Rejecting Cheap Grace: Baptism as New Life

Devotional

Day 1: When Assassins Choose Costly Grace Over Cheap Escape

A failed plot to kill Hitler cost Dietrich Bonhoeffer his life, yet his legacy exposes our temptation to seek painless faith. True discipleship means returning to the fire rather than hiding in safety. Grace becomes cheap when we treat forgiveness as permission to avoid hard choices. The cross demands we count the cost of aligning with Christ’s mission, even when systems of power rage against it. Bonhoeffer’s hanged body testifies: faith without sacrifice is hollow. [26:50]

“What shall we say then? Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it? Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death?” (Romans 6:1-3, ESV)

Reflection: What comfortable escape have you chosen recently to avoid Christ’s costly call? How might Bonhoeffer’s choice to return to Nazi Germany challenge your next compromise?

Day 2: Drowning the Old Self in Baptism’s Waters

Baptism isn’t a decorative sprinkle but a violent drowning. Presbyterians heave the font before congregations as a funeral for the selfish soul. This sacrament kills the parts of us that hoard resources, ignore the oppressed, or excuse petty cruelties. Like infants submerged, we emerge gasping for the Spirit’s breath to live differently. The water leaves us accountable – to God, to godparents, to the child who’ll ask why our lives don’t match our vows. [32:08]

“We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life. For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his.” (Romans 6:4-5, ESV)

Reflection: What specific attitude or habit needs metaphorical drowning in your baptismal waters today? Who holds you accountable to this resurrection life?

Day 3: The Congregation’s Weighty Promise at the Font

When a squirming infant gets baptized, the congregation inherits a dangerous promise. They vow to answer the child’s theological questions, confront their own complicity if the child strays, and model costly grace. This isn’t individual spirituality but communal warfare against cheap grace. Every Amelia, Harper, and Smith in the pews becomes the church’s shared responsibility – a check against privatized faith that ignores the hungry or excuses injustice. [32:49]

“Whoever receives one such child in my name receives me, but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea.” (Matthew 18:5-6, ESV)

Reflection: Which “child” in your faith community needs you to fulfill your baptismal promises this week? How does their presence disrupt your convenient excuses?

Day 4: Cheap Grace’s Empty Plate vs. Costly Grace’s Feast

Cheap grace gorges on forgiveness without chewing repentance. It’s communion without confessing stolen wages, baptism without dismantling racism, absolution without restoring broken relationships. Costly grace starves the ego to feed the neighbor. It’s Bonhoeffer trading a safe New York pulpit for a Nazi noose, Jesus trading heaven’s throne for a criminal’s cross. One leaves us bloated with entitlement; the other nourishes true freedom through surrender. [27:27]

“Whoever does not bear his own cross and come after me cannot be my disciple. For which of you, desiring to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, whether he has enough to complete it?” (Luke 14:27-28, ESV)

Reflection: Where have you been feasting on cheap grace’s empty calories? What cross-shaped choice would nourish your discipleship today?

Day 5: Sparrows, Strangers, and the God Who Numbers Hairs

Jesus insists sparrows matter despite their market value – and so do the relatives we avoid, the neighbors who vote oppositely, the strangers we deem unworthy. Costly grace refuses to dehumanize even the Hitlers, trusting God’s justice over our vengeance. When we dismiss others as “worthless sparrows,” we mock the God who numbers their hairs and dies for their redemption. Our baptismal life means seeing all as font-washed kin. [37:42]

“Are not two sparrows sold for a penny? And not one of them will fall to the ground apart from your Father. But even the hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not, therefore; you are of more value than many sparrows.” (Matthew 10:29-31, ESV)

Reflection: Who have you reduced to a “sparrow” – disposable, irritating, or unworthy? How might costly grace transform your next interaction with them?

Sermon Summary

Paul will not let sin be treated like a toy. When the hypothetical lands that sin could be costless, Paul answers with his stubborn phrase, by no means, because baptism has already put sin in the grave. Romans speaks as a grown-up word to grown-up saints, not skim milk for babies. Grace is not a permission slip. Jesus did not live, die, and rise so that anyone could do whatever they want and hide behind a thin religious blanket.

Bonhoeffer names the blanket cheap grace. Cheap grace sounds like forgiveness without repentance, communion without confession, absolution without owning anything, grace without Jesus Christ living and incarnate. Costly grace, by contrast, gives life. It condemns sin and justifies the sinner because it is God’s own movement toward humanity in the flesh. The question is not whether God is gracious. The question is whether disciples desire what crucified love desires.

A bad caricature of predestination pretends that conduct does not matter. Romans gets cherry picked into a get-out-of-jail-free card, even though the long argument ends with God’s wise choosing and human repentance. God chooses, but sin still requires turning. Grace does not erase consequences, and following a crucified Lord never promised a life free of pain. The cross stands as the pattern, so a clear conscience about harming others is off the table.

Baptism speaks by drowning. The font announces a figurative death to the old self and a rising into newness of life. The whole congregation promises to raise the newly washed into faithful discipleship, the god mamas and god papas ready to field thorny questions and give timely hugs. Baptism happens once, and its efficacy rests on the Holy Spirit, that feisty dove. Even if the baptizer fails, the Spirit does not.

Membership and ordination re-say the same renunciation. Being buried with Christ means walking in a new creation. Shortcuts tempt, but faith’s work cannot be accomplished alone. With God’s help, disciples learn to want what Christ wants, which rules out sin that wounds a neighbor and calls it unchristian because it is cheap grace dressed up for church.

Jesus also tells hard truth about divisions. Homes split, conversations freeze, friends become former friends. Yet the Father values children more than sparrows, and that worth lands on all y’all. The task is to recognize one’s own worth and the God-given worth of every neighbor, then act out of discipleship, welcoming and living the new life that baptism signposts. Costly grace becomes a way of life, not a loophole.

Key Takeaways

1. Cheap grace hollows out the gospel. Cheap grace offers forgiveness without repentance and sacraments without confession. It strips grace from the crucified and risen Christ and turns it into spiritual store credit. Bonhoeffer names it as the quiet enemy of discipleship because it excuses harm. Costly grace, rooted in the Incarnation, condemns sin while giving true life. [27:27]
2. Baptism drowns the old self. Baptism is a figurative death to sin and a rising into newness of life. The Spirit, not human hands, makes it efficacious, which is why even a flawed minister cannot undo it. The congregation’s vows bind a community to nurture that new life, god mamas and god papas included. The font marks a crucifixion of the former self so a disciple can walk free. [32:08]
3. Real discipleship keeps company with suffering. Paul refuses baby milk theology that promises an easy road. The Savior’s whole mission drew opposition and ended in a criminal’s death, so following him will never mean consequence-free choices. Grace forgives, but it also trains a conscience, which is why sin with a clear conscience is a nonstarter. The cross is the pattern, not an escape hatch. [31:32]
4. Every neighbor bears costly worth. Jesus names family fractures and aching distances, then points to sparrows to recalibrate value. God counts and keeps, which establishes both personal worth and the dignity of all y’all. Discipleship answers by welcoming, honoring, and choosing the new-creation life baptism announces. Cheap grace divides and uses, while costly grace attends and builds. [37:23]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[25:58] - The trick question about sin
[26:31] - Bonhoeffer and costly choices
[27:27] - Cheap grace defined and denied
[29:32] - Predestination caricature corrected
[30:31] - God chooses, repentance required
[31:32] - Suffering and consequences of faith
[31:52] - By no means to sin
[32:08] - Baptism as death to sin
[32:49] - Vows and communal responsibility
[33:56] - The Spirit makes baptism efficacious
[34:43] - Buried with Christ, newness of life
[36:57] - Divisions named, worth affirmed
[38:10] - Live through costly grace

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading
- Romans 6:4 (ESV): "We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life."
- Matthew 10:34-39 (ESV): "Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword..."
- Luke 12:6-7 (ESV): "Are not five sparrows sold for two pennies? And not one of them is forgotten before God. Why, even the hairs of your head are all numbered..."

Observation questions

According to Romans 6:4, what does baptism symbolize, and what is its purpose?
In the sermon, how does Bonhoeffer define "cheap grace"? What examples does he give? [27:27]
What does Jesus say about sparrows in Luke 12:6-7, and how does the sermon connect this to human worth? [37:23]
How does the sermon describe the congregation’s role in baptism? What vows do they take? [32:49]

Interpretation questions

Why does Paul link baptism to both death and "newness of life" in Romans 6:4? How might this contrast shape a Christian’s daily choices?
The sermon argues that "sin with a clear conscience is a nonstarter." How does costly grace challenge the idea of using grace as a "loophole" for harmful behavior? [31:52]
Jesus says he brings "not peace, but a sword" (Matthew 10:34). How might discipleship create divisions, and why does the sermon still call this "costly grace"? [36:57]
Why does the sermon emphasize that baptism’s efficacy depends on the Holy Spirit, not human actions? What does this mean for how we view failures in the church? [33:56]

Application questions

Where have you seen "cheap grace" show up in your own life or community (e.g., avoiding repentance, minimizing harm)? What practical step could help move toward costly grace instead?
Baptism vows include communal responsibility. Who in your life needs "thorny questions answered" or "timely hugs" as they grow in faith? How could you actively support them this week? [33:18]
Jesus says discipleship may strain relationships. Is there a situation where choosing faithfulness feels like it might cause division? How can you honor both truth and love in that tension?
The sermon says, "Grace forgives, but it also trains a conscience." What habit or attitude have you excused as "not a big deal" that actually harms your neighbor? What would repentance look like here? [31:32]
How does recognizing your "God-given worth" (as more valued than sparrows) change the way you interact with people you find difficult or disagree with? [37:42]
The cross is called "the pattern, not an escape hatch." What current challenge in your life might require embracing suffering rather than avoiding it?

Sermon Clips

89s

#WelcomingWorth

“``How many of us have a relative that we cannot bear to sit down with and have a conversation? Dear friends, former friends, neighbors that we just avoid, Jesus reminds us that this is nothing new. It is as old as humanity. Jesus also reminds us that we are more valuable to God than a couple common sparrows, which many would consider worthless. Our task is to recognize not only our own worthiness, which is hard enough sometimes, but the worthiness and the godliness of all god's children, which is all y'all. All. All. All. To act out of discipleship, welcoming and living into the new life and new creation that we become as a result of our baptism, but even more because it's the model that Jesus gives us. We live through costly grace, and we reject cheap grace.”

79s

#AllAreValued

“Dear friends, former friends, neighbors that we just avoid, Jesus reminds us that this is nothing new. It is as old as humanity. Jesus also reminds us that we are more valuable to God than a couple common sparrows, which many would consider worthless. Our task is to recognize not only our own worthiness, which is hard enough sometimes, but the worthiness and the godliness of all god's children, which is all y'all. All. All. All. To act out of discipleship, welcoming and living into the new life and new creation that we become as a result of our baptism, but even more because it's the model that Jesus gives us. We live through costly grace, and we reject cheap grace.”

64s

#MatureFaith

“But I hear you saying in your May in your brains, if Luke says we must forgive 77 times, well, why won't God forgive us endlessly no matter what we do? is there grace if it doesn't hold true in every single situation? And Paul retorts, you all are full grown adults. Why are you trying to drink baby milk as your scriptural understanding? Why do you believe that your life should be free and clear of any pain, any consequences when the savior you claim to follow was hounded during the entirety of his mission and died a gruesome criminal's death at the hands of those in charge. So you could sin with a clear conscience, to quote Paul again, by no means.”

89s

#WalkInFaithTogether

“That is the work of the holy spirit, and we never ever ever undercut that feisty dove. So Paul reminds us, if we are baptized, we have already renounced sin. And, of course, when we become a member of a congregation or when we are ordained as an officer, we restate our firm resolve to renounce sin and its power over our lives because we have been buried with Jesus Christ by baptism into a death like his so that just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the father, we too might walk in newness of life. Theologian Windy Corbin Ruchling calls baptism a crucifixion of our old self. In other words, again, a metaphorical death. Or as another theologian put it, in our least enlightened moments, we all look for shortcuts. Ouch. We know we can never accomplish our faith work on our own. We can only walk in faith with god's help.”

Ask a question about this sermon

First Presbyterian Church of Buffalo This sermon · AI assistant

What distinguishes cheap grace from costly grace?

How does baptism function as symbolic crucifixion?

When is forgiveness bounded by repentance and consequences?

Rejecting Cheap Grace: Baptism as New Life

Devotional

Day 1: When Assassins Choose Costly Grace Over Cheap Escape

Day 2: Drowning the Old Self in Baptism’s Waters

Day 3: The Congregation’s Weighty Promise at the Font

Day 4: Cheap Grace’s Empty Plate vs. Costly Grace’s Feast

Day 5: Sparrows, Strangers, and the God Who Numbers Hairs

Sermon Summary

Key Takeaways

Youtube Chapters

Bible Study Guide

Sermon Clips

Rejecting Cheap Grace: Baptism as New Life

Share