John 3:5 presses a question that cannot be treated like a small disagreement: What must happen for a sinner to enter the kingdom of God? Jesus tells Nicodemus that no one can even see the kingdom unless he is born again, literally born from above. Jesus then says that no one can enter unless he is born of water and Spirit. The requirement is not religious effort, church membership, a walk down an aisle, or somebody else assuring a person that he is fine. The requirement is a supernatural birth from God.
The controversy comes from the meaning assigned to “water and Spirit.” Baptismal regeneration makes water baptism the instrumental means of regeneration, whether fully or in part. Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and other traditions plainly connect baptism with being purified, justified, sanctified, reborn, and brought into eternal life. Those claims cannot be treated as basically the same gospel as justification by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone. A gospel that rests final confidence on what happens at a baptismal font leaves sinners asking, “Did I do it right? Did I do it enough?”
Jesus’ words point instead to one work described with two terms. The grammar joins water and Spirit under one preposition, much like “safe and sound” or “short and sweet” names one reality with two words. The flow of the conversation also demands a birth from above, not physical birth plus spiritual birth, and not a Christian sacrament that had not yet been instituted. Jesus rebukes Nicodemus because Nicodemus, as the teacher of Israel, should have recognized the Old Testament promise.
Ezekiel 36 supplies the clearest backdrop. God promises, “I will sprinkle clean water on you,” give a new heart, remove the heart of stone, and put His Spirit within His people. Water imagery names God’s cleansing work, while the Spirit gives life and causes obedience. Joel likewise speaks of God pouring out His Spirit, and Acts 10 shows the Holy Spirit falling on Cornelius and the Gentiles before they receive water baptism. Baptism follows the Spirit’s regenerating work; it does not produce it.
The Spirit’s work turns idolaters such as Abraham, persecutors such as Paul, and dead sinners like Lazarus into people who hear Christ’s call and live. Christ calls dead men from tombs, and dead men come because His power gives what His command requires. Faith comes by hearing the word of Christ because God opens hearts to receive the gospel. Confidence, then, rests not in what sinners have done, but in Christ’s perfect life, substitutionary death, victorious resurrection, and the Spirit’s work of making sinners see and trust Him.
Key Takeaways
- 1. New birth is absolutely necessary
Jesus does not present regeneration as an advanced step for especially serious Christians. Jesus makes birth from above the nonnegotiable requirement for seeing and entering God’s kingdom. Religious knowledge did not spare Nicodemus from this need, and religious activity cannot replace it. The heart must be made new by God. [56:51]
- 2. Water and Spirit name God’s cleansing
Ezekiel’s promise places the action entirely in God’s hands: “I will cleanse,” “I will give,” and “I will put my Spirit within you.” Water imagery does not make salvation a ritual that sinners manage. Water imagery displays the thorough cleansing God performs when He removes a heart of stone and gives a heart that desires His ways. [1:10:35]
- 3. Baptism follows regeneration, not creates it
Cornelius and his household received the Holy Spirit while hearing the gospel, before they were baptized. Peter recognized that God had already given them what baptism could never manufacture. Baptism matters as obedience and testimony, but it cannot bear the weight of being the source of new life. [1:18:40]
- 4. Confidence rests in Christ’s finished work
The gospel does not ask sinners to trust a ceremony, a decision remembered from years ago, or the judgment of another person. Christ lived the life sinners could not live, bore the wrath sinners deserved, and rose victorious from the grave. Faith in that Christ is evidence that God has opened blind eyes and circumcised the heart. [1:26:39]
- 5. The gospel calls dead sinners to life
Lazarus could not cooperate his way out of the tomb before Christ spoke life-giving words. Christ’s command carried the power needed for Lazarus to rise and come out. The same reality gives hope in gospel proclamation, because God can awaken those who presently seem far beyond reach. [1:22:57]
Youtube Chapters
- [00:00] - Welcome
- [28:07] - John 3 and Nicodemus
- [31:21] - Born of Water and Spirit
- [33:10] - Why This Question Matters
- [34:45] - The Controversy Over Baptism
- [36:25] - The Claim of Baptismal Regeneration
- [40:31] - Roman Catholic Claims About Baptism
- [49:13] - Eastern Orthodox Claims About Baptism
- [54:46] - The Requirement for Entering the Kingdom
- [57:28] - What Water and Spirit Mean
- [1:00:32] - One Reality Described Two Ways
- [1:04:39] - Scripture Interprets Scripture
- [1:09:28] - Ezekiel’s Promise of a New Heart
- [1:14:21] - The Spirit Poured Out
- [1:17:12] - Cornelius Receives the Spirit Before Baptism
- [1:19:06] - Regeneration Through Gospel Preaching
- [1:22:15] - Lazarus and the Power of Christ’s Call
- [1:25:14] - Confidence in Christ Alone