Character Over Charisma: Qualifications for Church Elders

Jul 27, 2026

Devotional

Sermon Summary

Bible Study Guide

Sermon Clips

61s
#ChurchIsPriceless
“``The church is infinitely more valuable than any corporation. It is infinitely more valuable for any ethnic political nation. Why? Because Jesus died to purchase the church for himself. It's paid for by the blood of Jesus. And that is why we have an entire chapter or almost an entire chapter devoted to simply laying out the qualifications that God expects of the leaders within his church. He doesn't simply ask as we read first Timothy three, if a man is gifted or if he's persuasive or he's a certain education level. And say, yep, that guy can be a pastor, that guy can be an overseer is the term we have here in the text. Rather, what does he fixate on? What does God focus on? What does he prioritize and value when it comes to evaluating leaders within the life of the church? Character.”
59s
#CharacterOverCredentials
“Now, why does God care so much about character? After all, we have really emphasized that an important part of ministry is teaching, even has able to teach. Preaching is essential. Why couldn't you have a pastor who's a little dodgy in the character, but awesome is in the communication department? Because Christianity is not merely a matter of right belief, divorced from right behavior. Christianity is not simply about, okay, hearing and thinking the right things and I'll go live however you want. Rather, it is about a life that is completely transformed by the gospel of Jesus Christ in such to such a degree that it changes what we believe and what we think, which in turn changes how we live. So a man whose own life has not been transformed by the gospel ought not be the one publicly proclaiming the gospel.”
79s
#PurchasedByHisBlood
“This goes back to the gospel. The church matters because the church believers in Jesus are purchased by the blood of Jesus Christ. We are redeemed, not with corruptible things, not with silver and gold, but with the precious blood of Jesus. And I wanna just say this as we as we land the plane here. If you are not a believer in Jesus Christ, your sin is so serious. Something that you cannot deal with yourself, it required the death of Jesus in your place. He died on the cross. He was buried. He rose again to satisfy the judgment against us so we could be forgiven, so we could be brought into his family, so we could become part of his flock, so we could have a seat at his table, so we could be welcomed in as forgiven saints. And the church is simply the collection and the gathering of of those who are redeemed by the blood of Jesus. So these requirements matter because the church matters, the church matters because the gospel matters, the gospel matters because Christ matters.”
64s
#GentlenessOverDrama
“How does that happen? Because we live in a culture where the social media algorithm rewards people who are argumentative and quarrelsome. I don't suggest trying this out, but just look at you know, like, don't literally go and post stuff that's argumentative. But if you posted something really controversial, you get way more engagement than you post something that's encouraging. That's how the algorithm works. And so in our online the the culture and even Christian culture rewards the opposite of being gentle. Gentleness will not gain you a huge following online. You're not gonna get like this huge TikTok following by being a gentle kind person. But man, if you're out there being like, man, we're gonna go out there and we're just gonna own the libs and we're gonna use name calling and we're gonna use abusive speech. Man, people will follow you and then they'll be like, look at this guy, this is boldness. What it is is bullying masquerading as boldness. It's cruelty masquerading as courage. It's neither courageous nor bold, but bullying.”
36s
#HomeIsProvingGround
“One of the core callings of a pastor is not only to teach, but also to lead. And if someone is not leading in their home, how will they lead in the household of God? Verse 15 calls the church the household of God. The home is the proving ground of spiritual leadership. So a man does not love his love his wife, why would we expect him to love the bride of Christ? If he does not lead his family, why would we expect him to lead God's household?”
53s
#RejectGreed
“Here's why greed is dangerous. You'll compromise the message to increase the offerings. Yeah. A sure proof way to like increase the offering, start preaching the health, wealth, prosperity gospel, and for whatever reason people show up and like give tons of money, and then people are flying around in corporate jets. If you're driven by greed and a desire for wealth, you'll compromise the message. You will manipulate people. So that's true of the false teachers. That's true of today. And here's a qualification that again is binding on every Christian. God calls all of us to learn to be content and he calls all of us to reject and repent of greed in our lives. Now, greed is not about how much money you have, but it's about how much money you think you need. It is about what you love.”
90s
#CharacterNotCharisma
“Spiritual leadership is not simply about authority and decision making. More often than not, author leadership is about influence more than position. It is about example more than it is about exhortation. So a leader's character will inevitably shape the spiritual health of the church just as a leader's health leader's character will inevitably shape the character of the nation. And I wanna pause on this point because churches, in particular evangelical churches were evangelical. We unashamedly believe the bible and salvation through grace and faith in Jesus. But within American evangelicalism, there is a tendency to prioritize charisma over character. And this guy can fill the have filled the fill the building and he can attract the crowd and he can get people eating out of the palm of his hand. But what's his character like? We have a tendency to prioritize talent over teaching content, visible success over personal holiness and maturity, and then we act horrified and surprised when we see gifted men without proven character collapse into moral failure. The reason this happens is churches promote the wrong men for the wrong reasons. And so God begins here with something else, not with platform, not with personality, not with polish, but with character.”
75s
#SeekServingElders
“So what kind of person do you look for to be an elder? Especially as we consider what we we we looked at last Sunday night that God intends for his church to be led by a plurality of elders, by a team of elders, not just paid professionals. What kind of men should we be looking around for? Ones who are actively pursuing spiritual leadership. You look for men who are already loving the flock. You look for men who are already leading by way of example. You look for men who are already teaching. You don't just say, hey, this guy seems like a nice guy who should have the decision making power, but isn't doing the work. Let's put him into the position. I've seen that done before. Hey, if we give the guy the title, maybe he'll start doing the task. I think that's that's that's that's the opposite. You look for someone who's already doing the job and you give them the badge to go along with the job. You look for people who are actively seeking this. So look for someone who studies scripture, who disciples other people, someone who cares for the saint, someone who leads by example. You see a man who is called to into eldership or into the pastorate does not drift into ministry. He pursues it and he prepares for it.”
Ask a question about this sermon