being. Bulgakov argued that capitalism is not just an economic system, but a false anthropology—a way of understanding humanity that distorts the soul by reducing people to mere instruments of profit. This, he believed, is not just a bad idea, but a spiritual error, a heresy.
Bulgakov’s critique goes beyond the surface of economic policy and dives into the spiritual consequences of a system that makes poverty a structural necessity. He saw that capitalism, by its very nature, depends on inequality and accumulation, and thus cannot simply be reformed with better policies or more charity. Instead, it must be confronted theologically, because it shapes our hearts and our communities in ways that are fundamentally at odds with the gospel. For Bulgakov, to tolerate systemic poverty is to deny the incarnation of Christ, because it denies the full dignity and spiritual potential of every human being.
The battle against poverty, then, is not just a matter of social justice or political activism. It is a spiritual struggle, a fight for the rights of the human spirit. To follow Christ is to refuse to accept any system that crushes the soul or makes suffering a necessity. Our faith calls us to see every person as bearing the image of God, and to resist any worldview that would treat them as less. In this light, economic justice is not a peripheral concern, but a central part of what it means to live out the gospel in the world.
Key Takeaways
- 1. The way we structure our economies is not spiritually neutral; it forms our souls and communities. When profit becomes the highest good, people are inevitably reduced to means rather than ends, and this distorts our understanding of what it means to be human in God’s image. We must be vigilant about the spiritual formation that economic systems produce in us. [01:22]
- 2. Capitalism, according to Bulgakov, is not just a set of practices but a worldview that shapes our desires, values, and relationships. It subtly teaches us to serve mammon rather than God, making the pursuit of wealth a rival to the love of neighbor and the worship of Christ. Recognizing this spiritual danger is the first step toward faithful resistance. [01:22]
- 3. Poverty, in this framework, is not merely an unfortunate byproduct of economic life, but a structural necessity for the system’s functioning. This means that addressing poverty is not just about charity or reform, but about challenging the very foundations of how we organize our common life. The gospel calls us to imagine and work for a different kind of community. [02:57]
- 4. To tolerate systemic poverty is, in Bulgakov’s view, to deny the incarnation—the truth that Christ took on human flesh and dignified every person. When we accept systems that degrade or exclude, we are implicitly denying the full humanity and spiritual potential of our neighbors. Our faith demands that we see and respond to the suffering of others as a matter of spiritual urgency. [02:57]
- 5. The battle against poverty is ultimately a spiritual battle for the rights of the human spirit. It is not enough to address symptoms; we must confront the underlying spiritual and moral distortions that allow poverty to persist. This requires courage, imagination, and a willingness to let the gospel challenge our deepest assumptions about wealth, value, and community. [02:57]
** [02:57]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [00:15] - Introducing Sergei Bulgakov
- [00:40] - Bulgakov’s Journey from Marxism to Orthodoxy
- [01:05] - Economic Concerns Reframed Theologically
- [01:22] - Capitalism as False Anthropology
- [01:45] - The Spiritual Distortion of Capitalism
- [02:05] - Capitalism’s Structural Dependence on Inequality
- [02:20] - Theological Confrontation, Not Mere Reform
- [02:35] - Poverty as Degrading and Dehumanizing
- [02:57] - The Battle Against Poverty as Spiritual Struggle
- [03:10] - Denying the Incarnation Through Systemic Poverty
