Cosmic Mystery #2: Comparison, Disgrace & How God Moves Outside Social Norms

On the surface, the arrival of Jesus seems like it should have been obvious: a warrior to crush enemies, a prophet to speak with fire, a king to seize the scepter. That’s what many expected. The record shows it—Herod felt threatened, Pilate named him “King of the Jews,” and the crowds tried to force him into kingship after the bread multiplied. But God chose another way. The incarnation is a subversive, gentle revelation, moving not through palaces and parade horses but through the lives of two women who carried shame in their communities—Elizabeth and Mary—and a Child whose first throne was a manger.

Elizabeth’s story shows how God sees and restores the ones culture overlooks. In a world that read childlessness as moral failure, God met her with mercy and removed her disgrace. Mary’s story shows God’s nearness to those under suspicion and danger. She runs with haste, likely to the one person who would understand. Their meeting is electric—joy erupts, a baby leaps, and praise flows—because Jesus has come into the room. These are the hinges of history: ordinary women, holy joy, and God’s quiet overthrow of our scorekeeping.

And Jesus himself comes as a genuinely human person—calloused feet, dusty clothes, no white robe to keep clean. No war horse; a donkey. Not the kind of presence we’d spotlight, and that’s the point. If he only looked like us, this would be a show; but he actually became one of us. That matters. It teaches us at least three things. First, what “everyone knows” isn’t always the truth; the kingdom keeps surprising us. Second, if you’re after prestige and leverage, you’ve picked the wrong path; the last really do come first with Jesus. Third, you cannot earn God’s favor—and you don’t need to. Your stacks of achievements don’t move the needle on a God this big, and neither do your failures. He entered our story to love us with the kind of attention that treats each of us as though we were the only one to love.

---

Key Takeaways

• 1. God overturns our expected savior We often project our appetite for control onto God—wanting a warrior, a platform, or a plan that puts us in charge. Jesus resists being made king on our terms and walks away from coercion. He brings a kingdom without the weapons we prefer, and asks whether we will follow him without the props of power. [04:52]
• 2. God centers the shamed and overlooked Elizabeth’s disgrace becomes the place of divine visitation. God doesn’t just comfort her; he restores her standing and makes her life a sign of his favor. Watch where honor is being returned to the dishonored—that’s where Jesus is already at work. [10:18]
• 3. Jesus is fully human, gloriously ordinary The Son of God takes on blistered feet, dusty garments, and the small irritations of our days. Holiness doesn’t float above real life; it inhabits it. That means your ordinary aches and limits are not obstacles to grace but places of meeting. [16:40]
• 4. Power, prestige, and privilege won’t fit The first-last reversal isn’t a slogan; it’s the operating system of the kingdom. Jesus sees the rich young ruler’s sincerity and still dismantles the scaffolding of his identity. Discipleship pries our fingers off the levers of importance so our hands can finally be open. [23:30]
• 5. You can’t earn love you already have God’s love is not calibrated to our performance; his scale is not impressed by our piles of good deeds. The same immensity that levels our comparisons also secures our worth. In Christ, the verdict of beloved is given before we do anything at all. [26:28]

Youtube Chapters

• [00:00] - Welcome
• [02:00] - Our expectations of a messiah
• [04:52] - Warrior, prophet, king—and Herod’s fear
• [06:20] - Crowds try to make Jesus king
• [07:42] - Shame around childlessness in Scripture
• [10:18] - Elizabeth’s disgrace removed by God
• [12:27] - Mary’s peril and hurried journey
• [14:43] - Joyful meeting and Spirit-filled recognition
• [16:40] - The gritty ordinariness of Jesus
• [19:14] - Donkey, not war horse
• [20:42] - Why mystery draws us—and humbles us
• [23:30] - Kingdom reversal: last first, first last
• [24:50] - The rich young ruler reimagined
• [26:28] - You can’t earn what grace gives
• [27:30] - God’s vast love, personally given

Bible Study Guide — The Subversive Arrival of Jesus

Bible reading (ESV)
Luke 1:39–56
39 In those days Mary arose and went with haste into the hill country, to a town in Judah, 40 and she entered the house of Zechariah and greeted Elizabeth. 41 And when Elizabeth heard the greeting of Mary, the baby leaped in her womb. And Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit, 42 and she exclaimed with a loud cry, “Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb! 43 And why is this granted to me that the mother of my Lord should come to me? 44 For behold, when the sound of your greeting came to my ears, the baby in my womb leaped for joy. 45 And blessed is she who believed that there would be a fulfillment of what was spoken to her from the Lord.”
46 And Mary said,
“My soul magnifies the Lord,
47 and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,
48 for he has looked on the humble estate of his servant.
For behold, from now on all generations will call me blessed;
49 for he who is mighty has done great things for me,
and holy is his name.
50 And his mercy is for those who fear him
from generation to generation.
51 He has shown strength with his arm;
he has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts;
52 he has brought down the mighty from their thrones
and exalted those of humble estate;
53 he has filled the hungry with good things,
and the rich he has sent away empty.
54 He has helped his servant Israel,
in remembrance of his mercy,
55 as he spoke to our fathers, to Abraham and to his offspring forever.”
56 And Mary remained with her about three months and returned to her home.

Observation questions

1. Read Luke 1:41–45. What physical and verbal responses take place when Mary greets Elizabeth (who speaks, what happens in the womb, and what titles or blessings are declared)? [14:43]
2. Read Luke 1:46–55. What values and reversals does Mary name about God’s action—who is lifted and who is brought low? Point to at least two specific images she uses. [23:30]
3. The passage shows two women from the edges of their society speaking and recognizing God’s work. What details in Luke 1:39–56 underline their ordinariness or social vulnerability (age, shame, haste, relationship ties)? How do those details shape the moment of recognition? [10:18]
4. The gospel often contrasts popular expectations for a savior with the reality of Jesus’ coming. What concrete examples in Luke 1 or connected story elements show that Jesus’ arrival subverts expectations of power and prestige? [04:52]

Interpretation questions (third-person, objective)

1. How does Elizabeth’s restoration (from shame to honored witness) reshape the group’s understanding of where God’s favor appears in the world? What does this imply about how God evaluates social shame and status? [10:18]
2. How does Mary’s Magnificat (Luke 1:46–55) function as a theological claim about God’s kingdom priorities rather than only a personal song of praise? Which lines point most clearly to a repeated pattern of reversal? [23:30]
3. In what ways does the full humanity of Jesus (the ordinary, dusty, vulnerable life) change the expectations for holiness and ministry among followers? How should that affect what the community looks for in leaders or models? [16:40]
4. How does the crowd’s impulse to make Jesus a political king help explain contemporary tendencies to seek prestige, control, or quick fixes from religious leaders? What caution does that offer the community? [04:52]

Application questions (personal, concrete)

1. The kingdom’s Savior resists being crowned on human terms. Where in your life are you still trying to make God into the kind of savior who secures your plans, status, or control? What is one concrete step you can take this week to loosen that grip? [04:52]
2. God often visits and restores the shamed and overlooked. Who in your life or neighborhood carries shame, scorn, or social invisibility (an elder, a single parent, someone ostracized)? What one tangible thing can you do this month to restore honor or speak blessing into their life? (Visit, write a note, offer help, invite them to dinner.) [10:18]
3. Jesus’ holiness inhabits ordinary, sometimes messy life. What ordinary, imperfect part of your daily routine (work, home, relationships, body) have you treated as unfit for God’s presence? How will you intentionally bring that part of life to God this week (a prayer, a conversation, an act of care)? [16:40]
4. The “first-last” reversal asks disciples to loosen the levers of prestige and privilege. What levers of influence—money, reputation, titles, social circles—do you rely on to feel secure? Name one specific practice you can try in the next 30 days to pry your fingers off that lever (give away time/money, step back from a leadership role, publicly acknowledge a need). [23:30]
5. God’s favor is not earned by lists of achievements or failures. Where do you most try to earn acceptance (work, family, church, performance)? What habit could help you receive being beloved without having to prove yourself (daily confession, a friend’s accountability, memorizing a gospel text)? [26:28]
6. The crowds tried to force Jesus into a role he refused. When have you tried to force spiritual outcomes or quick solutions in your life or the life of the community? What would surrendering to God’s timing look like in that situation? [04:52]

Use this guide to open conversation, listen well, and let Scripture and the Spirit shape practical next steps for each person.