Building Meaningful Relationships Through Disagreement and Love

Devotional

Day 1: Christ Is All That Matters

In a world filled with differences—backgrounds, beliefs, and opinions—what truly unites us is not our sameness but the presence of Christ in each of us. The Apostle Paul reminds us that, above all the things we think are important, Jesus is the only thing that ultimately matters. When we focus on Christ as our foundation, we can move beyond the surface-level facts and opinions that often divide us and instead build deeper, more meaningful relationships. Letting Jesus be the center allows us to see others through His eyes, recognizing that every person, regardless of their views or history, is loved by God and carries His image. [18:07]

Colossians 3:11 (ESV)
"Here there is not Greek and Jew, circumcised and uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave, free; but Christ is all, and in all."

Reflection: Who in your life do you find it hardest to see as “Christ in all”? How might focusing on Jesus as the only thing that matters change the way you relate to them today?

Day 2: Clothe Yourself with Mercy, Kindness, Humility, Gentleness, and Patience

Living in harmony with people who are different from us is not something that comes naturally; it requires intentionality. Paul urges us to “clothe” ourselves with mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience—qualities that don’t just happen but must be put on daily, especially when we encounter disagreement or offense. This kind of love is sacrificial, not sentimental, and it mirrors the way Jesus loves us: forgiving, patient, and always seeking the good of the other. When we choose to put on these virtues, we create space for real community and reflect the heart of Christ to those around us. [24:01]

Colossians 3:12-14 (ESV)
"Put on then, as God's chosen ones, holy and beloved, compassionate hearts, kindness, humility, meekness, and patience, bearing with one another and, if one has a complaint against another, forgiving each other; as the Lord has forgiven you, so you also must forgive. And above all these put on love, which binds everything together in perfect harmony."

Reflection: What is one practical way you can “put on” kindness or patience with someone you disagree with this week?

Day 3: Iron Sharpens Iron—Growth Through Disagreement

It’s tempting to surround ourselves only with those who agree with us, but true growth happens when we allow ourselves to be challenged by differing perspectives. Just as iron sharpens iron, healthy relationships require friction and even contradiction to help us grow stronger and wiser. Avoiding disagreement may feel safer, but it actually stunts our development and makes us more fragile. Embracing respectful disagreement, rather than canceling or insulating ourselves, leads to deeper relationships and personal maturity. [11:06]

Proverbs 27:17 (ESV)
"Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another."

Reflection: Think of a recent disagreement you’ve had—how might you approach it as an opportunity for growth rather than something to avoid or resent?

Day 4: Be Quick to Listen, Slow to Speak, Slow to Anger

In a culture where everyone is quick to share their opinions and slow to listen, James’ wisdom is more relevant than ever. Being quick to listen and slow to speak allows us to truly understand others, even when we disagree. When we feel our emotions rising, especially anger, it’s a signal to pause and listen more deeply rather than react. This posture not only diffuses conflict but also opens the door to genuine connection and understanding, reflecting the humility and patience that Jesus calls us to embody. [35:20]

James 1:19-20 (ESV)
"Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger; for the anger of man does not produce the righteousness of God."

Reflection: When was the last time you truly listened to someone you disagreed with? What would it look like to be “quick to listen” in your next difficult conversation?

Day 5: Move from Insulation to Intentional Diversity

It’s easy and comfortable to insulate ourselves from those who are different, but God calls us to intentionally seek out relationships with people from diverse backgrounds, experiences, and beliefs. This diversity can be messy and challenging, but it is also beautiful and necessary for a healthy, vibrant community. When we move beyond isolation and independence to interdependence and diversity, we reflect the unity and love of Christ, building a culture where everyone is valued and included. [38:59]

Romans 12:16 (ESV)
"Live in harmony with one another. Do not be haughty, but associate with the lowly. Never be wise in your own sight."

Reflection: What is one step you can take this week to intentionally connect with someone whose background or perspective is different from your own?

Sermon Summary

Today’s focus is on the challenge and necessity of building meaningful relationships with people who are different from us—especially those with whom we disagree. In a culture that increasingly encourages isolation, independence, and insulation from opposing views, it’s easy to fall into the trap of only surrounding ourselves with those who think, vote, and believe like we do. But this is not the way of Jesus, nor is it healthy for us as individuals or as a church community. True growth—spiritually, emotionally, and relationally—comes not from avoiding disagreement, but from engaging with it in a Christlike manner.

We live in a world where algorithms and social pressures push us into echo chambers, making it feel safer and simpler to “cancel” or unfriend those who challenge our perspectives. Yet, this only leads to shallow relationships and stunted personal growth. Scripture and even modern science affirm that it is through “iron sharpening iron”—through the friction of differing views—that we are refined and strengthened. The Apostle Paul, writing to a diverse and conflicted church, reminds us that in Christ, our differences are secondary: “Christ is all that matters, and he lives in all of us.” This foundational truth should shape how we approach every relationship.

To move toward deeper, healthier relationships, three practical steps are essential. First, be clear about what is foundational—what truly matters is Jesus, and every person is made in God’s image. Second, be curious about others’ perspectives, asking questions and seeking to understand rather than to win arguments. Third, be cautious with your own emotions, recognizing that our first instinct is often to judge or defend, but Christ calls us to humility, patience, and sacrificial love. When we clothe ourselves with mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience—even toward those we disagree with—we reflect the heart of Jesus and experience the peace that only he can give.

Key Takeaways

1. Isolation, Independence, and Insulation Hinder Growth Our culture pushes us toward isolation (being alone), independence (doing life on our own), and insulation (removing differing voices). While these may feel safe, they actually harm us spiritually, emotionally, and relationally. God designed us for interdependence, where we are challenged and supported by others, even those who see the world differently. [07:19]
2. Disagreement is Essential for Maturity Filtering out all disagreement may feel comfortable, but it leads to simple-mindedness and stagnation. Challenging contradictions—when handled with humility—are catalysts for growth. Scripture’s “iron sharpens iron” metaphor reminds us that friction and difference are necessary for sharpening our character and faith. [11:06]
3. Jesus is the Only True Foundation We all hold a mix of facts, opinions, and feelings, but only a few things are truly foundational. Paul teaches that “Christ is all that matters,” and this truth should be the lens through which we view every relationship and disagreement. When Jesus is central, our differences become opportunities for grace rather than division. [18:07]
4. Clothe Yourself with Sacrificial Love and Humility Mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience are not natural; they must be intentionally “put on” each day, especially with those who offend or disagree with us. The New Testament model of love is sacrificial, not sentimental—giving up our preferences for the sake of others, just as Christ did for us. [25:31]
5. Be Clear, Curious, and Cautious in Difficult Relationships Healthy engagement with those who differ from us requires clarity about what is foundational, curiosity about others’ stories and beliefs, and caution with our own emotions. Instead of assuming something is wrong with others, we should first examine our own hearts, seeking to listen, understand, and reflect Christ’s love in every interaction. [37:24]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[01:42] - The Tension of Disagreement
[04:17] - Barriers to Meaningful Relationships
[07:19] - The Dangers of Insulation and Cancel Culture
[09:33] - Isolating Ourselves from Different Views
[11:06] - The Value of Challenging Contradiction
[13:37] - Paul’s Words to a Divided Church
[16:04] - Three Types of Beliefs: Facts, Opinions, Feelings
[18:07] - Christ is All That Matters
[19:31] - Depth in Relationships: Moving Beyond Small Talk
[21:00] - The Fragility of Insulated Generations
[22:33] - The Church and the Way of Jesus
[24:01] - Clothing Ourselves with Mercy and Patience
[25:31] - Sacrificial Love and True Harmony
[27:17] - The Promise of Christ’s Peace
[29:19] - Three Practical Keys: Clear, Curious, Cautious
[32:21] - Getting Close to Those Who Differ
[35:20] - Quick to Listen, Slow to Speak
[37:24] - Examining Our Own Hearts
[38:59] - Embracing Diversity in Community
[40:11] - Viewing All Relationships Through Jesus
[41:14] - Closing Prayer and Next Steps

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading

Colossians 3:11-14 (ESV) — > Here there is not Greek and Jew, circumcised and uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave, free; but Christ is all, and in all.
> Put on then, as God's chosen ones, holy and beloved, compassionate hearts, kindness, humility, meekness, and patience,
> bearing with one another and, if one has a complaint against another, forgiving each other; as the Lord has forgiven you, so you also must forgive.
> And above all these put on love, which binds everything together in perfect harmony.

Proverbs 27:17 (ESV) — > Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another.

James 1:19 (ESV) — > Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger.

Observation Questions

In Colossians 3:11, what kinds of differences does Paul mention, and what does he say is most important?
According to Proverbs 27:17, what is the result of “iron sharpening iron”?
In James 1:19, what three actions does James tell believers to take when interacting with others?
The sermon described three barriers to meaningful relationships: isolation, independence, and insulation. What do each of these look like in everyday life? [[04:17]]

Interpretation Questions

Why do you think Paul emphasizes that “Christ is all, and in all” when talking to a church with lots of differences? How does this change the way we see people who disagree with us? [[18:07]]
The sermon said that disagreement is actually essential for maturity and growth. Why might avoiding disagreement lead to “simple-mindedness” or shallow relationships? [[11:06]]
What does it mean to “clothe yourself” with mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience? Why do you think Paul uses the image of putting on clothes? [[24:01]]
The sermon talked about being “clear, curious, and cautious” in difficult relationships. What does it look like to be curious about someone’s perspective instead of just trying to win an argument? [[31:17]]

Application Questions

Think about your closest friends and family. Do most of them think and believe the same way you do? If so, what might be missing from your relationships because of that? [[09:33]]
When was the last time you had a real disagreement with someone? How did you respond—did you listen, defend, judge, or withdraw? What would it look like to handle it in a “Christlike manner” next time? [[13:37]]
The sermon challenged us to be “clear” about what is foundational—namely, that Jesus is all that matters and every person is made in God’s image. How can you remind yourself of this truth when you’re frustrated or offended by someone? [[30:30]]
“Be curious” was the second practical step. Can you think of a person you disagree with? What is one question you could ask them this week to better understand their perspective? [[31:17]]
The third step was to “be cautious” with your own emotions. What are some warning signs that you’re letting anger or pride take over in a conversation? What could you do to pause and reset in those moments? [[36:47]]
Paul says to “make allowance for each other’s faults” and to forgive as the Lord forgave you. Is there someone you need to forgive or show more patience toward right now? What’s one step you could take this week? [[24:01]]
The sermon said that when we “clothe ourselves” with sacrificial love, we reflect the heart of Jesus and experience his peace. What is one practical way you can show sacrificial love to someone you disagree with this week? [[25:31]]

Sermon Clips

We are seeing this more and more in our culture and unfortunately, it's creeping into the church. In fact, I feel like it's actually more in the church. It might be more in the church today than it even is outside the walls of the church. We send these messages to people like, hey, if you don't believe exactly what we believe, if you don't believe the same thing we believe on any of those hot button topics that's on the screen, if you don't believe what we believe, if you don't believe what we believe about scripture, hit the road, get on out of here. You're not welcome here. We don't welcome questions and doubts and disagreement around here. Can I just say that is the way of culture? That is the way of culture. That is not the way of Jesus. It's just not. [00:22:33] (49 seconds) #GraceForFaults

The way of love in the New Testament was one of sacrifice. giving up your own self, giving up your own preferences, giving up what you want for the other person. Just like Jesus sacrificed for us in the ultimate expression of love that has ever happened. He sacrificed himself and that was not gooey, mushy stuff. It was bloody. It was gory. It was not soft. Paul's like, I want you to approach other people with that kind of love, with sacrificial love, choosing to sacrifice on your end, even if they're wrong. [00:26:04] (32 seconds) #JesusRulesOurHearts

Process everything in your life through the lens of Jesus. Here's a fun fact that you can process through the lens of Jesus. Anytime you see somebody that you disagree with, and it's a challenging conversation, maybe it's a family member, maybe it's a friend on social media or whatever. Anytime you see somebody you disagree with, here's a fact. That person, just as we talked about in week one, was also made in the image of God. And therefore, they matter to God just as much as you do. [00:30:21] (31 seconds) #ListenMoreSpeakLess

What if instead we trained ourselves? What if you trained yourself and I trained myself for our first instinct to be, hey, something's wrong with me. Why in the world would you go and do that? Why in the world would you go believe that? What if instead we went, you know what? I'm broken. I'm messed up. I'm flawed. I'm imperfect. I don't know everything. Everything that I think I know is not necessarily a fact. My feelings are not necessarily perfect. My emotions are not necessarily perfect. [00:37:45] (35 seconds)

There will always be people in your life that you disagree with. It's just a fact of life. And I'm not talking about the big ones. I'm not talking about, you know, Trump and Biden and, you know, factions and groups of people that you disagree with. I'm not talking about that. There will always be people that you disagree with. It's your neighbor across the street or next door, somebody in this room. It might be a parent, maybe a spouse, maybe some things that you disagree with when it comes to your spouse, somebody that you work with, a coworker. Our job, as Paul says, is to view all of those relationships through the lens of Jesus. He is the only thing that matters through the lens of Jesus who loved you and forgave you, even when you disagreed with him. That's how we follow Jesus. And that's how we build a culture of meaningful relationships with one another. [00:40:23] (59 seconds)

Ask a question about this sermon

Chatbot

What does it mean to build meaningful relationships?

How can disagreement deepen spiritual growth?

Why is curiosity vital in challenging relationships?