The Abolition of Man | C.S. Lewis | A Summer with C.S. Lewis

Devotional

Day 1: The Chest Where Morality Meets

A plane crashes, leaving boys to choose between order and chaos. Like Lewis’ “chest” bridging head and belly, morality filters raw instinct and cold logic into virtuous action. Without this center, society becomes feral—impulsive or rigid, never balanced. The Christian life requires nurturing this “chest” through Scripture, prayer, and community to discern true good from selfish whims. Truth isn’t a feeling or formula but a compass planted deep within. [46:08]

“Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them.”
(Romans 2:14–15, ESV)

Reflection: Where have you recently felt tension between gut reactions and reasoned choices? How might nurturing your “chest” through prayer reshape your next moral decision?

Day 2: Conditioners and the Illusion of Freedom

Power-hungry “conditioners” promise liberation but impose their own rules, trading objective truth for control. Like the boys’ splintered tribes in Lord of the Flies, society fractures when leaders reject humility. Lewis warned that rejecting God’s morality doesn’t erase authority—it replaces divine truth with human tyranny. True freedom flourishes under Christ’s yoke, not the shifting demands of cultural influencers. [51:41]

“Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness, who put bitter for sweet and sweet for bitter!”
(Isaiah 5:20, ESV)

Reflection: What voices in your life claim to offer “freedom” while quietly demanding conformity? How does Scripture clarify their true agenda?

Day 3: Thermometers React, Thermostats Reset

A thermostat doesn’t just read the room—it changes it. Jesus calls believers to set the spiritual temperature through acts of love, not merely critique culture’s decay. Like fathers modeling integrity for their families, Christians must embody grace so vividly that others feel Christ’s warmth. Passive faith fades; active faith ignites. [01:04:59]

“Let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.”
(Matthew 5:16, ESV)

Reflection: Are you more prone to complain about the world’s coldness or to radiate Christ’s light? What one action could “reset the temperature” for someone this week?

Day 4: The Early Church’s Countercultural Harmony

The Acts 2 church didn’t erase differences—they anchored them in shared truth. Unlike Lennon’s “Imagine,” their unity came from submitting to Christ’s lordship, not abolishing boundaries. They proved that objective morality, lived in love, creates deeper community than any utopian fantasy. [01:09:26]

“All the believers were together and had everything in common. They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need. Every day they continued to meet together… praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people.”
(Acts 2:44–47, ESV)

Reflection: Where do you prioritize “living in harmony” over standing firm in truth? How might bold love disrupt superficial peace for eternal gain?

Day 5: Daniel’s Hope in the Midst of Chaos

An angel told Daniel wickedness would persist—but so would God’s promise. Like the stranded boys awaiting rescue, believers fix their eyes on Christ’s return, not the island’s chaos. Endurance isn’t passive; it’s planting seeds of truth in a world that may reject them until the Harvest. [01:00:18]

“Go your way, Daniel, for the words are shut up and sealed until the time of the end… But the wise shall understand.”
(Daniel 12:9–10, ESV)

Reflection: When has despair over cultural decay tempted you to silence? How does Christ’s certain return reframe your courage to speak truth today?

Sermon Summary

Lord of the Flies opens the door by showing what happens when young boys are left to their own devices with no adults, no guardrails, and no shared standard. The story starts with rules, a leader, a conch shell, and survival plans, but it slowly falls into madness because self interest takes over. The question underneath all of that is whether objective truth actually exists, whether there is one real standard of morality that people are meant to live by.

C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man takes that question seriously. The book warns that if objective morality gets removed, humanity may not disappear physically, but what it means to be fully human starts getting destroyed. The Green Book example matters because calling a waterfall “sublime” gets reduced to nothing more than personal feeling. Lewis sees the danger there, because courage, betrayal, beauty, and goodness cannot survive if every judgment is only “true for you” and never actually true.

The image of “men without chests” names the problem. The head represents intellect, the belly represents instinct and impulse, but the chest is where trained emotion, virtue, morality, and the soul sit. If people are taught only to think or only to feel, but never to love what is truly good, then society ends up expecting courage from people it has trained not to have any. The result is people who react, shame, pressure, and even hate, but do not know how to live rightly.

The Tao names the moral law that shows up across cultures. Promises should be kept. Murder is wrong. Cruelty for fun is evil. Even people who reject objective morality end up borrowing from it the moment someone wrongs them and they say, “That’s not fair.” Romans 2 says the same thing, because the law is written on human hearts, and conscience either accuses or defends.

The “conditioners” become dangerous because they reject objective truth but still want power to shape everyone else. In the name of freedom and self discovery, they end up saying, “Live your truth, unless your truth disagrees with mine.” That same spirit shows up politically, culturally, and personally, on both sides, wherever people stop seeing opponents as neighbors and start seeing them as enemies.

Daniel 12 gives patience in the middle of that chaos. Wickedness is gonna wicked, but God has not lost control. Jesus is coming, and the one who created truth and morality will purify the world. Until then, Christian witness is called to be more like a thermostat than a thermometer, setting the temperature through good works, love, discipleship, and the visible life of Jesus.

Key Takeaways

1. Truth cannot become personal property Truth stops being truth when it only belongs to the person saying it. “My truth” sounds freeing at first, but it quickly becomes a way to demand that everyone else bow to personal preference. Real truth stands over every person, including the one who wants to use it for control. [53:52]
2. Men without chests cannot stand The chest is the place where intellect and impulse are trained by virtue. A person can be smart and still be morally hollow, or passionate and still be spiritually dangerous. Courage, honor, and self control do not appear by accident. [46:45]
3. Conditioners become the system The conditioners claim to be tearing down oppressive standards, but they replace those standards with their own desires. When objective morality disappears, power does not disappear with it. Power simply moves into the hands of whoever can shape the room, the screen, the classroom, or the culture. [51:41]
4. Hope waits while wickedness continues Daniel is told that wickedness will keep going, which is not comforting in a shallow way. The comfort is deeper than quick relief, because God still gives an inheritance and still holds the end of the story. Patience grows when judgment and restoration are trusted to God rather than demanded on human terms. [60:18]
5. Faith sets the room’s temperature A thermometer only reports the atmosphere, but a thermostat changes it. Christian life is not meant to simply mirror the panic, anger, and confusion of the age. Faith becomes visible when good deeds, love, and discipleship create a different kind of environment for families, churches, and neighbors. [64:41]

Youtube Chapters

[00:00] - Welcome
[33:01] - Lord of the Flies and Human Nature
[36:23] - Questions About Truth and Morality
[38:38] - Introducing The Abolition of Man
[43:07] - The Green Book and the Waterfall
[45:08] - Men Without Chests
[47:19] - The Tao and Moral Law
[49:31] - Power, Nature, and the Conditioners
[53:29] - Living in a Relativistic Culture
[59:09] - Hope in a Wicked World
[61:11] - Romans 2 and the Law on Hearts
[63:01] - Light of the World
[64:41] - Thermometers, Thermostats, and Fathers
[68:51] - True Unity in Acts 2
[70:46] - Prayer and Response

Bible Study Guide

Bible Reading

Daniel 12:9-10
He said, “Go your way, Daniel, for the words are shut up and sealed until the time of the end. Many shall purify themselves and make themselves white and be refined, but the wicked shall act wickedly. And none of the wicked shall understand, but those who are wise shall understand.” [01:00:18]

Romans 2:14-15
For when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them [01:01:32]

Matthew 5:14-16
You are the light of the world. A city set on a hill cannot be hidden. Nor do people light a lamp and put it under a basket, but on a stand, and it gives light to all in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven. [01:03:24]

John 13:34-35
A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another: just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another. By this all people will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another. [01:03:01]

Acts 2:42-47
And they devoted themselves to the apostles' teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers. And awe came upon every soul, and many wonders and signs were being done through the apostles. And all who believed were together and had all things in common. And they were selling their possessions and belongings and distributing the proceeds to all, as any had need. And day by day, attending the temple together and breaking bread in their homes, they received their food with glad and generous hearts, praising God and having favor with all the people. And the Lord added to their number day by day those who were being saved. [01:09:09]

Observation questions

In Daniel 12:9-10, what two groups are described, and what is each group doing?
In Romans 2:14-15, what does Paul say conscience does, and what does that show about the human heart? [01:01:32]
In Matthew 5:14-16, what are believers compared to, and what are others supposed to see in them?
What examples were given of the “Tao” or moral law that people across cultures tend to recognize, even when they deny objective morality? [47:54]

Interpretation questions

If the wicked continue to act wickedly in Daniel 12:10, what kind of patience and steadiness does that call for in God’s people right now? [01:00:18]
Romans 2:14-15 says the work of the law is written on human hearts. How does that help explain why people still say things like “that’s not fair” even when they claim truth is only personal? [49:00]
Jesus says in John 13:34-35 that love among believers will make Him visible to the world. Why is love such a strong witness in a culture shaped by pressure, outrage, and division? [55:15]
Acts 2:42-47 shows a people devoted to teaching, fellowship, prayer, and generosity. Why does that kind of shared life offer a real picture of unity, while unity built only on slogans or self-expression falls apart? [01:09:45]

Application questions

Where is the pressure to say “my truth” or to treat truth like personal property showing up most in everyday life right now—at work, online, at school, or in family conversations? How has that pressure affected the way truth gets spoken about? [53:52]
The “chest” is where intellect and impulse are trained by virtue. In this season, is there a greater tendency to live from the head only, the gut only, or a trained heart that loves what is good? What would growth look like there? [46:45]
People often become most moralistic when they have been wronged. When something feels unfair, what does that reveal about what is already believed deep down about right and wrong? How could that moment become an opening for honest self-examination? [48:37]
A thermometer only reacts, but a thermostat helps set the room. In the places that matter most right now—home, friendships, church, workplace, online—what would it look like to bring a steadier, more Christlike temperature instead of just mirroring the mood around you? [01:04:41]
Jesus says the world should recognize His disciples by their love. What is one concrete way love could become more visible this week inside the church or among Christian friends, not just in words but in action? [01:03:01]
Acts 2 describes believers who shared meals, prayer, teaching, and resources. Which of those practices feels weakest in life right now, and what would be a realistic step toward deeper Christian community? [01:09:09]
Daniel 12 says wickedness will continue, yet God still holds the end of the story. Where is there a temptation to panic, rage, or despair over the state of the world? What would trusting God’s final justice change in that area this week? [01:00:18]

Sermon Clips

53s

“``So what ends up happening is that these conditioners, in the name of rejecting the imposed system, in in the name of rejecting the man, they actually become the system themselves. And so in order to maintain the power that they already have set up for themselves, they impose it on other people in disguise by saying, hey, like, we we have the best interest for you for your own self discovery. We want you to find yourself because it is about you. But if you don't end up agreeing with the way that we think that you should live your life, then you are in the wrong. And it doesn't allow for people to have an understanding for themselves, and instead, it makes people slaves to their own impulses, ultimately losing what true freedom actually is.”

62s

“Every human needs their virtue, their morality in order to have a better, more well thought out understanding of what reality even is. So then if we refrain from teaching people what objective truth is, then there is a gap between the head and the belly. As Lewis puts it, we make men without chests and expect virtue and enterprise, and this is a problem. We're essentially creating people who cannot function on their own because they were never taught how to see things objectively right or wrong, because there is no objective right or wrong. And then we wonder why they don't have any courage, why they don't have any honor, why people don't have any self control. It's because we act out of impulse rather or act purely out of reason and have no understanding of our reasoning or our emotion. And that only happens if you observe the world as subject to your own feelings and were never taught to understand what morality is.”

47s

“It's ultimately up to us to set the standard of what moral and objective truth, what moral living should look like. This was a there there's a visual or an illustration that I'd heard one time about, like, being a good influence to people. It goes like this. There's a difference between a thermometer and a thermostat. A thermometer reacts to the temperature of the room and tells you where things are at. A thermostat, on the other hand, sets the temperature of the room. A thermometer is told what to feel and then tells other people what it was told, and a thermostat is the one that determines the environment of the room.”

44s

“And, ultimately, when we find when we get to the presence of the creator for all eternity, when we are with him again in the new heaven and new earth, when we are worshiping him and giving him praise, that is where that true peace, that true unity will be found. And so in the meantime, as the world is wicked, we can know that example. We can strive to be that example that's given to us throughout scripture, ultimately being the example of Jesus to the rest of our world, and in doing so, bringing people into a relationship with him.”

Ask a question about this sermon

New Hope Community Church Clovis This sermon · AI assistant

Is there such a thing as objective morality?

What is meant by the Tao of morality?

How does a thermostat differ from a thermometer?