Delicious Ambiguity (05-17-26)

Devotional

Day 1: Mystic, Scientist, and Quarks

A religious man asks about God. The mystic meditates, expands her heart, and declares the world more wondrous than she could imagine. The scientist calculates cosmic vastness and quantum minutiae, arriving at the same awe. Both point beyond themselves to a mystery that holds them. [22:43]

The story rejects easy answers. Jesus often answered questions with deeper questions, redirecting focus from abstract debates to lived wonder. The disciples didn’t receive a theology lecture on the stormy sea—they encountered a miracle that reordered their fear.

When faced with unanswerable questions, do you default to debate or awe? Name one situation this week where you’ll choose wonder over certainty. What concrete action could help you embrace mystery instead of demanding resolution?

“When I look at your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have set in place—what is man that you are mindful of him?”
(Psalm 8:3-4, ESV)

Prayer: Thank God for three specific wonders in creation that humble you.
Challenge: Spend 10 minutes observing nature today—a plant, insect, or cloud—and jot down three questions it sparks.

Day 2: Imagination Before Solutions

Children designed a church building with water parks and cotton candy. Adults often dismiss such visions as impractical. Yet Jesus said the kingdom belongs to those who become like children—unafraid to dream beyond perceived limits. [01:00:31]

God’s creativity defies human logic. The burning bush didn’t fit Moses’ expectations. Jonah’s rescue from fish guts reshaped his mission. When we fixate on “how,” we risk missing the “what if” that precedes every miracle.

Identify one problem where you’ve stopped brainstorming solutions. Write three absurd ideas for it, like turning budget deficits into community art projects. Which limiting belief keeps you from voicing wilder possibilities?

“Truly, I say to you, unless you turn and become like children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.”
(Matthew 18:3, ESV)

Prayer: Ask forgiveness for every time you’ve prioritized practicality over holy imagination.
Challenge: Text a friend one “impossible” idea you’ve never dared share.

Day 3: Spaciousness of Uncertainty

Rebecca Solnit reimagines uncertainty not as a threat but as fertile ground. The disciples huddled in fear post-crucifixion until Jesus breathed new purpose into their locked room. What felt like an ending became space for resurrection. [52:04]

God works in the gaps humans rush to fill. Joseph’s prison time forged leadership. Esther’s delay before approaching the king saved her people. Anxiety shrinks possibilities; trust expands them.

Where are you white-knuckling control? List three ways to loosen your grip this week. How might “not knowing” become an invitation rather than a curse?

“Behold, I am doing a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it?”
(Isaiah 43:19, ESV)

Prayer: Confess one situation where you’ve resisted God’s timing. Request patience to wait actively.
Challenge: Write “spaciousness” on your wrist. When anxious, trace the word and breathe deeply.

Day 4: Seeds in the Imagination

John Adams called the American Revolution a battle of ideas before bullets. Jesus planted parables like seeds—small stories that upended empires. The mystic and scientist sowed curiosity, not conclusions, in their questioner. [58:28]

Ideas outlive their creators. David’s psalms still comfort. Lydia’s hospitality birthed a church. Your words and actions plant unseen harvests.

What idea have you dismissed as too small? Share it with someone this week. What legacy of thought do you want to leave in your community?

“Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind.”
(Romans 12:2, ESV)

Prayer: Name one cultural narrative you’ve absorbed. Ask God to replace it with kingdom imagination.
Challenge: Discuss a “fairy tale” problem (yours or the world’s) with a child. Record their solutions.

Day 5: Extinguishing Chalices, Keeping Curiosity

The chalice flame dies, but the congregation carries its light. The Emmaus Road disciples didn’t recognize Jesus until they walked, talked, and broke bread. Curiosity turned their despair into direction. [01:15:31]

Endings birth beginnings. Paul’s persecution birthed missionary journeys. Your present uncertainty holds future purpose. The church exists not to maintain traditions but to midwife new creations.

What ending are you mourning that might hide a beginning? What ritual could help you release control and receive surprise?

“Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding. In all your ways acknowledge him, and he will make straight your paths.”
(Proverbs 3:5-6, ESV)

Prayer: Light a candle. Thank God for one closed door, then blow it out.
Challenge: Ask “What if?” instead of “Why?” in a frustrating situation today.

Sermon Summary

Delicious ambiguity sets the frame with Gilda Radner’s line about poems that do not rhyme and stories without clean arcs, and with an invitation to bring the fullness of heart and be curious. The parable of the mystic and the scientist centers the confession, “I do not know what you mean by the word God,” while knowing the world is more mysterious and that lives are part of something larger; wonder leads first, naming comes later. Real security names the ability to tolerate mystery, complexity, and ambiguity, even to hunger for them, so that the human impulse to control loosens enough for trust and play.

Rebecca Solnit’s image of fairy tales locates hope in the not yet created, where the end is known but the impossible task pulls the heart through the dark woods. That image reframes uncertainty as the stage where possibility gets born, not the trap that shuts people down. A reader’s love of story exposes the ache for closure and the fury at cliffhangers, and that ache mirrors the wider refrain “in these uncertain times” that casts a shadow across daily life; yet the spaciousness of uncertainty opens room to act.

History’s unpredictability, as Howard Zinn testifies, keeps astonishing with crumbling institutions and quick collapses of systems that looked invincible, and such turns often arrive after long unseen labor. Revolution in the mind precedes revolution in the street, as John Adams tells Jefferson, and culture, beliefs, and values mark the most important territory to take, which is the imagination. Once a community enlarges what feels possible and acceptable, the conditions for winning take root.

Brainstorming then becomes a spiritual practice that trains communities for possibility. The children’s blue-sky plans for a building with a water park, roller coaster, and cotton candy stands model the scale of dreaming needed right now. Curiosity, not immediate solutions, becomes the assignment, and shared conversations become the method, with topics as wide as artificial intelligence or a congregational budget or a private ache. Audre Lorde’s charge refuses passivity, warns against false security and despair, and calls each person to find the work to do. Joy in companionship rounds out the charge so that the work of imagining and acting is both communal and playful. May it be so, and may people make it so.

Key Takeaways

1. Real security hungers for mystery [48:00] Real security is not control but capacity. A soul that can sit with not-knowing has room for wisdom, compassion, and play. Hunger for complexity keeps faith alive when neat answers fail. Such appetite turns fear into curiosity. [48:00]
2. Uncertainty opens room for action [52:04] The unknown is not a cul-de-sac, it is a wide field. Spaciousness lets love improvise, test, and learn without the burden of perfect foresight. Faithfulness gets measured by participation, not prediction. Movement begins where maps end. [52:04]
3. Imagination tills the field of change [58:28] Revolution takes root in the mind before it reaches the streets. Culture shifts set the range of what feels possible and then policy follows. Sanctified brainstorming becomes strategy in seed form. Guard the imagination, because it is contested ground. [58:28]
4. Wonder precedes the urge to name [24:46] Encounter should come before category. Let the taste of largeness shape the tongue before it speaks its labels. Humility keeps language from shrinking the holy to a slogan. Naming after wonder makes room for mystery and for each other. [24:46]
5. Dreaming together trains courage [01:00:16] Low-stakes play builds high-stakes resilience. Communities that practice saying preposterous ideas out loud become communities that risk mercy and justice in public. Hospitality to wild thoughts often births the most practical paths. Shared dreaming makes bold action feel normal. [60:16]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[11:28] - Community gathered and roles
[13:34] - How to participate today
[14:14] - Delicious ambiguity named
[22:06] - The Mystic and the Scientist
[24:46] - Wonder before naming God
[47:31] - Confession and craving certainty
[48:33] - Fairy tales and the work of hope
[52:04] - The spaciousness of uncertainty
[52:47] - History’s unpredictability and surprise
[58:28] - Imagination as contested territory
[59:55] - Kids dream the building big
[61:30] - Congregational brainstorming practice
[66:51] - Audre Lorde’s charge and sending
[75:31] - Extinguish the chalice, keep curiosity

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading
Proverbs 25:2 (ESV)
"It is the glory of God to conceal things, but the glory of kings is to search things out."

Isaiah 55:8-9 (ESV)
"For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, declares the Lord. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts."

Revelation 21:5 (ESV)
"And he who was seated on the throne said, 'Behold, I am making all things new.'"

Observation Questions

The mystic and scientist both respond, "I do not know what you mean by the word God," yet affirm the world’s mystery and interconnectedness. How does this mirror the tension in Proverbs 25:2 between concealment and discovery? [22:25]
Rebecca Solnit compares uncertainty to fairy tales where "the end is known but the impossible task pulls the heart through the dark woods." What parallels does this have to Isaiah 55:8-9’s emphasis on God’s higher ways? [48:33]
The children’s brainstorming session included wild ideas like water parks and cotton candy stands. How does Revelation 21:5’s vision of renewal encourage such imaginative thinking? [59:55]

Interpretation Questions

The sermon claims "uncertainty opens room for action" rather than being a trap. How does Isaiah 55:8-9 challenge the human impulse to demand clarity before acting?
Howard Zinn notes history’s unpredictability, citing collapses of seemingly invincible systems. How might Revelation 21:5 reframe such disruptions as part of a larger renewal? [52:47]
The mystic and scientist both prioritize wonder over labels. Why might Proverbs 25:2 suggest that mystery is not a problem to solve but a gift to explore?

Application Questions

When has clinging to certainty (in relationships, faith, or societal issues) limited your ability to act? What small step could you take to embrace "spaciousness" instead? [52:04]
The children’s brainstorming modeled "low-stakes play" to build courage. What playful, "preposterous" idea have you dismissed lately? How could sharing it with others strengthen communal imagination? [01:00:16]
Audre Lorde warns against passivity and despair. What personal or collective "impossible task" (like the fairy tale’s challenge) could you commit to pursuing, even without knowing the path? [01:06:51]
The sermon urges "naming after wonder" to avoid shrinking the holy. How might labeling experiences or people too quickly hinder your ability to see mystery in daily life?
Reflect on a time when an unpredictable event (like the Berlin Wall falling) reshaped your worldview. How can that memory fuel hope in current uncertainties? [54:06]
Brainstorming is framed as a spiritual practice. What issue in your life or community needs imaginative "tilling" rather than immediate solutions? Who could you invite to dream with you? [01:01:30]

Sermon Clips

35s

“That's the type of imagination we need right now. That expansive, no holding back, outside the box thinking. It is in that place of delicious ambiguity that embraces the unknown and plays with it instead of fearing it. We don't need to get caught up in solutions or names or outcomes. Right now, we need to dream, to imagine, to tap into what is larger than us, and share our ideas no matter how preposterous they are.”

53s

“And as our reading suggested, we have turned into a society that seeks security in the certainty of things, when in actuality we live in a world that is constantly changing and unpredictable. I love the way Rebecca Solnit rephrases uncertainty. She proclaims, in the spaciousness of uncertainty, there is room to act. In the spaciousness of uncertainty, there is room to act. When we embrace uncertainty with this lens, there is so much hope and possibility for us to embrace. And it is proven again and again throughout history that in many times of uncertainty, awesome and wonderful things have happened.”

46s

“I think the one session that sticks out in my mind the most, which truly embraced the sense of possibility, was when I served a congregation up in Washington State, and we were in the process of thinking about what we would want in a new building. We wanted to make sure we included all ages, and so we had a brainstorming with our children and youth. By the end of that brainstorming session, our building would have a water park, a roller coaster, a games room, an ice cream parlor, cotton candy stands, and so much more. They really dreamed.”

23s

“So what would happen if instead of a sense of foreboding, when we say the phrase in these uncertain times, we feel a sense of curiosity, a sense of possibility, a sense of spaciousness. What if we leaned into cultivating our imaginations of what could be?”

Ask a question about this sermon

UUSF Media This sermon · AI assistant

What is the spiritual value of embracing uncertainty?

How can imagination fuel communal change and hope?

Why is brainstorming a spiritual practice of possibility?