Christ Our Head: Following God’s Pattern for Church Leadership

Devotional

Day 1: The Shovel God Gave, Not Forks We Choose

A hole dug with forks makes slow progress. God designed specific tools for His church’s health: qualified elders who shepherd according to Scripture. When we ignore this pattern, we settle for inefficient substitutes that delay His work. Just as a child’s fork can’t replace a shovel, human innovations can’t replace God’s blueprint. His design protects the church from division and drift. Trust the tools He provides. [38:21]

“Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood.”
(Acts 20:28, ESV)

Reflection: Where have you been tempted to prioritize convenience over God’s design for community? How might supporting biblical leadership deepen your spiritual growth?

Day 2: One Degree Off, A World Away

A ship one degree off course eventually sails into oblivion. Small deviations from Scripture’s leadership model—like elevating a single pastor or regional hierarchy—compound over time. Early churches faced this drift, creating unbiblical offices that fractured unity. Christ’s pattern of local plural eldership guards against centralized power and pride. Precision matters because eternity hangs in the balance. [40:52]

“Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls, as those who will have to give an account. Let them do this with joy, and not with groaning, for that would be of no advantage to you.”
(Hebrews 13:7-8, ESV)

Reflection: What subtle compromises in your spiritual life might lead to greater drift? How can you realign with Scripture’s clarity today?

Day 3: Plural Shepherds, Not Lone Rangers

Every New Testament church had multiple elders—never a solitary leader. Plurality prevents pride, distributes wisdom, and mirrors the Trinity’s communal nature. Peter, Paul, and James all addressed teams of elders, not individuals. Shared leadership reflects God’s heart for collaborative stewardship. When we resist lone-ranger models, we honor Christ’s safeguard against autocracy. [45:46]

“Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching.”
(1 Timothy 5:17, ESV)

Reflection: How does shared leadership challenge your assumptions about authority? What steps can you take to affirm God’s design for plurality?

Day 4: Christ’s Headship, Our Compass

Before elders, deacons, or apostles, Christ alone reigns as the church’s head. Human structures exist to point believers back to His lordship, not replace it. When Leo I declared himself pope, he usurped Christ’s singular authority. Elders shepherd best when they kneel often—reminding the flock that every knee must bow to the true Shepherd. [50:47]

“And he is the head of the body, the church. He is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in everything he might be preeminent.”
(Colossians 1:18, ESV)

Reflection: Where might you be tempted to elevate human leaders above Christ? How does His preeminence reshape your daily priorities?

Day 5: Shepherds Who Labor for Your Soul

Elders will answer to God for how they stewarded your spiritual growth. Their labor involves midnight calls, tough conversations, and costly prayers. Unlike hired hands, they’re called to lay down their lives—not for control, but for Christ’s glory. Honoring them isn’t about hierarchy; it’s about gratitude for those who dig trenches of grace with God’s shovel. [58:34]

“We ask you, brothers, to respect those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord and admonish you, and to esteem them very highly in love because of their work.”
(1 Thessalonians 5:12-13, ESV)

Reflection: When have you undervalued a leader’s sacrificial care? How will you actively encourage those guarding your soul this week?

Sermon Summary

Christ stands as the one head of the church. Colossians and Ephesians do not leave room for human preference to sit above Him, because Christ has always been and will always be the head. The church loses its posture of servitude whenever human wills, wants, and whims begin designing what Christ has already designed.

The shovel image shows why the biblical pattern matters. God has provided a tool made for the job, and forks may pick at the ground a little, but they are not what He gave. Small departures from the pattern can feel insignificant at first, like a ship moving only one degree off course, but over time that ship ends up miles and miles away from its destination.

The New Testament repeatedly presents a local plurality of elders. Acts, the epistles, James, Peter, and Philippians show elders serving in churches across many places, not merely in one localized situation. The apostolic pattern appoints elders in every church, and Scripture never presents one elder ruling alone over a congregation.

The terms elder, overseer, bishop, shepherd, and pastor describe the same office from different angles. Acts 20 calls the same men elders, says the Spirit made them overseers, and charges them to shepherd the church. The biblical pattern therefore gives Christ as head, qualified men serving as elders in a local congregation, and a flock being shepherded toward Christ.

Human history shows how quickly extra rungs can be added to that simple pattern. Early distinctions between bishops and elders grew into bishops over bishops, regional control, and eventually claims of Roman authority over the wider church. The early church cannot be romanticized, because even the New Testament records division and the human tendency to create factions.

The eldership exists for the flock, not for men seeking power. Elders labor among God’s people, keep watch over souls, and will give an account to God for how they shepherded those entrusted to them. Christ gives elders as a gift so that the church will not try to dig life’s hole alone with its own forks. Christ remains the true Shepherd, and elders serve rightly when they point every soul back to Him.

##

Key Takeaways

1. Christ alone heads the church [42:08] Christ is not one authority among several competing authorities. Christ stands over every earthly role, structure, and preference within the church. Human leadership remains healthy only when it openly submits to His headship. Any structure that makes human wisdom final has already moved away from its true center. [42:08]
2. Small changes can carry far [40:52] The ship one degree off course does not look lost at the beginning. The danger comes through time, because small changes slowly become a different destination. Scripture calls the church to keep checking its compass rather than trusting familiarity, tradition, or usefulness. Faithfulness often means refusing the little adjustments that feel harmless. [40:52]
3. Elders serve as a plurality [45:22] The New Testament consistently shows elders, plural, in each local congregation. Plurality guards against the pride, pressure, and unchecked opinions that can gather around one man. Shared shepherding calls men to labor together under Christ rather than acting as though any one of them is the head. [45:22]
4. Elders watch over eternal souls [58:34] Elders carry more than organizational responsibility. Hebrews says they keep watch over souls and must give an account, which makes their work weighty and deeply personal. The flock should not treat such care casually, because godly oversight is one of Christ’s provisions for leading His people toward maturity. [58:34]
5. The flock must not ignore God’s shovel [01:01:31] God’s gift of elders is not meant to sit off to the side while Christians attempt to live alone. Submission, encouragement, prayer, and honest openness allow shepherds to do the work God has given them. Christ’s care often comes through the ordinary, sacrificial presence of men who are willing to bear responsibility for the flock.

## [61:31]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[37:27] - Gratitude for Servants and New Elder
[38:21] - God’s Shovel and Human Forks
[40:52] - One Degree Off Course
[42:08] - Christ Is Head of the Church
[43:27] - The Apostolic Pattern of Elders
[45:22] - Why a Plurality of Elders Matters
[46:58] - Elder, Overseer, Shepherd, Pastor
[48:40] - What Scripture Does Not Establish
[50:47] - Historical Departures From the Pattern
[57:04] - Eldership Given for the Flock
[58:34] - Elders Give an Account for Souls
[60:48] - Submit to Christ Through Godly Shepherding
[62:04] - Christ the True Shepherd

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading

Acts 20:17-28
“Now from Miletus he sent to Ephesus and called the elders of the church to come to him. And when they came to him, he said to them: “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood.” [48:04]

Hebrews 13:17
“Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls, as those who will have to give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with groaning, for that would be of no advantage to you.” [58:34]

1 Thessalonians 5:12-13
“We ask you, brothers, to respect those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord and admonish you, and to esteem them very highly in love because of their work. Be at peace among yourselves.” [58:33]

Observation questions

In Acts 20:17–28, what three descriptions are used for the same group of church leaders, and what does each description show about their work? [48:04]
What repeated pattern does the New Testament show regarding elders in local churches: one elder or elders serving together? [45:22]
According to 1 Thessalonians 5:12–13, what kinds of work do those who lead in the Lord do among the congregation?
In Hebrews 13:17, what responsibility do leaders carry for the people they shepherd, and how are believers told to respond?

Interpretation questions

Why does Acts 20 connect being an elder, an overseer, and a shepherd rather than treating them as separate levels of authority? What does this protect the church from? [48:14]
Hebrews 13:17 says leaders keep watch over souls and will give an account. What does this suggest that faithful oversight should look like beyond making organizational decisions? [59:47]
Why might a plurality of elders be wiser and safer than placing the direction of a congregation in the hands of one person? [46:14]
How does Christ’s position as head of the church shape the proper limits of every human leader’s authority? [42:39]

Application questions

Where might personal preferences, past experiences, or familiar traditions tempt someone to place human wisdom above Christ’s leadership? What would it look like to return to Scripture as the compass? [43:05]
Small changes can move a ship far from its destination over time. Are there any small compromises in a believer’s life, relationships, or view of church that may seem harmless now but could lead away from Christ over time? [40:52]
In what ways can group members make it easier for elders to shepherd with joy rather than with groaning—especially through prayer, encouragement, honesty, and a willingness to receive correction? [01:01:31]
When someone is facing a spiritual struggle, a family burden, or a hard decision, what might keep that person from seeking the care of godly shepherds? What could help them take that step? [01:01:42]
How can believers show genuine respect and love for elders without treating them as if they are the head of the church? [58:18]
Christ is the true Shepherd, and elders serve by pointing people to Him. What is one practical way each person can keep Christ—not a personality, leader, or preference—at the center of their faith this week? [01:02:04]

Sermon Clips

38s

#EldershipIsGodsGift

“What they do isn't for them, it is for us. They are taking eternal consequences for their actions. Right? Or their their their an eternal responsibility, I'll say, for for their actions for our sake so that we can be led to become more like Christ. The eldership is God's gift to us, to help us live like Christ. It is our shovel so that we can live like God wants us to live, and they can help guide us into to being like that. God gave us a shovel, so let's not look around for forks.”

31s

#ChristTheTrueShepherd

“And in everything, remember that Christ is the true shepherd. Christ is the shepherd of our souls and of the souls of the elders. He is the shepherd of the church. He is the head of the church, and it is our lifelong goal to submit to his leadership above all. And the elder's primary role is to point us to him and to help us live like him. And that is your encouragement today.”

36s

#SupportYourElders

“And so it is our duty then to seek their guidance, to submit to them, to encourage them, to pray for them, to help them. But most importantly, don't ignore them. God has given you a shuffle. Don't leave it off to the side and say, can dig this hole on my own. I can live this life on my own. If these men are are giving up their their time and and their life to to to shepherd you well, allow them to be your shepherds. And come to them and encourage them and love them and pray for them and help them and submit to them.”

Ask a question about this sermon

Erie Church of Christ This sermon · AI assistant

What is God’s pattern for local church leadership?

Why does plurality matter among church elders?

How should believers respond to their elders?